LGBT Cartoon Characters You Never Realized Are Probably Gay  

Hannah Collins
38.7k votes 6.7k voters 416.9k views 18 items Embed

List Rules Vote up the cartoon characters you think are the most likely to be closeted.

Today, LGBTQ representation in animated media gets more and more visible each day, with gay cartoon characters appearing in Gravity Falls and The Legend of Korra, to name a few. But in the same way art imitates life, potentially closeted cartoon characters also face the scrutiny of being branded "other" or "different" by the worlds they inhabit. The animated world proves to be just as treacherous and difficult to navigate as the physical one, and secretly gay cartoon characters must traverse their own unsteady paths as well. When you think about it, though, the cartoon world makes a wonderful place for potentially gay characters to be introduced, the wonder and adventure of each world providing a vibrant canvas for young children to explore these topics more engagingly.

The cartoon characters who are secretly gay below may not even really be hiding it; they might have just never confirmed it either. Some of the younger characters here likely might not even realize it yet, as puberty will come along later in life to complicate things as it does for everyone, gay or straight. Not all are gay role models, but they do offer viewers the chance to see someone they identify with. And while speculating on a real person's sexuality is not something you should ever do, guessing a fictional character's possible preferences may add some facets to characters you thought you knew so well.

1 1,759 VOTES

Mr. Simmons


Mr. Simmons is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Cartoon Characters You Never Realized Are Probably Gay
Photo:  Nickelodeon

Hey Arnold! was often praised for its smartness when it was on the air, and this extended to its inclusion of a pretty clearly queer-coded character. Mr. Simmons, Arnold's kindly fourth-grade teacher, loved his job and encouraged healthy inquisitiveness in his pupils.

In the episode "Arnold's Thanksgiving," it came out that, as well as teaching, Robert Simmons also loved an eyebrow-raising, red wine-drinking man called Peter. Though it never explicit in the show, their romantic relationship was confirmed by series creator Craig Bartlett.

1,219 540
Is this character closeted?
2 2,046 VOTES

Ren And Stimpy


Ren And Stimpy is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Cartoon Characters You Never Realized Are Probably Gay
Photo:  Nickelodeon

Arguably, this cat and dog duo never hid an openly gay lifestyle. Not only did they live together, they slept in the same bed too, definitely not something two straight housemates, or for that matter two people who aren't dating, normally get up to. Though they weren't lovey-dovey with one another like a normal couple, The Ren & Stimpy Show was far from normal anyway, always undercutting their physical closeness with a healthy dose of weirdness.

Creator John Kricfalusi always acts a little cagey about confirming or denying the perceived couple's relationship status. "I don't know if they're gay or not. It's none of my business."

1,356 690
Is this character closeted?
3 2,645 VOTES

SpongeBob SquarePants


SpongeBob SquarePants is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Cartoon Characters You Never Realized Are Probably Gay
Photo:  Nickelodeon

No other (mostly) straight animated character draws the amount of ire from anti-LGBTQ critics as SpongeBob. Though the happy-go-lucky fry cook who famously lives in a pineapple under the sea shows a romantic interest in female chum Sandy the Squirrel, his flamboyance and hyper-sensitivity incited a "gay panic" in the early '00s.

Of course, the Sponge's sizeable queer fanbase feel thrilled by the character's campy undertones, as one adult, male fan told Entertainment Weekly, "He’s not very masculine for a male character. And he’s soft."

Also Ranked

#16 on The Greatest Cartoon Characters in TV History

#9 on What TV Character That Everyone Loves Do You Actually Hate?

#79 on The Funniest TV Characters of All Time

#92 on The Greatest TV Characters of All Time

1,729 916
Is this character closeted?
see more on SpongeBob SquarePants
4 3,178 VOTES

Harley Quinn


Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Harley Quinn is now canonically bisexual since making the jump to comics. But, before she freed herself from the abusive "Mistah J" and lived her truth, she found herself stuck firmly in the closet in Batman: The Animated Series. The mature kids show featured tons of "censor decoys," and one that raised a lot of eyebrows was Harley's close bond with Poison Ivy.

Both villains are inherently sexy characters who enjoy exploiting their sexual power, and this playfulness, combined with their obvious affection for one another, led many viewers to believe the pair probably felt enough to enjoy a friendship with benefits.  

Also Ranked

#6 on The Best Characters from Batman Comics

#9 on The Best Batman Villains Ever

#2 on Villains People Find Weirdly Attractive (Even Though They Know It's Wrong)

#86 on The Most Likeable TV Anti-Heroes

2,060 1,118
Is this character closeted?
see more on Harley Quinn