15 Fairy Tales And Their Lesser-Known 'Horror Story' Versions
Most people have read some of Grimm's Fairy Tales during their lives, or at least have seen Disney adaptations of the most popular stories. However, many readers don't know how terrible and creepy fairy tales can really get. Pages of these classic books are peppered with murder, incest, anthropomorphic sausages, and even dismemberment just for fun. While many of these scary fairly tales come from the Brothers Grimm, some of them go back farther. They're enough to make you wonder why fairy tales are ever considered okay for children.
To be clear, there are some stories here that do have childish themes. They feature silly games, fairies, and even little songs and poems that are sung by birds. But in each one of these stories, some darker theme emerges. Often those innocent plot points end up seeming all the more morbid.
The worst things that happened in fairy tales aren't for those seeking happily ever after. Even the ever-optimistic Cinderella would have run from most of the princes in these stories.
- 14,401 VOTES
An Old Lady Is Flayed AlivePhoto: Dressler, Florence / Wikimedia Commons / No Restrictions
The title of this Italian tale is "The Flayed Old Woman," and it certainly delivers on that name. Two old, ugly sisters live together near a king's castle. One day, the king goes for a walk, and hears one of the women singing. Her voice is so beautiful that the king assumes she is young and fair, and falls for her instantly. The women, realizing this as a chance for glory, attempt to fool the king into thinking they're young by sucking on their wrinkled fingers and only showing him those. Then, they pull back all of their saggy skin and approach him in complete darkness. Still, the king discovers their ruse, and throws one of the women from a tower.
She gets caught in tree branches below rather than dying, and she hangs there by her saggy skin, weeping. Some forest fairies hear her, and decide to help her out. They give her fine clothes, servants, anything a rich lady could ask for, and they make her young. The king sees her, and decides that even if she was an ugly old liar before, she's pretty and rich now, so he marries her.
So, happily ever after, right? Not quite. The other old sister is extremely jealous, and decides she wants to be young and beautiful, too. She demands her now-young sister tell her how she was transformed. The sister becomes so irritated with her questions that she says she flayed herself. The old sister believes the lie, and goes to a barber to be flayed. He's dubious, but eventually consents, and flays her alive. As the old woman bleeds out on the floor, skinless, she reminds herself that you must suffer for beauty. Then, she dies.
- 23,916 VOTES
A Dead Mother Returns To Nurse Her BabyPhoto: Jessie Willcox Smith / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain
A fairy tale from Russia, "The Dead Mother," is equal parts sweet and horrifying. A husband and wife live happily together, awaiting the birth of their baby. When the baby is born, the mother is so happy that she dies. Everyone weeps and mourns, and the man hires an old woman to look after the baby. The child screams and cries all day, and refuses to eat. But then, when nightfall comes, the baby is silent.
Eventually, people got pretty curious about the baby's habits. The husband, old woman, and some of the townsfolk get together and enter the baby's room. There, they find the baby's dead mother, dressed in her bloodied burial clothes, breastfeeding the baby. The dead woman looks at them, then sadly puts the baby to bed and leaves. When the group checks on the baby, they discover that it had died.
Never try to separate a mother and her child.
- 32,957 VOTES
A Children's Game With Deadly ResultsPhoto: Alfred Jacob Miller / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain
There are two versions of this German story, and both of them are terrifying. Both start with a pair of children who decide to pretend that one is a butcher and one is a pig. As you might guess, the story is called "How Some Children Played at Slaughtering" for a reason. The boy playing the butcher takes the game too seriously, and tackles the pig boy and slits open his throat, killing him.
This is where the story diverges. In one version, the mother of the two children playing sees the killing while bathing her youngest child, rushes down in a fit of rage, and kills the older boy herself. She then goes upstairs to discover that her other child has drowned in the tub. The distraught mother hangs herself, and when her husband comes home to find everyone dead, he dies from grief.
The other version is less morbid, but it's arguably more distressing. A councilman witnesses the killing, and brings the boy in for trial. However, everyone agrees that it was just supposed to be a game, so they can't tell if the boy is evil or not. They decide to test him by setting out some money and a shiny apple. If he chooses the money, he's bad, and if he chooses the apple, he's good. The boy chooses the apple, and isn't punished for committing murder.
