Photo: British Cartoon Prints Collection / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain

Allegedly True Paranormal Stories Revolving Around Christmas

Voting Rules
Vote up the scariest Yuletide tales.

When conjuring up stories of ghostly legends and paranormal encounters, the Christmas season isn't usually what comes to mind. With its tree-filled windows and light-strewn rooftops, Christmas is typically admired as a time for being with loved ones, giving heartfelt gifts, and snuggling up next to a warm fire with some hot cocoa. But what happens when something goes bump in the night and it isn't Santa Claus?

Christmas ghost stories are far more common than many people might expect. In fact, sharing ghost stories from years past was once a Christmas Eve tradition. So before you unwrap any presents, let these scary ghost stories help get you into the Christmas spirit.

Photo: British Cartoon Prints Collection / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain

  • 1
    702 VOTES

    The Legend Of The Mistletoe Bride Haunts England's Bramshill House

    The legend of the Mistletoe Bride has been retold for centuries and has taken many forms. While the story's true origin is difficult to determine, many have come to believe its roots are in the disappearance of Lord Lovell's bride at the Bramshill House in Hampshire, England.

    Allegedly, Lord Lovell was preparing to wed a young woman related to Sir John Cope, the owner of Bramshill House. This was around Christmastime, so mistletoe hung throughout the mansion, inspiring the wedding party to play a game. The young bride-to-be would hide somewhere in the mansion, the groomsmen would all seek her out, and whoever found her first would get to kiss her. So the bride went to hide, and the wedding party sought to find her. However, the minutes turned to hours, and they still could not find her. Eventually, the game turned terribly serious, as no matter where they looked, she remained missing.

    Not until 50 years later did Lord Lovell, still seeking answers to his bride's disappearance, happen upon a secret closet in an upstairs room of the Bramshill House. Inside, he found a wooden chest sealed shut with a lock. Upon opening the chest, he found the nearly unrecognizable remains of his bride.

    702 votes
  • The Brown Lady Of Raynham Hall Wanders The Passages Every Christmas
    Photo: Anonymous / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain
    470 VOTES

    The Brown Lady Of Raynham Hall Wanders The Passages Every Christmas

    The Brown Lady of Raynham Hall has perplexed visitors and paranormal investigators for hundreds of years. Back in the 1700s, owner Charles Townshend married a young woman named Dorothy Walpole. While they lived happily together for some time in Raynham Hall, Townshend soon became paranoid that his new wife was being unfaithful to him. Eventually driving himself mad with jealousy, he decided to hide Dorothy away in the hall, telling all of their friends and family that she had tragically passed.

    Dorothy was forced to stay inside the mansion, allowed only to wander through its halls. Not long after, she perished, never having left Raynham Hall after her husband imprisoned her. Ever since her passing, people have witnessed the image of a woman in a tattered brown dress wandering through the halls, and some of these reported encounters are truly horrifying. One visitor, unaware of the Brown Lady's legend, approached a woman in the hall, only to have her look at him "with a glowing face... but where her eyes should have been, there were only empty sockets."

    Years later, after numerous other reported sightings, a photographer from Country Life magazine visited Raynham Hall to document it for an article. After snapping a photograph of the central stairwell, he saw within the image a hazy silhouette that many believe is none other than Dorothy Walpole, the Brown Lady.

    470 votes
  • 3
    426 VOTES

    Alleged Phantoms Plagued A Brooklyn Home During Christmastime

    A few weeks before Christmas in 1878, Edward F. Smith was at his home in Brooklyn, NY, when the doorbell rang. He answered the door, but there was no one there. This soon became a nightly occurrence - the doorbell would ring, only for Smith to find no one outside and no signs that anyone had been there at all.

    Growing frustrated, Smith "sprinkled ash and flour along the path to the door, expecting to find footprints left behind, but the substances were undisturbed and the noises continued." No matter where he and his family stood around the house, the noises remained unidentifiable. Smith and his family were growing more concerned, as the doorbell ringing turned to aggressive banging on the doors. Eventually, they contacted the police.

    The ringing and banging continued, and still no one was able to identify its source. One night, a brick suddenly flew through the window from outside, even though police officers were standing nearby and saw no one. 

    Although they investigated the home for some time, police were unable to identify the cause of the disturbances. Smith and those who witnessed the strange occurrences ultimately concluded they must be paranormal in nature.

    426 votes
  • An Old Victorian House Is Allegedly Haunted By An Eccentric Woman Every Christmas
    Photo: Gilman Collection, Museum Purchase, 2005 / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain
    287 VOTES

    An Old Victorian House Is Allegedly Haunted By An Eccentric Woman Every Christmas

    One group of ghosts from the Stark family has created quite a legacy for themselves. The Starks left behind numerous spirits that are now haunting a Victorian home in Ludington, MI, and visitors have reported numerous sightings - particularly around Christmas.

    One such specter, Vera Stark, was well known in life for her eccentricities and seems to have brought them with her into the afterlife. Those who claim to have seen her ghost say she appears in the front yard of the home wearing only a fur coat and picking flowers - just as she did in life. In addition, the ghost of one of the Stark daughters - who suffered a terrible mishap in the mansion's gymnasium - can allegedly be seen walking through the halls of the home.

    The current owners of the home have even attempted to open it up to historical tours, but they apparently ran into problems: "Our spirits did not care for it being open to the public, and went wild..."

    287 votes
  • The Ghost Of Sir Geoffrey de Mandeville And His Headless Dog Roam The Streets On Christmas Eve
    Photo: Unknown / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain
    294 VOTES

    The Ghost Of Sir Geoffrey de Mandeville And His Headless Dog Roam The Streets On Christmas Eve

    The story of Sir Geoffrey de Mandeville is brimming with political betrayals. He held the title of Earl of Essex and was a prestigious European landowner during the 1100s. Because of his title, he had great influence over royal politics at the time. However, when a debate emerged regarding the rightful heir to the throne, he chose the losing side and was promptly stripped of many of his assets and excommunicated from the church.

    During his excommunication, Sir Geoffrey was slain on the battlefield, but because of his exile, he was not allowed a proper Christian interment, which many believe left his spirit trapped within the earthly realm.

    Rumor claims that Sir Geoffrey also left a curse on the properties he owned, stating that, should they ever be taken away from him, ruin would befall his betrayer, and every six years on Christmas Eve, he and a headless dog would haunt the lands draped in a red cloak.

    Ever since his demise, people who have visited the properties he once owned - particularly the Pymms Brook Bridge in East Barnet - have reported hearing strange sounds and witnessing the hazy image of a headless dog breaking through the fog, accompanied by a knight in full armor and a red cloak.

    294 votes
  • 6
    316 VOTES

    A Ghost Supposedly Disrupted A Christmas Party At Alcatraz

    Alcatraz, the isolated penitentiary located in the middle of California's San Francisco Bay, closed down in 1963, but tales of those who were once held on the island continue to haunt generations of onlookers and visitors. Often referred to as "the Rock," Alcatraz has gained a reputation for unexplainable and shocking ghost encounters, and one of the most notable was recounted during Christmas. 

    Back in the 1940s, while the facility was still in operation, the warden at the time, Warden Johnston, decided to throw a small Christmas party at his boarding house on the island. 

    During the gathering, a few of the guards began retelling the story of a phantom figure who appeared before them "wearing a gray suit, brimmed cap, and sporting mutton-chop sideburns." All the guards could do was stare at the ghostly figure in shock, and before they had a chance to move, "the room suddenly turned very cold and the fire in the Ben Franklin stove was extinguished." And just as suddenly as he had appeared, the phantom man vanished.

    316 votes