Weird History The Original, Rejected Designs For New York's Central Park Were Absolutely Insane  

Mariel Loveland
10 items Embed

The construction of Central Park was truly the beginning of a cultural movement –  it's a landmark that remains one of the most visited parks in the United States today. This expansive patch of green within Manhattan's concrete jungle attracts over 25 million visitors a year, but did you know it was almost a whole lot different?

In 1857, New York City held a design competition to choose a plan for a plot of city-owned land. Out of 33 entries, the city chose the "Greensward Plan," which was created by Frederick Law Olmsted, a landscape architect, and Calver Vaux, an architect. Their submission eventually evolved into the Central Park you know today, with winding foot trails and grassy patches for sunning and sports. But what if Olmsted and Vaux never won?

John Rink isn't the guy who designed Central Park, but he was a true visionary. His failed designs for Central Park show a much different idea – one that goes against the park's current-day organic feeling. John Rink's Central Park designs are orderly and geometric, and they feature a whole lot of topiaries. Check out the Central Park that's more akin to the gardens of Versailles than it is to a city park below.

John Rink's Plan Was Almost Lost Forever


John Rink's Plan Was Almos... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Original, Rejected Designs For New York's Central Park Were Absolutely Insane
Photo: John Rink/New York Historical Society/Fair use

John Rink's plan for Central Park didn't win the 1857 design competition. It was overlooked and discarded. From there, it went missing for decades – until it was discovered in an attic in 2008. As of 2017, the 8 ½-foot-long design was on display at the New-York Historical Society.

In Rink's Plan, The Park Was Totally Devoid Of Open Green Spaces


In Rink's Plan, The Park W... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Original, Rejected Designs For New York's Central Park Were Absolutely Insane
Photo: John Rink/New York Historical Society/Fair use

Central Park is known for being a sweeping patch of nature that contrasts with the metal and concrete of Manhattan's streets and skyscrapers. This patch of serenity includes various meadows and gardens, including the East Meadow, the North Meadow, the Great Hill, the Great Lawn, and the Conservatory Garden. These large fields of grass and open spaces were non-existent in Rink's plan. The only open space was the Parade Ground.

The Parade Ground


The Parade Ground is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Original, Rejected Designs For New York's Central Park Were Absolutely Insane
Photo: John Rink/New York Historical Society/Fair use

John Rink's idea for Central Park had just a single open space – the Parade Ground. This area, which would have either been dirt, concrete, or very short grass, rested next to the reservoir. It would have been an ideal place for outdoor events, including concerts and fairs. Today, that area is teeming with winding paths, tennis courts, and a police station.

Rink's Park Featured Geometric Paths And An Abundance Of Topiaries


Rink's Park Featured Geome... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Original, Rejected Designs For New York's Central Park Were Absolutely Insane
Photo: John Rink/New York Historical Society/Fair use

Rink's design was perfectly manicured – almost obsessively so. Rather than opting for a park where nature could run its course and grow wild, the plans were filled with hundreds and hundreds of topiaries laid out in a very calculated, geometric design. Today, historians locate Rink's plan in the Victorian tradition of highly stylized, ornamented landscapes.