Total Nerd 'Arrow' Fan Theories That Might Actually Be Possible  

John Saavedra
351 votes 77 voters 2.7k views 9 items

List Rules Vote up the most plausible fan theories about 'Arrow'.

From the true identity of certain masked heroes to ways the CW could expand the Arrowverse, fans on the internet tend to run wild when it comes to solving Arrow's mysteries. Fan theories about Arrow include special appearances by popular DC characters and a villainous group capable of replacing the sadly departed Suicide Squad. Not to mention all of the elaborate theories that popped up during season six as fans attempted to answer the season's most pressing question: Who is Prometheus?

The best Arrow fan theories can sometimes be a bit strange, but they're all earnest attempts to understand the unanswered questions from the Arrowverse.

1 36 VOTES

Black Siren Joins Team Arrow

Black Siren Joins Team Arrow is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 'Arrow' Fan Theories That Might Actually Be Possible
Photo:  Warner Bros. Television Distribution

Redditor /u/DonnyMox has a theory about how Black Siren's (AKA Earth-Two Laurel's) shift from super villain to super hero could go down, and it begins with Quentin's death. According to this theory, Black Canary (Dinah Drake) turns evil and Quentin's death inspired Black Siren to join Team Arrow in order to stop the now rogue Black Canary who has a lasting vendetta against Black Siren for killing her beloved Vincent (AKA Vigilante). 

 

32 4
Can you believe this theory?
2 35 VOTES

The Birds Of Prey Could Join The Arrowverse

The Birds Of Prey Could Join T... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 'Arrow' Fan Theories That Might Actually Be Possible
Photo:  Warner Bros. Television Distribution

Many fans have theorized that the Birds of Prey could be introduced to the CW's Arrowverse. After all, at least two of the classic all-female superhero team's members have been featured on Arrow as of season six: Black Canary and Huntress. Could they team up with Black Siren, Felicity, and others to fight crime alongside Team Arrow? Or perhaps in a spinoff?

Redditor /u/OddBank thinks Thea Queen should be in on the fun, while /u/Dagenspear theorizes that the Arrowverse's very own version of Barbara Gordon faked Laurel Lance's death with the help of Huntress, and the three women are hunting down any remaining members of HIVE. 

18 17
Can you believe this theory?
3 47 VOTES

John Diggle Will Become Green Lantern

John Diggle Will Become Green ... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 'Arrow' Fan Theories That Might Actually Be Possible
Photo:  Warner Bros. Television Distribution

Some of the theories surrounding John Diggle's transformation into the Green Lantern suggest Diggle's middle name is Stewart, allowing the character to segue into the role of John Stewart, one of the early adaptations of the Green Lantern. 

Redditor /u/james_notdeen's Diggle-Lantern theory is tied to an even bigger event teased by the Arrowverse. Essentially, Diggle will fulfill his destiny as the Arrowverse's very own Green Lantern during Crisis on Infinite Earths, a famous comic book event first teased on the The Flash

23 24
Can you believe this theory?
4 41 VOTES

Batman Will Appear On "Arrow"

Batman Will Appear On
Photo:  DC Comics

Over the years, the CW's Arrowverse has made many references regarding Batman and other members of the Bat family. Arrow has even featured a few of Batman's more popular rogues, including Ra's al Ghul and Deathstroke. Redditor /u/atomic00abomb seems to think it is inevitable that the show will feature everyone's favorite bat. 

After all, Superman has shown up on Supergirl, it's only fair that we get Batman on Arrow

19 22
Can you believe this theory?