The Biggest Flash-In-The-Pan Athletes And What They're Up To Now 

Rhune Kincaid
Updated September 15, 2017 2.1k views 18 items

Joel Embiid's rookie season sparked a heated debate in the sports world about whether or not an athlete could be worthy of receiving a seasonal award without having played anywhere close to a full schedule of games in that season. The 76ers forward was undeniably the best first-year player in the NBA, but should the NBA Rookie of the Year trophy really go to someone who only played 31 of his team's 82 games?

The hype of this situation begs the question: Who are the biggest flash-in-the-pan athletes of all-time? Who made the biggest splashes in the smallest sample sizes? And who had the most sizzle with the least steak?

For clarification, a flash-in-the-pan player needs to have shown superstar potential at the highest levels of their sport before, of course, sinking into mediocrity, irrelevance, or worse. A draft bust and prospects who never excelled are different things altogether.

Tim Tebow is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Biggest Flash-In-The-Pan Athletes And What They're Up To Now
Photo: CNN

It seemed like a reach when Josh McDaniels traded up for Florida's Heisman-winning quarterback, Tim Tebow, with the 25th pick in the 2010 NFL draft. But for one shining season in 2011, Tebow became a superstar.

With his unorthodox throwing style and rugged runs, he led the Broncos into an overtime upset with the Pittsburgh Steelers during the AFC Divisional Round.

However, by the next season he had been replaced by Peyton Manning, and now he's a terrible baseball player in the Mets minor league system (and a somewhat decent commentator for SEC football).

More Tim Tebow 

#99 of 770 American Public Figures Who Are National Treasures #257 of 292 The Most Obnoxious Athleteslisted on Athletes You Didn't Know Were Conservative

Mark Fidrych is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Biggest Flash-In-The-Pan Athletes And What They're Up To Now
Photo:  Wikimedia Commons (CC-BY)

People had zero expectations when Mark Fidrych joined at the Detroit Tigers in 1976, but the charismatic goofball surprisingly wreaked havoc on opposing batters. He was nicknamed "The Bird" for his resemblance to Big Bird from Sesame Street, he swore on live national television, and he could be seen and heard talking to the ball before he threw it.

Tigers attendance nearly tripled on the days that he pitched. He won 19 games and became American League Rookie of the Year, but during spring training before the 1977 season began, he hurt his knee while "goofing around in the outfield."

More injuries followed and his previously charming antics grew thin. However, he continued pitching with an undiagnosed tear in his right rotator cuff for the rest of his career and was out of the league before 1981. The rotator cuff injury was finally diagnosed in 1985.

More Mark Fidrych 

#7 of 25 MLB Players Whose Careers Ended Too Soon #18 of 157 The Best Detroit Tigers of All Time

Aaron Hernandez is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Biggest Flash-In-The-Pan Athletes And What They're Up To Now
Photo: flickr/CC0

Aaron Hernandez was an innocuous 4th round pick by the New England Patriots in the 2010 NFL Draft, but he quickly teamed with Rob Gronkowski to form the most fearsome pair of pass-catching tight ends that the NFL has ever seen.

Over the course of three NFL seasons, Hernandez racked up 1,956 receiving yards and 18 touchdowns, and even had a 42-yard rush in Super Bowl XLVI. 

However, after the Patriots lost the 2010 AFC Championship Game to the Baltimore Ravens, things quickly unraveled. The following summer, police raided his home in search of evidence relating to the murder of Odin Lloyd, and Hernandez was arrested and charged with a 2012 double homicide in Boston. He was also convicted of the Lloyd murder and hung himself in prison shortly after being cleared for the double homicide.

More Aaron Hernandez 

#30 of 57 The Best College Football Tight Ends of All Time #1,430 of 1,556 The Best Football Players Ever

Buster Douglas is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Biggest Flash-In-The-Pan Athletes And What They're Up To Now
Photo: Metaweb/CC-BY

In 1990, Buster Douglas shocked the boxing world by defeating the seemingly invincible Mike Tyson and becoming the new undisputed heavyweight champion of the world - he had caught an already-wobbly Tyson with an uppercut in the 10th round resulting in the surprising knockout.

Douglas was so unheralded that the only Las Vegas casino willing to take bets on the fight offered 42-1 odds.

Douglas quickly lost the belt to Evander Holyfield in his very next bout and never returned to championship contention. He closed his career with a string of bizarre publicity-stunt fights without ever actually getting back into shape.

More Buster Douglas 

#106 of 193 The Best Boxers of All Time #37 of 67 The Best Boxers of the 1990s