34.9k readers

EW's Most Overrated Oscar Winning Films

34.9k views10 items
The Academy Award for Best Picture is the most prestigious film award in Hollywood, yet some years the awards seemed like a hoax. These movies did not deserve to win the Oscar for Best Picture but were really just average movies compared to the other films they were going against in the category. It's a shame that these films got tremendous recognition when other, more well-deserved movies did not get their praise. This list of Best Picture films comprise of works that deserve to be applauded but definitely do not deserve the Golden Man.
  • The Greatest Show on Earth1

    The Greatest Show on Earth

    James Stewart, Charlton Heston


    Directed byCecil B. DeMille

    More The Greatest Show on Earth 

    #34 of 50 The Best Oscar-Nominated Movies of the 1950s#43 of 85 Every James Stewart Movie, Ranked Best to Worst

  • Around the World in 80 Days2

    Around the World in 80 Days

    Frank Sinatra, Shirley MacLaine


    Directed byMichael Anderson

    More Around the World in 80 Days 

    #4 of 46 Movies That Won Best Picture at the Oscars and Golden Globes#363 of 549 The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made

  • Oliver!3


    Oliver Reed, Leonard Rossiter


    Directed byCarol Reed

    More Oliver! 

    #143 of 356 The Best Musical Movies Of All Time#95 of 175 The Best Movies Of The '60s

  • Ordinary People4

    Ordinary People

    Mary Tyler Moore, Donald Sutherland


    Directed byRobert Redford

    More Ordinary People 

    #144 of 369 The Best Movies Based On Books#200 of 277 The Top Tearjerker Movies That Make Men Cry

  • Chariots of Fire5

    Chariots of Fire

    Stephen Fry, Kenneth Branagh


    Directed byHugh Hudson

    More Chariots of Fire 

    #333 of 522 The Greatest Movies Of The 1980s, Ranked#299 of 480 The Greatest Movies For Guys

  • Dances with Wolves6

    Dances with Wolves

    Kevin Costner, Mary McDonnell


    Directed byKevin Costner

    More Dances with Wolves 

    #11 of 28 Civil War Movies List#103 of 372 'Old' Movies Every Young Person Needs To Watch In Their Lifetime

  • Forrest Gump7

    Forrest Gump

    Tom Hanks, Sally Field


    Directed byRobert Zemeckis

    More Forrest Gump 

    16 Extremely Messed Up Things About Forrest Gump That'll Change How You See It#27 of 1,189 Every Oscar Winning Film Ever

  • The English Patient8

    The English Patient

    Willem Dafoe, Ralph Fiennes


    Directed byAnthony Minghella

    More The English Patient 

    #157 of 221 The Greatest World War II Movies of All Time#67 of 105 The Best Valentine's Day Movies

  • American Beauty9

    American Beauty

    Kevin Spacey, Annette Bening


    Directed bySam Mendes

    More American Beauty 

    #499 of 1,540 The Most Rewatchable Movies#581 of 782 The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made

  • Crash10


    Sandra Bullock, Brendan Fraser


    Directed byPaul Haggis

    More Crash 

    #84 of 261 The Best Ensemble Movies#60 of 63 Movies You Wish You Could Still Watch for the First Time