• Total Nerd

14 Movies That Turned Thin Source Material Into Great Stories

List RulesVote up the movies that turned a few words into a great story.

These days, most of the major movies released by Hollywood are based on something else, whether it's a bestselling novel, a comic book character, a previous movie, or even a video game. Studios like to make films that come with a built-in audience. Knowing there's a base of fans out there helps ensure that their releases have a maximized chance of becoming profitable. In fact, it's getting harder and harder to find a film that's completely, totally original.

On occasion, filmmakers don't just find inspiration in preexisting source material, but in exceptionally thin source material. Children's picture books, magazine articles, a set of trading cards, and even a Twitter thread have become fodder for full-length movies over the past few decades. What's fascinating about this is that the people making these movies have to find ways to stretch out minimal material so that it can fill up a 90-minute to two-hour film. There are some examples of people getting it really wrong - 1987's disastrous sticker-based The Garbage Pail Kids Movie, for example - but each of the following pictures did it very well.

Which of these movies most successfully turned thin source material into a great story? Vote for your top picks.

  • 1

    Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl

    In 1967, Disneyland debuted a new water ride called Pirates of the Caribbean. Using animatronic animals and humans, it took riders on an adventure down a waterfall, through "Dead Man's Cove" (where they were greeted by skeletons), and into the middle of a pirate war, complete with flying cannonballs. The ride also introduced the song "Yo Ho (A Pirate's Life for Me)" into the Disney lexicon. 

    Thirty-six years later, Disney decided to create a cinematic ride from the property. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl kept a few of the characters from the ride, as well as the general plot about the search for treasure. Beyond that, it added characters Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann, and expanded the concept of a supernatural curse, which is only mentioned briefly at the start of the ride. 

    Of course, with live actors and a big budget, the movie was able to achieve action sequences far more elaborate than anything Disneyland could accomplish. The end result was popular enough to spawn four sequels.

    Made the most of it?

    The Best Characters in the Pirates of the Caribbean Movies#18 of 557 The Best Film Scores Of All Time#19 of 306 The Greatest Movie Themes

  • Chris Van Allsburg's picture book Jumanji is only 32 pages long. In it, a brother and sister discover an odd board game at the local park. They take it home to play, only to discover that the dangers in the game become real. Among the hazards they face are a lion running loose in their house. Eventually they finish the game, sending all the jungle creatures back into their fantasy world. The siblings return the game to the park, but later see two other children walking off with it. 

    Once CGI became sophisticated enough to create realistic-looking animals, Hollywood jumped at the chance to turn Jumanji into a film. Directed by Joe Johnston, it cast Robin Williams as Alan Parrish, a guy who, we learn in a flashback, played the game in 1969 and subsequently became trapped inside of it for 26 years. Only when two siblings move into his family's old mansion and discover the board game is he finally let loose. Jumanji essentially expands everything in Van Allsburg's book, amping up the action and exploring the emotions inherent in the concept.

    Made the most of it?

    #89 of 381 The Best Movies Based On Books#53 of 1,436 The Most Rewatchable Movies#46 of 440 The Best Movies Of The 1990s

  • The Nightmare Before Christmas originated with a poem Tim Burton wrote while working as an animator at Disney. It tells the story of Jack Skellington, a resident of Halloweenland who becomes disenchanted with what he sees as the monotony of his life. Upon stumbling into Christmas Town, Jack comes to believe that the grass is greener in this realm. He then kidnaps Santa - with the best of intentions - and attempts to do his job, only to terrify children with the horrific "toys" he delivers. In the end, he returns to Halloween Town feeling like a failure, until a pep talk from Santa makes him feel better about his place in life.

    It's a good tale, and a natural one for the stop-motion animation Burton and director Henry Selick brought to The Nightmare Before Christmas when it hit screens in 1993. Aside from fully envisioning Halloween Town, the movie also expands on the story, adding love interest Sally, plus a nemesis in the form of Oogie Boogie. Burton and Selick also turned it into a musical with songs from former Oingo Boingo frontman Danny Elfman. The poem was a blueprint for the film, which took the basic story and spun a whole world from it.

    Made the most of it?

    'The Nightmare Before Christmas' Fan Theories That Just Might Be True#6 of 371 The Best Musical Movies Of All Time#107 of 532 The Best Animated Films Ever

  • 4


    It was a big trend in the '70s and '80s to turn hit movies into board games. The makers of Clue did the opposite, turning a board game into a movie. The game has players assuming the role of detective. Someone has been slain in a mansion, and by rolling dice and sneaking peeks at other players' cards, you have to assemble the evidence to guess who the killer is, what they used as a weapon, and in which room the slaying took place. The game is addictive and fun.

    Writer/director Jonathan Lynn imagined Clue as a star-studded mystery comedy. The 1985 film maintains the general idea of a murder inside a mansion. It retains the game's colorfully named characters - Professor Plum, Colonel Mustard, Mrs. Peacock, etc. Of course, the game has no plot, so Lynn had to create one out of whole cloth, taking the time to develop the suspects, in addition to devising motives for each character to commit the central crime. 

    In perhaps the shrewdest move, Clue cinematically recreated the "different outcome every time" element that makes the game replayable. The movie was released to theaters with three different endings. Depending on where you saw it, the murder was committed either by Miss Scarlet, Mrs. Peacock, or everyone except Mr. Green.

    Made the most of it?

    #96 of 512 The Greatest Movies Of The 1980s, Ranked#113 of 929 The All-Time Greatest Comedy Films#183 of 375 'Old' Movies Every Young Person Needs To Watch In Their Lifetime