Weird History Myths About Colonial America, Debunked  

Quinn Armstrong
2k votes 563 voters 18.3k views 12 items

List Rules Vote up the most shocking debunkings.

For many in the United States, the colonial period is murky and full of half-remembered stories from school. We may recall some important tidbits like the Mayflower, the Salem Witch Trials, and the Declaration of Independence, but the stuff in between can be a blur. Didn't Thomas Jefferson own slaves? Wasn't there a mystery about Roanoke and the Croatoan?

The fact is there are many misconceptions about this period of history, from simple yet slightly off aspects of daily life to major historical moments that are nothing like you thought. You may not know quite as much about colonial America as you think you do. This period - and particularly during the American Revolution - has become so heavily mythologized the truth may elude you. For the storytellers who discuss this period, it's much easier to recount only the thrilling story of heroes who fought for freedom than delve into the complicated politics surrounding the revolution and the brilliant but flawed Founding Fathers.

1 283 VOTES
MYTH: The Continental Congress Declared Independence From England On July 4, 1776
MYTH: The Continental Congress... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Myths About Colonial America, Debunked
Photo: William Stone/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain

Reality: On July 3, 1776, John Adams wrote to his wife Abigail, "The Second Day of July 1776, will be the most memorable Epocha, in the History of America. I am apt to believe that it will be celebrated, by succeeding generations, as the great anniversary Festival." Through a vote in the Continental Congress, the Founding Fathers declared Independence on July 2 and fully expected the date to be marked as the anniversary of America's birth.

Why The Myth: The first printing of the Declaration of Independence took place two days after independence was officially declared, and it was performed by a Philadelphia printer named John Dunlap. As was customary at the time, Dunlap printed the date of publication - July 4 - on top of the document, and the date has stuck ever since. As early as 1777, Americans were celebrating on July 4, not July 2.

99 184
Does the reality surprise you?
2 212 VOTES
MYTH: Early European Settlers Lived Exclusively In Their Own Colonies
MYTH: Early European Settlers ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Myths About Colonial America, Debunked
Photo: Benjamin West/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain

Reality: Native American and frontier cultures were often intermingled, and there was a constant interchange between them. Many white settlers found the Native communities attractive; thus, many settlers left to join Native villages, wherein the pilgrims banned the wearing of long hair by men, fearing it might lead to "Indianization."

Why The Myth: This myth likely arose for the same reason pilgrims banned long hair: to prevent intercultural exchange. For settlers intent on taking Native land, the idea of coexisting was infeasible. Subsequent history, books, and movies portraying early America have followed suit, often depicting a simple European town and separate Native tribe nearby.

74 138
Does the reality surprise you?
3 187 VOTES
MYTH: America Was A 'Pristine Wilderness' When The Europeans Arrived
MYTH: America Was A 'Pristine ... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Myths About Colonial America, Debunked
Photo: Benjamin West/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain

Reality: The forests of America were far from untouched when the Europeans arrived. Large Native American tribes had practiced agriculture for centuries, and they had felled so many trees it changed the climate of the northeastern United States. Native Americans practiced controlled burning of the forests and enormous clearing operations to create land for farming.

Why The Myth: There are a number of reasons why the early settlers thought of America as largely untouched. For one, the majority of Native Americans had succumbed to the plagues, and so there were simply less humans around. It also played into the popular "noble savage" myth, an idea that encouraged the Europeans to take land from Native Americans on the grounds that the latter didn't know how to use it.

60 127
Does the reality surprise you?
4 247 VOTES
MYTH: Paul Revere Rode His Horse Through Lexington And Concord Shouting, 'The British Are Coming!'
MYTH: Paul Revere Rode His Hor... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Myths About Colonial America, Debunked
Photo: Office Of War Information/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain

Reality: Most of what we think we know about Revere's ride is simply untrue. He never shouted, "The British are coming!" in part because the citizens of Massachusetts still considered themselves British and would have been confused. Instead, he shouted, "The Regulars are coming out." Furthermore, Revere never made it to Concord; he was captured and interrogated en route to Lexington, then forced to walk to the city to give his first official warning. Word still got to Concord, however, because Revere didn't ride alone - he was part of a network of roughly 40 riders.

Why The Myth: In 1860, the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow was concerned about rising partisan unrest and political conflicts. In response, he wanted to write a poem that presented a heroic, united story of America, and the image of a lone rider with a message of warning fit the bill. The poem was a huge success. For many years, children learned it in school, so the myth was cemented.

78 169
Does the reality surprise you?