Total Nerd

Wildly Convincing Black Mirror Fan Theories That Somehow Make The Show Even Crazier 

Zack Howe
Updated May 7, 2020 5.3k votes 1.5k voters 65.5k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the most convincing Black Mirror fan theories.

Even if you're an avid viewer of the Netflix series, you may still have a lot of unanswered questions from Black Mirror swirling in your head. To be fair, that's basically the whole point of the show: it's a science fiction trip into a speculative future. Other shows like Black Mirror try to do the same. As is inevitable these days, there are myriad fan theories about Black Mirror mysteries thanks to just how bizarre and mind-blowing the series is. It's so trippy, in fact, that it's leaking into other shows, sparking a theory that Black Mirror and Riverdale exist in the same universe, thanks to an Easter egg from one of Black Mirror's best episodes popping up in an episode of CW's Riverdale.

In short, Black Mirror is enigmatic, but after its fourth season, a broader narrative is starting to coalesce; with that comes some clarity and so many theories. While many of those place the show in the universe of other movies/shows (or vice versa), many are self-contained, as well, and a lot are brilliant.

These are some of the best Black Mirror fan theories that are sure to break your brain, or maybe repair the damage that the show has caused. Vote up the ones that are the most convincing, no matter how much of a trip they might be.

Rolo Haynes Is The Narrator Of The Series And Each Artifact In His Museum Represents An Episode
Rolo Haynes Is The Narra... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Wildly Convincing Black Mirror Fan Theories That Somehow Make The Show Even Crazier
Photo:  Netflix

Redditor nathanlunn68's theory is actually quite simple; as his TL;DR says, "Rolo Haynes (the Black Museum’s owner) is the metaphorical narrator of the Black Mirror series. Each episode is his explanation of an artifact in his Museum." So each artifact in the "Black Museum" is associated with an episode in the series, and represents the narrative of that episode.

Is this convincing?
'15 Million Merits' Is Contemporaneous With 'Nosedive' And Is A Part Of The Shared Universe's Reality
'15 Million Merits' Is C... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Wildly Convincing Black Mirror Fan Theories That Somehow Make The Show Even Crazier
Photo:  Netflix

"15 Million Merits" is the source of much debate within the Black Mirror universe, one that many are coming to see as a shared universe with a specific timeline (just not in the order the episodes are presented). Kally-0 believes "15 MM" is a reality within the universe (not a show or work of fiction within the universe as some believe). Here's the Redditor's breakdown:

"All episodes seem to fit into three general eras:

  • Current day with 'experimental tech' (e.g. 'National Anthem,' 'Shut up and Dance,' 'Waldo Moment').
  • Near future episodes with advanced technology within cultures that take these technologies as the norm (e.g. 'Nosedive,' 'Entire History of You,' 'White Christmas').
  • Apocalyptic episodes (e.g. 'Men Under Fire,' 'Metalhead').

My theory is that 15 MM is contemporary with the 'Nosedive' era, but the people in it are the British working classes and/or underclasses. I propose that 15 MM actually takes place in a futuristic form of a Victorian workhouse, where the unemployed are used as a cheap, renewable power source in exchange for shelter and food. Of course this is a depressing system, so the use of 'merits' and reality TV shows like 'Hot Shots' are used as a way to give these working classes false hope of escaping to a better life."

Is this convincing?
All Episodes Take Place In The Same Universe
All Episodes Take Place ... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Wildly Convincing Black Mirror Fan Theories That Somehow Make The Show Even Crazier
Photo:  Netflix

This is not an uncommon theory, but 2localboi does an uncommonly good job of explaining it. This Redditor lays out the events of six episodes explaining how they chronologically relate to one another in this order: "The National Anthem," "The Waldo Moment," "White Bear," "Entire History Of You," "Be Right Back," "15 Million Merits." What's more, the theory suggests that all the events in the series are related to Waldo's rise to power, his totalitarian government, and the subsequent effects on humanity with centuries'-long ramifications. 

The TL;DR reads: "'The National Anthem' sets off a series of events that lead to WALDO controlling the world, ultimately making people live a quasi-virtual game-ified existence in the year 2211."

Is this convincing?
Dr. Dawson Killed The Weather Girl
Dr. Dawson Killed The We... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Wildly Convincing Black Mirror Fan Theories That Somehow Make The Show Even Crazier
Photo:  Netflix

Redditor thisisforscienceonly is not alone in believing Dr. Dawson to be the real murderer of the weather girl (as the comments make clear), but the user's theory on what is going on withing Season 4's "Black Museum" episode is presented well:

"I think that Dr. Dawson is the one who murdered the weather girl.

We first hear about the weather girl's disappearance when Dawson is watching TV, contemplating hurting himself.

For the theory to work it means either A) he starts hurting himself after he killed her,

or B) it's from Douglas Hodge, the museum director's perspective, so the whole timeline could be a bit faulty on his part. Maybe the self mutilation, then kidnapping of weather girl happened, and finally murder of the homeless man, but of course Hodge wouldn't have known all of this, so that's why the story is portrayed differently.

In the monkey story the news report discusses that the weather girl had been mutilated, which ties in with Dawson's whole 'pain = pleasure' thing.

It's strongly alluded that Clayton was innocent, as there had been DNA tampering, and he just didn't seem to have a motive of any kind."

Is this convincing?