VOTE 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay  

Christopher Shultz
4k votes 783 voters 173.8k views 18 items

List Rules Vote up the doll you'd absolutely never, ever buy

There's a big market for creepy dolls on eBay. Auctions for these damaged, spooky little dollies have gone for hundreds of dollars. And if creepy-looking isn't bad enough, some sellers actually claim to sell cursed dolls and haunted dolls. Here are 18 scary porcelain, cloth, and wax figures you can buy on eBay.  

Note: These auctions were live as of this writing, with many of them ending sometime around June 20, 2016. Furthermore, the prices shown were current at the time of posting. If you desire these macabre dolls, you'd better get on it now.
1 419 VOTES

Porcelain Doll, Vacant Green Eyes, Haunted, Possessed, or Cursed


Porcelain Doll, Vacant Green E... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: bookmans_exchange

Current Price:  $6.66

DescriptionNOTE: This doll has a dark magnetism that may cause certain people to be inexplicably drawn to her. Some owners have reported "strange" occurrences that begin near the time of the acquisition of this doll. Some people report "creepy" or "scary" feelings when they are near the doll. This doll may be haunted, cursed or possessed. Seller holds no liability for any "strange" occurrences surrounding ownership or proximity to this doll.
282 137
Is this creepy?
2 293 VOTES

Creepy Dirty Dolls


Creepy Dirty Dolls is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: 9133_dog

Current Price: $35.00

DescriptionOld, barn rescue dolls, 1960's plastic or possibly rubber dolls, in an old, dirty condition. Found in my 95 year old neighbor's barn, folded up in his old aluminum lawn chairs.  He told me his daughter never did like them, said they scared her! All original.  Selling as a pair, as is.  I will not clean.
192 101
Is this creepy?
3 242 VOTES

Creepy Baby Doll Head and Hands


Creepy Baby Doll Head and Hand... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: loribelle409

Current Price: $25.00 
 
Description
New without package creepy baby doll head and hands.  Made of ceramic porcelain type material...Sorry, no returns on this one...if I get him out of my house, he can't come back! 
160 82
Is this creepy?
4 277 VOTES

Antique Ventriloquist Dummy


Antique Ventriloquist Dummy is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: ksallvin09

Current Price: $75.00

DescriptionI think the outfit is all original, But I am far from an expert on dolls.   The clothing has some noticeable soiling  on his shirt,  and pants. Did not see any rips or mending.
178 99
Is this creepy?