- 42,729 VOTES
A Woman Chops Off Her Hands To Be Less Beautiful
The Italian tale "Penta of the Chopped-Off Hands" opens with Penta happily growing up as the sister of the king. Then, the king's wife dies, and the only woman nearly as beautiful is his own sister. He decides to marry her, but Penta disagrees. She decides to make herself as ugly as possible, by cutting off the part of her the king liked the most: her hands.
The king is horrified at what Penta has done, so he stuffs her into a crate and throws it into the ocean. She's initially helped by a kind fisherman, but his wife still finds her too beautiful, and Penta is once again tossed in the sea. At last, Penta's crate washes up on the shores of a wealthy kingdom, and she is taken in by the queen. When the queen dies, her husband remarries Penta.
Penta gives birth to the king's child while he's away at sea. But the fisherman's jealous wife intercepts the message intended to inform the king that he's a new dad, and changes it to say that Penta has given birth to puppies. The king decides to accept this twist of fate, but Penta is banished before he arrives home. Eventually, with the help of a sorcerer, she's reunited with her king and given new hands. The fisherman's wife is dipped in wax and burned to death.
- 52,967 VOTES
A Man Seals Himself In A Tomb To Watch His Wife RotPhoto: Frank C Pape / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain
In the Brothers Grimm tale "The Three Snake Leaves," a son of a poor man leaves to find his fortune, and takes a job fighting in a war under the king. He rises to prestige during the conflict, and the king takes notice. He thinks his daughter may be right for the young war hero, but she's a little strange in one aspect. She won't marry a person unless they are willing to be sealed up in a tomb with her dead body, so they could never marry another. Surprisingly, the war hero agrees to this unconventional arrangement, and the two are married.
Then, his bride becomes sick and dies. As was promised, the young man has himself walled up in the tomb alongside his beloved, with only some bread, wine, candles, and a rotting corpse to keep him company. Then, a snake slithers into the tomb. The man kills the snake, hacking it into pieces, but another snake comes out with magical leaves to heal the animal. Seeing the leaves' magic at work, the man takes the leaves and uses them on his dead wife. Lo and behold, she comes back to life!
Still, this is not a happy ending. The young wife suddenly finds that she doesn't love her husband anymore. In fact, she's fallen in love with a skipper on a voyaging ship. She and the skipper throw her husband into the ocean, killing him. Luckily, he still has those leaves, and comes back to life with the help of a servant. Heartbroken and angry, he hunts down his murderous wife, and tells the old king what had happened. Disgusted by his treacherous daughter, the king places her and her lover in a ship full of holes to sink and drown.
- 62,306 VOTES
A Half-Hedgehog Boy Endures Years Of SufferingPhoto: Internet Archive Book Images / flickr / No known copyright restrictions
In the Grimm's tale "Hans-My-Hedgehog," a peasant couple has a son who is born with the top half of a hedgehog. They name him Hans-My-Hedgehog, and then ignore him as he stays behind the stove for years and refuses to die (though they really want him to). One day, in his infinite kindness, Hans's father asks him if he wants a gift. He asks for bagpipes and a rooster to ride, and he leaves his parents' house.
One day, the king rides by and hears Hans playing his "beautiful" bagpipe music. The king asks if he knows the way back to the palace. Hans tells the lost king that he'll take him there, under the condition that he gets the first thing he sees. Upon their arrival, the king's beautiful daughter runs out to greet her father. The king doesn't want to give his daughter to a hedgehog boy, and he orders his guards to attack Hans. But they can't kill Hans, and he demands to be paid what he is owed.
At last, the king gives in, and the princess rides away with Hans. However, Hans stops, rips off her clothes, and sticks her with his spines until she is a bloody mess. He tells her that that was for her deceit, and that she must return to her father to live out her days in ugliness.
This same thing happens at a second kingdom, but this time, the girl agrees to be with Hans. The hedgehog boy tears off his hedgehog skin and has it burned, and is transformed into a handsome prince. He even returns to his parents' house with his new bride to rub it in their faces.