Graveyard Shift

All The True Stories, People, And Crimes Referenced In Every Season Of 'American Horror Story' 

Mariel Loveland
Updated May 29, 2020 560.6k views 32 items

List Rules Vote up the real-life stories you most loved seeing on AHS.

American Horror Story, the long-running FX horror anthology, is known for its intricate storytelling. How does the series weave together complex characters and storylines throughout its seasons? Because often, American Horror Story characters are based on real people. Sometimes these people are the victim, other times they're the evil mastermind, and still other times they're regular people with an outlandish story to tell.

The real-life horror stories behind AHS paint an undeniably terrifying picture of American history - from recreating Columbine to recounting H.H. Holmes's real-life murder-trap hotel. Inspiration for AHS isn't just limited to real tragedies, however; it also encompasses creepy unsolved mysteries (such as Roanoke) and long-standing urban legends.

Here are the true stories American Horror Story has drawn from to tell its horrifying tales.

Cecil Hotel is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list All The True Stories, People, And Crimes Referenced In Every Season Of 'American Horror Story'
Photo: FX

The real-life Cecil Hotel (now the Stay on Main Hotel) in Los Angeles has been the site of a number of horrific occurrences. The hotel housed two serial killers at separate times - Richard Ramirez (known as the Night Stalker), who killed at least 13 people, and Johan Unterweger, who claimed several victims while living at the Cecil.

The Cecil also was the setting of the mysterious and highly publicized death of Elisa Lam, who was found in the hotel's water tank after guests noticed low water pressure and a funny taste in the hotel's tap water.

The hotel also shares a number of similarities with H.H. Holmes's infamous Murder Castle, a hotel he had custom built to make his bloodthirsty hobbies more convenient.

H. H. Holmes is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list All The True Stories, People, And Crimes Referenced In Every Season Of 'American Horror Story'
Photo:  FX

Evan Peters's twisted character James March was inspired by the hotelier who is often regarded as the first serial killer in America: H.H. Holmes. Holmes constructed a "murder hotel," perfectly crafted as the ultimate house of horrors, complete with trap doors, hidden rooms, chutes leading down to the basement, and purposefully disorienting hallways.

Some of the rooms were even equipped to turn into gas chambers on command, with air-tight doors that couldn't open from the inside. Holmes claimed as many as 200 lives, though he only confessed to 28.

More H. H. Holmes 

#1,021 of 2,835 The Most Influential People of All Time #5 of 19 The Creepiest Wikipedia Pages

Marie Laveau is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list All The True Stories, People, And Crimes Referenced In Every Season Of 'American Horror Story'
Photo: FX

Angela Bassett's mysterious, ancient voodoo queen was based on a real person renowned in New Orleans history. Marie Laveau was a hairdresser in the French Quarter between the 1820s and 1860s, but she also practiced black magic. Laveau was said to mix elements of Catholicism with voodoo and was known as a nurse and a healer. Today, people still visit her grave and draw three Xs on the side of it, hoping the voodoo priestess will grant them wishes.

Elizabeth Báthory... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list All The True Stories, People, And Crimes Referenced In Every Season Of 'American Horror Story'
Photo:  FX

Lady Gaga's American Horror Story debut did not disappoint. Her character, Countess Elizabeth Bathory, was truly terrifying both on the series and in real life. Elizabeth Bathory currently holds the Guinness World Record for "Most Prolific Serial Killer" and was a true sadomasochist. In the 1600s, she became a Transylvanian countess and convinced her husband to build her a torture chamber in their castle.

Her victims of choice were young, virginal girls, who she'd torture for hours by driving pins through their lips and fingernails and forcing them to cook and eat their own flesh, among other horrors. She'd then bathe in their blood to retain their youthful beauty.

Eventually, Bathory was found guilty of over 80 counts of murder and was supposed to be executed. Instead, she was imprisoned in a room alone for the rest of her life.

More Elizabeth Báthory 

#1 of 14 The Most Ruthless Queens And Female Rulers Of All Time #2 of 10 Horrifying True Stories That Are Just Like The Blair Witch Mythology #6 of 12 12 Criminals Who Really Thought They Were Vampires