664 voters

Great Bands That Really Jumped the Shark with That One Album

Updated November 6, 2017 1.9k votes 664 voters 26.6k views13 items

List RulesVote up the most awful album by a band you usually love

If you think about it, the most prolific bands have the highest chance of putting out at least one album that's total sh*t - but one bad album does not a bad band make. In fact, plenty of bad albums by great bands exist. Sometimes the artists bounce back (David Bowie took six years off after Never Let Me Down flopped to work on a comeback album), and sometimes they can't recover (RIP classic Weezer). We rounded up the 13 worst albums by good bands to prove that even the best in the biz have low moments. Do you agree?
  • Metallica: St. Anger (2003)
    Video: YouTube
    Metallica is a band that broke barriers when they first came on the music scene in the eighties. They brought heavy metal/thrash rock to the masses, and the masses loved it - especially 1991's The Black Album, which debuted at No. 1 in ten countries. Following a legal dispute with Napster and some unfavorable press in the early aughts, Metallica released St. Anger, meant to go back to their garage-rocking roots. The attempt didn't quite work out. The album got mixed reviews but most critics agreed that the lo-fi production was more noisy than raw and real, and Metallica took a lot of shit for abandoning their signature sound. 
      Agree or disagree?

      More Metallica 

      The Best Metallica Songs of All Time#103 of 1,891 The Greatest Musical Artists of All Time#21 of 1,728 The Best Rock Bands of All Time

    • Robin Thicke: Paula (2014)
      Video: YouTube
      Pop and R&B star Robin Thicke's rise to fame was a slow burn. He spent the beginning of his career writing for other artists before his own single, "Lost Without You," was released in 2006 and Thicke became known for his sultry, white-boy R&B sound. His 2013 single with Pharrell, "Blurred Lines," catapulted him to superstardom. After a highly-publicized cheating scandal and subsequent separation from his wife, Paula Patton, Thicke released Paula as an attempt to win her back. The whole album was sappy, semi-creepy, and slightly stalkerish - a total turn-off for fans. 
      • Age: 43
      • Birthplace: Los Angeles, California, United States of America
      Agree or disagree?

      More Robin Thicke 

      The Best Robin Thicke Songs#143 of 154 The Druggiest Rock Stars of All Time#148 of 461 The Best Current Pop Groups/Singers

      Spotify buy button
    • Coldplay: Mylo Xyloto (2011)
      Video: YouTube

      The members of Coldplay are soft rockers and we love them for it. They saw a lot of commercial, Top 40 success, but their music still felt authentic. That is, until 2009’s Mylo Xyloto. A concept album, Xyloto attempted to merge electronic sounds with pop sensibilities and fell flat. Frontman Chris Martin explained, “We have Justin Bieber and Adele to compete with and they're much younger than us.” Coldplay should’ve let Bieber be Bieber and stayed true to their piano-ballad roots.

        Agree or disagree?

        More Coldplay 

        The Best Coldplay Songs of All TimeThe Best Bands Like Coldplay#335 of 363 Musicians Who Belong In The Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame

      • U2: Pop (1997)
        Video: YouTube
        U2 is a rock band that's always striving to reinvent itself, which has, for the most part, worked for them. That wasn't exactly the case with 1997's Pop, which was a complete departure from the type of alt-rock that fans expected (and wanted). Instead of soaring vocals and clear guitars, Pop delivered electronic dance music bordering on techno that critics just couldn't agree on. The music was good, but it just wasn't U2.
          Agree or disagree?