Graveyard Shift

18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay 

Christopher Shultz
Updated April 24, 2020 7.3k votes 1.2k voters 190.4k views 18 items

List Rules Vote up the doll you'd absolutely never, ever buy

There's a big market for creepy dolls on eBay. Auctions for these damaged, spooky little dollies have gone for hundreds of dollars. And if creepy-looking isn't bad enough, some sellers actually claim to sell cursed dolls and haunted dolls. Here are 18 scary porcelain, cloth, and wax figures you can buy on eBay.  

Note: These auctions were live as of this writing, with many of them ending sometime around June 20, 2016. Furthermore, the prices shown were current at the time of posting. If you desire these macabre dolls, you'd better get on it now.

back to page 1
5
Antique Ventriloquist Dummy
Antique Ventriloquist Du... is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: ksallvin09

Current Price: $75.00

DescriptionI think the outfit is all original, But I am far from an expert on dolls.   The clothing has some noticeable soiling  on his shirt,  and pants. Did not see any rips or mending.
Is this creepy?
6
Antique Cracked Composition Doll
Antique Cracked Composit... is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: treasureexcavationteam

Current Price: $1,500.00

DescriptionNIGHTMARE DOLL.
Is this creepy?
7
Old German Bisque with Leather Body
Old German Bisque with L... is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: cindiana

Current Price: $159.00

Description: Original brown wig in original set. Light blue grey sleep eyes (head is packed) and open mouth. Some surface damage to leather on upper leg (see picture). Body is nice white and clean leather. Big pretty girl.
Is this creepy?
8
Old, Creepy, Scary, Antique Doll, Authentic
Old, Creepy, Scary, Anti... is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list 18 of the Creepiest Dolls You Can Buy on EBay
Photo: via ebay.com

Seller: tonydc15

Current Price: $34.99

DescriptionI got it at an antique store's family estate sale. It is quite terrifying... he has no hands, and the eyes roll around in a most unsettling way...
Is this creepy?