Snacks Discontinued McDonald's Menu Items People Won't Stop Talking About  

Molly Gander
125.3k votes 17.2k voters 1.3M views 30 items

List Rules These should only be actually discontinued items. It's okay if McDonald's has tried (and failed) to resurrect them, or if they're still available in another country, but they shouldn't be seasonal items like the McRib or the Shamrock Shake.


This is a list of discontinued McDonald's menu Items. With the ever-changing fast-food landscape, these old McDonald's menu items just couldn't keep up. Some of these delicacies never got a chance to shine and were retired before they could find an audience. Others were just horrible, horrible ideas that left sad memories and sadder slogans. Some of these retired items should be brought back. If we can have a yearly McRibbing, why can't a seasonal McLobster also grace our dollar menus? If every St. Patrick's Day we get to indulge in a Shamrock Shake, why can't we pair it with some Onion Nuggets? Okay, replacing the potato isn't the best thing to do on an Irish holiday. Maybe bring back the super-sized fries for that day only?

It's too bad that McDonald's won't sell this retired fast food to a competing chain. The McHotDog would have a welcome home in the eclectic calamity of the Jack in the Box menu. Taco Bell could probably do something with the McDonald's Chicken Fajita recipe. And a McPizza would be great paired with a Pizza Hut P'Zone.

But, perhaps that's just a dream. Perhaps fast food items need to move on so that new ones can take their place. If that is the case, welcome to the McDonald's Fast Food Graveyard Ranker list. Vote for your favorite discontinued McDonald's food item. (Would you like fries with that?)

1 6,705 VOTES

McDONALD'S BIG 'N TASTY is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Discontinued McDonald's Menu Items People Won't Stop Talking About
Photo: ajai_west/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0

The Big N' Tasty was a direct competitor for a piece of Burger King's (Whopper) market, but it never really took off and was discontinued in the US in 2011.


Also Ranked

#51 on The Best Fast Food Burgers

3,917 2,788
Did you love this?
see more on McDONALD'S BIG 'N TASTY
2 6,477 VOTES

SuperSized Menu Items

SuperSized Menu Items is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Discontinued McDonald's Menu Items People Won't Stop Talking About
Photo: Alison Faith/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0
McDonald's Supersize menu items officially bit the dust in 2004 for a variety of reasons. The fast food giant cited lackluster sales, a need to trim what it considered to be a bloated menu, and the public's clamor for healthier options. 
3,759 2,718
Did you love this?
3 8,551 VOTES

Chicken Selects

Chicken Selects is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Discontinued McDonald's Menu Items People Won't Stop Talking About
Photo: powerplantop/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0
Chicken Selects undersold nationally and were taken off the menu in 2013. 
4,922 3,629
Did you love this?
4 6,383 VOTES

Hot Mustard Sauce

Hot Mustard Sauce is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Discontinued McDonald's Menu Items People Won't Stop Talking About
Photo: Kodamakitty/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0
Despite the outcry over the loss of Hot Mustard Sauce, the food giant has no plans to bring it back, citing low sales. Or are they? This is the answer received from corporate – you be the judge: “The bold kick and flavor of the Habanero Ranch dipping sauce recently made its debut on the McDonald’s menu, beating out Hot Mustard, Sweet Chili, and Chipotle BBQ for a final spot on the sauce line up. Customers love the Habanero Ranch sauce, which is also found on McDonald’s Bacon Habanero Ranch Quarter Pounder and Southwest Premium McWrap.”
3,692 2,691
Did you love this?