True Crime 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying  

Ann Casano
91.4k votes 17.4k voters 2.1M views 20 items

List Rules Vote up the scariest crime movies with the creepiest real-life stories behind them.

Scary crime movies are even more horrifying when we know they’re based on true stories. It’s terrifying to think someone actually encountered a serial-killing monster masquerading as a human being. Reality always hits close to home, and these movies are some of the best films in horror. Here are the scariest true crime movies ever.

Not all the movies on this list are, strictly speaking, crime films. Not in the sense that The Departed or The French Connection or Heat are crime films. However, they all have their roots in real crimes or bizarre cases, such as The Exorcism of Emily Rose, in which priests and a girl's parents may have been responsible for her death. 

Okay, it’s true, Freddy Krueger wasn’t actually a real person who killed teenagers in their sleep. However, the premise of A Nightmare on Elm Street was based on the story of a perfectly healthy young Cambodian refugee who was having terrible nightmares before finally dying in his sleep. Famed serial killer and grave robber Ed Gein was so heinous and psychotic, some of the most iconic film characters in the history of cinema are based on him. Gein served as the inspiration for three characters from a few of the scariest true crime movies ever: Norman Bates from Psycho, Buffalo Bill from The Silence of the Lambs, and Leatherface from Texas Chainsaw Massacre.

Some of the crime films based on true stories from this list are more factual than others. For example, Dahmer and Monster are not horror films inspired by actual murders, they are biopics of the real murderers. Not every single aspect of those films are 100% factual, but for the most part, they tell the stories of Jeffrey Dahmer’s and Aileen Wuornos’s twisted lives.

It’s not just a movie. These films should and will haunt you, once you know there were actual victims behind the massacres. Make your voice heard and vote up for your favorite scary movies based on true stories. If you can't get enough of this list and want more crime, horror, and just kind of straight up disturbing movies based on real crimes, see 13 Horror Movies and the True Stories They're Based OnThe Best Scary Movies Based on True Stories, and Hard-to-Sit-Through Movies Based on Real Atrocities.

1 10,826 VOTES

The Hills Have Eyes is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying
Photo:  Vanguard Monarch Releasing Corporation

One of Wes Craven's earliest films, The Hills Have Eyes (1977), follows a family whose car breaks down in the middle of the Nevada dessert. They encounter a clan of savage, inbred, mutant beasts. Craven based his script on the 15th century legend of Alexander "Sawney" Bean, who, with his family, lived in a cave in Bennane Head, Scotland. 

According to legend, Sawney had eight sons, six daughters, and 22 grandchildren, most of whom were products of incest. The clan lived in a cave, and emerged at night to rob and murder travelers, whose bodies they would bring back to their cave to eat. This lasted for about 25 years, until locals finally figured out why people kept disappearing, and why random body parts would wash up on the shore.

Also Ranked

#9 on The Best Scary Movies Based on True Stories

#7 on Horror Movie Set-Ups You'd Least Like to Be Trapped In

#9 on The Best Horror Movies Set During Summer

#16 on The Best Classic Movies Streaming on Hulu

8,572 2,254
Does this freak you out?
see more on The Hills Have Eyes
2 6,205 VOTES

Hostel is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying
Photo:  Hostel/Lionsgate

It's difficult to determine how historically accurate Hostel is, in part because the series's infamous "Elite Hunting" organization might actually still exist. In an interview, director Eli Roth said that allegedly, an organization based in Thailand lets members shoot people in the head for the price of $10,000 per kill. The victims are sold to the organization by their impoverished family members, at which point the best thing they can hope for is a quick death. While there's no evidence online to confirm the existence of such a group, considering how morally lax the government of Thailand is, it seems highly possible that a real-life Elite Hunting organization could exist within the country. 

Also Ranked

#82 on The Greatest Horror Films of All Time

#18 on The Best Movies You Never Want to Watch Again

#4 on The Goriest Movies Ever Made

#33 on The Most Rewatchable Horror Movies

4,844 1,361
Does this freak you out?
see more on Hostel
3 6,942 VOTES

The Girl Next Door is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying
Photo:  Starz Home Entertainment

Gregory M Wilson's 2007 horror film The Girl Next Door was based on Jack Ketchum's 1989 novel of the same name, which was inspired by real-life events. In 1965, in Indiana, 16-year-old Sylvia Likens was tortured and killed by Gertrude Baniszewski. The prosecutor called the case, "the most terrible crime ever committed in the state of Indiana."

Also Ranked

#65 on The Goriest Movies Ever Made

#23 on The Best Scary Movies Based on True Stories

#80 on The Most Nausea-Inducing Great Films

5,407 1,535
Does this freak you out?
see more on The Girl Next Door
4 6,688 VOTES

The Strangers is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying
Photo:  Rogue Pictures

A young couple (Scott Speedman and Liv Tyler) is terrorized by three mentally deranged, masked lunatics in The Strangers (2008). The film's writer-director, Bryan Bertino, revealed that the home invasion premise was inspired by a time during his childhood when a stranger knocked on his door and asked for someone who wasn't there. The director later found out that a series of break-ins had occurred in his neighborhood, the perpetrators of which would knock front doors and, if no one was home, enter the house. Bertino was also inspired by Manson Family murder true crime novel Helter Skelter.

The film opens with the following narration: "What you are about to see is inspired by true events. According to the FBI, there are an estimated 1.4 million violent crimes in America each year. On the night of February 11, 2005, Kristen McKay and James Hoyt left a friend's wedding reception and returned to the Hoyt summer home. The brutal events that took place there are still not entirely known."

Also Ranked

#94 on The Greatest Horror Films of All Time

#18 on The Best Scary Movies Based on True Stories

#10 on Horror Movie Set-Ups You'd Least Like to Be Trapped In

#24 on The Best and Scariest Psychological Thrillers of All Time

5,207 1,481
Does this freak you out?
see more on The Strangers