Graveyard Shift The Creepiest Things Ever Found in People's Basements  

Christopher Shultz
13.2k votes 3.4k voters 635.9k views 12 items

List Rules Vote up the freakiest things discovered in people's basements.

Creepy basements - they're a staple of horror movies, particularly in titles like The Silence of the Lambs and The Conjuring. But of all the scary basements featured on the big screen, nothing can compare to the real life horrors discovered by everyday people beneath their homes and businesses. From mysterious wells, medical oddities, skeletal remains, animals, and even other people, this list of creepy things found in basements will surely raise the hair on the back of your neck.
1 1,681 VOTES

Mummified Infant Remains and a Peter Pan Obsession

Mummified Infant Remains and a... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Creepiest Things Ever Found in People's Basements
Photo: IndianCaverns/Wikimedia Commons

In 2010, a woman made a shocking discovery inside a trunk tucked away in her Los Angeles, CA apartment building's basement. Wrapped in LA Times newspapers from the 1930s were two mummified remains of newborn infants, sealed away together with various Peter Pan-related paraphernalia, including a copy of the book by J.M. Barrie and a membership card to the Peter Pan Woodland Club. Weirdly enough, the previous owner of the trunk was Janet M. Barrie - or J.M. Barrie, the same name as the famous author.  

While some theorized the woman might have been a distant relative of the writer, it was later revealed there was no familial relation.

Furthermore, DNA tests showed the infants were indeed the children of Janet, and it's possible they were illegitimate children who died shortly after birth. While the identity of the children and further information about the trunk's owner were unearthed, the circumstances that led Janet to stow her deceased children in her trunk will forever be a mystery.
1,399 282
Is this creepy?
2 1,312 VOTES

Two Fetuses in Jars

Two Fetuses in Jars is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Creepiest Things Ever Found in People's Basements
Photo: via YouTube
Workers tasked with renovating an old building in Hannibal, MO uncovered two fetuses preserved in jars of formaldehyde in the basement. The discovery bolstered rumors that the property once housed an illegal abortion clinic established sometime in the early 1900s.
1,103 209
Is this creepy?
3 1,421 VOTES

A Secret Roommate

A Secret Roommate is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Creepiest Things Ever Found in People's Basements
Photo: via YouTube
Ohio State University students made a startling discovery in September 2013, when they found a locker in the basement of their house that led into a secret room, complete with textbooks and photographs on the wall. The room was apparently inhabited by "Jeremy," a complete stranger to the other residents of the house. The matter was resolved peacefully - Jeremy simply vacated his sweet secret room. Still, the tenants have no idea how many keys to their home might be floating around town.
1,172 249
Is this creepy?
4 1,094 VOTES

Three Kidnapped Women

Three Kidnapped Women is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Creepiest Things Ever Found in People's Basements
Photo: Cuyahoga County Sheriff's Department

This story rocked headlines in May 2013 - Ariel Castro, a Cleveland, OH man, was arrested following the revelation that he had been keeping three women imprisoned as sex slaves for over a decade. Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus, and Michelle Knight had all been kidnapped by Castro between 2000 and 2004, and ranged between 14 and 20 years old at the time of their kidnappings. They were discovered when one of Castro's neighbors heard Berry crying for help from within their underground prison.  

Castro was sentenced to life in prison. One month later, in September 2013, he was found hanging by his bedsheets in his cell, an apparent suicide. He was mourned by few.
892 202
Is this creepy?