Total Nerd Dark Scooby-Doo Fan Theories  

Mariel Loveland
75.2k votes 12k voters 361.4k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the most plausible dark Scooby-Doo fan theories.

Scooby-Doo, Where Are You! aired its first episode in 1969. Since then, the beloved show has had numerous iterations, taking the Mystery Machine far and wide to solve harebrained whodunits. In the show, monsters go from bad guys in masks to real-life paranormal entities, or vice versa. Scooby-Doo is creepy, or at least its premise is, and thus fans have devised a number of dark Scooby-Doo fan theories musing on just how much darker this cartoon may be.

Fan theories about Scooby-Doo range from the plausible to the highly bizarre. From a theory that the gang are actually fugitives dodging the Vietnam War draft, to another that insists Shaggy has undiscovered magical powers. Weird Scooby-Doo stories suggest some very strange elements to an already groovy - one might say psychedelic - show. Especially considering its hippie-era setting.

Each Scooby-Doo conspiracy pointed out is sure to make your next viewing of the show fraught with new interpretations. These Scooby-Doo theories will shock you more than discovering that a bank-robbing ghost is really just a dude in a bed sheet. One thing's for sure, those meddling kids sure got themselves into some strange situations.

1 8,088 VOTES

Shaggy Is A Pothead

Shaggy Is A Pothead is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Dark Scooby-Doo Fan Theories
Photo: Warner Bros.

One of the show's longest-standing fan theories purports that Shaggy is a total pothead. Which pans out on a number of levels, not least of which is the prevalent recreational use of drugs in the era the show originally aired. Shaggy is constantly paranoid about the existence of ghosts and always, always hungry.

Plus, he spends most of his time blabbering to his dog. In very high doses, weed is a hallucinogen. His personality does rather fit the stereotypical pothead to a T.

7,665 423
Is this theory believable?
2 6,113 VOTES

The Gang Live In A Post-Economic Collapse Country

The Gang Live In A Post-Econom... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Dark Scooby-Doo Fan Theories
Photo: Warner Bros.

Ever wonder why the gang seems to always be exploring the absolute dredges of the universe? Maybe it's because they live in a run down world. Reddit user Randomd0g suggests that the Scooby-Doo gang live in a post-depression world. The evidence is alarming.

They gang are almost always creeping around shoddy places like run- down hotels, abandoned theme parks, and unused airfields – places businesses up and left. Almost all of the villains in the series try to pull off money-making schemes, but they're generally really intelligent, highly-employable people (scientists, entrepreneurs, engineers). The theory alleges these people were laid off during the depression and unable to find work in the difficult economic climate.

There's also the fact that Shaggy can never seem to afford food for Scooby and himself. Never mind the that being a vigilante detective probably doesn't pay the bills, but the pair almost exclusively live off of biscuits. Sometimes, they come across a real, hot meal and show far too much enthusiasm, suggesting it may be because they are actually starving.

4,447 1,666
Is this theory believable?
3 5,634 VOTES

Scooby-Doo Exists In A Universe Where Supernatural Entities Are Real

Scooby-Doo Exists In A Univers... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Dark Scooby-Doo Fan Theories
Photo: Warner Bros.

While viewers may find it strange that entire villages of grown adults - with fully-staffed police forces - are willing to believe ghosts, goblins, and ghouls are to blame for disturbances, one Tumblr fan theory explains the discrepancy. This theory posits that, at one point, supernatural entities did exist in the Scooby-Doo world.

Real monsters are shown in the Scooby-Doo movies. In Scooby-Doo! and the Witches Ghost, the Ghost of Sarah Ravencroft is sealed in a book. The very real monsters in Scooby-Doo! on Zombie Island exist in a secluded area and kill people who find them out. Basically, all the monsters in the Scooby-Doo universe are sealed away or in secluded locations.

This is why it's not wild for the people of that universe to accept that paranormal entities are behind crimes, but why it almost always turns out to be a guy in a suit.

4,065 1,569
Is this theory believable?
4 6,722 VOTES

Velma Is A Lesbian, She Just Hasn't Come Out Yet

Velma Is A Lesbian, She Just H... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Dark Scooby-Doo Fan Theories
Photo: Warner Bros.

Jinkies! Fashion choices aside, this theory suggests Velma is definitely a lesbian. (This despite writers putting her and Shaggy in a relationship in Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated). For one, Velma is always the odd one out. She seems to get a bit jealous when Daphne always picks Fred as her number one. She's doesn't have a boyfriend through much of the series, and when she finally does, it's Shaggy. Shaggy is a beard – a cover and a completely unsuitable partner who always, always chooses his dog over her.

Velma is brilliant and motivated. Do you really think she'd get on well with a stoner who lives in a car? So, why did she choose him? Because it's all a sham, and they're not really together. In the very least, Velma chose an unsuitable partner because she knows it can't work and isn't ready to admit her sexuality.

The theory is so widely backed that numerous think-pieces have been written urging writers to finally let the beloved brainiac settle down with a nice girl. In the original script for James Gunn's Scooby-Doo film, Velma was actually supposed to be gay.

4,362 2,360
Is this theory believable?