Total Nerd

The Next Batman Movie Should Be Based On 'The Court Of Owls,' Or It's Probably Not Worth Seeing 

Stephan Roget
Updated November 5, 2019 4.4k views 14 items

Fans have spent so much time arguing over lead roles and directors that there hasn't been much in the way of speculation over the plot of the next Batman movie. After the grim and gritty tales of the Christopher Nolan era and whatever Batman v Superman was, many fans have found themselves debating which Batman movie based on comics DC and Warner Bros. should tell. Among the many options that the Dark Knight’s near-century of publishing history has to offer, a Court of Owls adaptation is undoubtedly the best option.

Court of Owls is the first arc in the lengthy and legendary Batman run by writer Scott Snyder and artist Greg Capullo. The story flips Gotham’s history on its head, revealing that a sinister secret society, the titular Court, has been using their wealth and political pull to influence the city from the shadows for generations. Most disconcertingly of all, they’ve been doing this without Batman noticing! When the Court decides to target Bruce Wayne, however, it brings the Caped Crusader into direct conflict with the Owls and their legion of immortal assassins, known as the Talons.

The Court of Owls is a fun story for both the Dark Knight veterans as well as the uninitiated, and it is also the best answer regarding comics that should be Batman movies. If you're searching for the plot of this inevitable film, look no further, because the plot of The Court of Owls Batman comic is obviously the correct answer. Read on to discover the reasons why, and don't forget to vote up the most compelling pieces of evidence. 

Gotham Is A Character In The Court Of Owls
Gotham Is A Character In... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Next Batman Movie Should Be Based On 'The Court Of Owls,' Or It's Probably Not Worth Seeing
Photo:  DC Comics

There may be no fictional city more well-known than Gotham, but it’s a location that has yet to be truly captured in a cinematic adaptation. Tim Burton’s films nailed Gotham’s kooky architecture, at least, but Batman v Superman reduced it to the hellhole across the bay from Metropolis.

In The Court of Owls, Gotham City is as much a part of the story as Batman himself. The Court is intertwined with Gotham’s history and its famous families and they’ve controlled it for generations, meaning Batman has to come to grips with some harsh truths about his hometown before he can crack the case. The arc offered some sorely needed “character development” for Gotham City.

Court Of Owls Could Provide Some Historical Fiction

The Court of Owls has been active in Gotham City for centuries, making them a truly historical threat. All of Gotham’s famous and influential families have some sort of tie to the Court, meaning their group’s biography is very much a historical account of the city. On top of that, the Court’s legion of assassins, the Talons, are functionally immortal.

The Talons represent all eras of American history, potentially pitting Batman against someone who has been killing people since the Civil War.

Dick Grayson Could Be Introduced To The DCEU

Dick Grayson, the original and most widely-known Robin, did not appear at all in the Nolan trilogy and has yet to make an appearance in the rebooted DC cinematic universe. However, whether in Robin or Nightwing form, fans are clamoring for his return.

The Court of Owls would offer a convenient entry point to bring the character back into Batman’s cinematic life. In the comic, Grayson was identified at an early age as a potential Talon, until his adoption by Bruce Wayne saved him from their clutches.

This could easily be re-written as an origin story for Dick, with Batman coming into contact with him after discovering his name in the Owls’s ledgers.

The Story Explores The Wayne's Cloudy History

Movie audiences have seen a lot of Thomas and Martha Wayne over the years, but their appearances consist entirely of saying inspiring things to their son and then getting shot in an alley. The Wayne's are generally depicted as perfect parents, but The Court of Owls breaks away from that by making Bruce – and by extension, the audience – question his family for the first time.