List of popular Shelby Mustangs, listed alphabetically with photos. If you're thinking about getting a new vehicle then choosing a top rated Shelby Mustang is a great idea. Save yourself the headache of dealing with a slimy used car salesman by checking out the highly rated Shelby Mustangs on this list. Click each Shelby Mustang's name to get more detailed information about the vehicle. The Shelby Mustangs on this list range from old to new models, so use this list to see how the car has evolved over the years. Examples of cars on this list include 2002 Ford Thunderbird and 1968 Ford Mustang.This list answers the questions, "What do older Shelby Mustangs look like?"