Surprisingly Dark 'Arthur' Fan Theories That Make Us Rethink The Series

List Rules
Vote up the most mind-boggling theories about the Arthur universe.

Arthur is undoubtedly one of the most beloved PBS shows, but is there something sinister hiding beneath the surface of this wholesome, feel-good cartoon?

Let's be real: there are a lot of dark kids' shows out there, some that fly inconspicuously over the heads of young viewers, and others that are intentionally chaotic. Who'd seriously try to scar the youth with something heinously disturbing? Just check out the scandalous stuff going on over at YouTube Kids and you'll get an idea. In any event, it's pretty rare for a PBS show to be utterly scandalous, but PBS shows' fan theories sometimes paint a different picture.

Theories explaining kids' shows are usually pretty farfetched, but these dark Arthur fan theories make a whole lot of sense. If your childhood wasn't already ruined, brace for impact.

Photo:

  • 1
    574 VOTES

    There Are A Ton Of Bunnies In The Arthur Universe Because Bunnies Breed Like Crazy In Real Life

    There Are A Ton Of Bunnies In The Arthur Universe Because Bunnies Breed Like Crazy In Real Life
    Photo: PBS

    Ever notice how the Arthur world is chock full of bunnies? Well, if we're to believe that the characters in Arthur evolved from their common species, then the reason is because bunnies have a wildly short gestation period. The average bunny is pregnant for only a month which allows them to reproduce a heck of a lot faster than any other species in the Arthur universe. On the flipside, monkeys and ant eaters can have gestation periods lasting four months.

    574 votes
  • 2
    577 VOTES

    Rats Are Widely Disliked In The Arthur World, Just Like In Real Life

    Rats Are Widely Disliked In The Arthur World, Just Like In Real Life
    Photo: PBS

    Rats get a really bad rap in the real world even though they make excellent pets. Their reputation doesn't fare much better in Arthur's world. According to Reddit user AwesomenessOnAPlate, rats carry a lot of negative stereotypes in Elwood City. Proof? In "Arthur and the Real Mr. Ratburn," Prunella makes up all these crazy rumors about Mr. Ratburn. She says he regularly sends kids to Death Row for answering questions wrong and eats nails for breakfast - gross. Buster even starts to believe that Mr. Ratburn is a vampire, when in reality, he's just a normal teacher who also happens to be a poorly stereotyped rat.

    Much like Mr. Ratburn, Prunella, a rat herself, doesn't really have a good reputation. She doesn't have many actual friends her age, and she's an avid liar playing deeply into the stereotype that you "can't trust a rat." Her family is rumored to be in the illuminati, and her only fourth grade friend is a blind girl, who presumably cannot see that she's a rat and therefore, wouldn't stereotype her.

    577 votes
  • 3
    503 VOTES

    The 'Arthur' Universe Is Prejudiced Against Non-Mammals

    The 'Arthur' Universe Is Prejudiced Against Non-Mammals
    Photo: PBS

    Most of us don't spend our time thinking about the socio-economic status of the characters in Arthur, but it's undeniable that the show is a snapshot of a typical middle class town that just so happens to be largely populated by mammals. Did anyone ever stop to wonder where the heck all the non-mammals are?

    This fan theory alleges that non-mammals are an oppressed minority who were pushed out of the city because of gentrification. The evidence lies in the lack of ducks and crocodiles shown in later episodes. Ducks and crocodiles were occasionally shown in the background of earlier episodes, but always had very blue collar jobs (construction, manual labor, etc.). In later seasons, non-mammal species are totally absent in the middle class suburb. Elwood City was slowly gentrified and the oppressed minority (non-mammals) could no longer afford to live there.

    503 votes
  • 4
    452 VOTES

    Arthur Exists In A Future Where Animals Evolved Into Humans Over Thousands Of Years

    Arthur Exists In A Future Where Animals Evolved Into Humans Over Thousands Of Years
    Photo: PBS

    Every single character on Arthur is based on an animal we have on Earth, but not all of the animals are human-like. Why? One fan theory alleges that it's all because of evolution. Many theories of human evolution state that people evolved from primates. Similarly, as Reddit user AwesomenessOnAPlate theorizes, the characters in Arthur evolved from their animal counterparts. This also explains why some animals like Arthur's dog and D.W.'s pet parakeet did not evolve into humans, but there are also humanoid dogs in Elwood City. The evolutionary branch split off somewhere thousands of years ago.

    452 votes
  • 5
    496 VOTES

    Prunella's Sister Is In The Illuminati

    Prunella's Sister Is In The Illuminati
    Photo: PBS

    Though some fans argue that the entire show is peppered with illuminati imagery, leading them to believe PBS is pushing some kind of sinister agenda, others think the occult symbolism is character development. Prunella's sister, and possibly the whole rest of Prunella's family, is in the illuminati.

    Let's be real, rats are already largely untrusted in the Arthur universe. It only makes sense for Prunella's family, a literal family of rats, to be part of the sinister organization. The all-seeing eye is shown multiple times in Prunella's house, most notably on her sister's bookshelf.

    496 votes
  • 6
    433 VOTES

    Arthur And His Friends Are Stuck In A Time Loop

    Arthur And His Friends Are Stuck In A Time Loop
    Photo: PBS

    Arthur and his friends never seem to age. The show has been on air for 20 years, but the characters are mostly still in fourth grade. It's not just fans who acknowledge that Arthur may be stuck in a time loop – the writers also give this idea a nod.

    In the episode titled "Arthur's New Year's Eve," Prunella says that if there's no green flash on New Year's Eve, it stays the same year. The green flash is never shown in the episode. Of course, Prunella is a known liar (she's a rat, right?). What do you believe?

    The theory has one small fault: the show has had a couple flash-forwards. In reality, all this tells us is that the characters eventually escape from the time loop. We're still not there in the story yet even though it's been 20 years.

    433 votes