15 Movies With Great Ideas Ruined By Terrible Execution  

Justin Andress
10.1k votes 2.5k voters 207.7k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the movies with wasted potential that most make you want to reach for your Brett Ratner voodoo doll.

What’s your favorite good bad movie? Everyone has one, be it an adaptation that was botched between the page and the screen or a picture with horrible execution that resulted in a ruined premise. The fundamental truth of these movies that failed to deliver but are still loved by some is that they could've been much, much better. 

Hollywood is littered with failed films that should have worked. It seems like every year gifts a handful of awful movies with great ideas, films in which flashes of brilliance are lost in a sea of mediocrity. In the wide world of cinema, there are few things more depressing than movies that could've been great but turned out crap, because you can see the greatness within them, trapped, forever unable to get free. In some ways it's worse than a movie that's terrible in every way, because at least those aren't wasting potential. 

Steel is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 15 Movies With Great Ideas Ruined By Terrible Execution
Photo:  Warner Bros.

In the comics, John Henry Irons puts on a metal suit and goes on a solo quest to rid his streets of super weapons he designed. It's an enthralling undertaking, in which he tries to make up for a sin committed several years earlier. If you're noticing any parallels to Iron Man, the good folks at DC would like you to please ignore that. The character’s initial solo series, which arrived after he tried to be Superman (a matter for another day), was the origin of a new hero who traded on wits and served the little guy. It’s stirring shiznaz.

Then, some dillhole decided to make a movie starring Shaquille O’Neal in the lead, because John Henry Irons is a tall fella, get it? Never mind that casting a slow-talking basketball player as a brilliant scientist is an even sillier concept than casting him as a genieSteel is a mess from start to finish.

O’Neal sucks, his supporting cast (including villain Judd Nelson) is static, and the story is so predictable not even one of the great NBA players of all time, clad in laughable metal armor, can get a rise out of the audience. It’s a seriously terrible movie that’s not even bad enough to be funny.

More Steel

#60 of 60 on The Funniest Superhero Movies Ever Made #44 of 44 on The Best Guilty Pleasure Comic Book Movies #8 of 20 on The Best Black Superhero Movies #45 of 51 on The Best Action Movies of 1997

Was this executed terribly?
see more on Steel
X-Men: The Last Stand is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 15 Movies With Great Ideas Ruined By Terrible Execution
Photo:  20th Century Fox

There may not be enough time left on Earth to fully explain how great a sin Brett Ratner committed with X-Men: The Last Stand. Following two wonderful installments from Bryan Singer (who was off disappointing fans with Superman Returns), The Last Stand simultaneously mutilates two of the comic world's most acclaimed story lines.

The studio cycled through a number of directors before Ratner finally signed on. Those who turned the role down or left the project include Darren Aronofsky, Joss Whedon, Zack Snyder, and Matthew Vaughn. Yet Ratner can't take full credit for The Last Stand - co-writers Simon Kinberg and Zak Penn deserve equal billing in the credits of this catastrophe. Together, they concocted the idea of blending the Phoenix saga with a story about a cure for mutants.

What could have been two or three movies worth of content was rushed out the door with middling effort and a Michael Bay-like reliance on spectacle-over-character. This  mentality directly contradicts the thoughtful social commentary, philosophical insight, and contained action set pieces.

More X-Men: The Last Stand

#54 of 187 on The Best Superhero Movies Ever Made #81 of 162 on The Greatest Comic Book Movies of All Time #66 of 73 on The Dumbest Movie Sequel Titles #43 of 93 on The Best Third Films In A Movie Series

Was this executed terribly?
see more on X-Men: The Last Stand
The Island of Dr. Moreau is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 15 Movies With Great Ideas Ruined By Terrible Execution
Photo:  Newline Cinema

The 1996 adaptation of HG Wells’s eponymous novel was a behind-the-scenes disaster from day one. Val Kilmer was an impossible egomaniac, Marlon Brando was as eccentric as you might expect (he suggested a final act twist in which it's revealed his character is a dolphin). Kilmer strong-armed producers into casting him in a different role than they initially offered him so he had to work fewer days, then got mad other characters had more lines than him. Brando refused to learn his lines; instead, an assistant read them to him via earpiece.

Add to that background insanity the fact that the manimal costumes used by the extras — some of which were homeless rainforest dwellers, by the way — were really sad, and that visionary underground sci-fi director Richard Stanley, who conceptualized the film and wrote the script, was fired and replaced by dgaf tyrant John Frankenheimer, and you’ve got a sad, limp interpretation of one of Wells’s most thought-provoking novels.

More The Island of Dr. Moreau

#2 of 14 on These Movies Almost Came To A Halt Because Of The Lead Actors' Nightmare Behavior #7 of 12 on 12 Major Films With So Many Development And On Set Disasters They Almost Didn't Happen #17 of 31 on The Best Horror Movies About Evil Doctors and Surgeons featuring The Making Of The Island Of Dr. Moreau Was A Disastrous Nightmare

Was this executed terribly?
see more on The Island of Dr. Moreau
Masters of the Universe is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 15 Movies With Great Ideas Ruined By Terrible Execution
Photo:  Paramount

If there’s one surefire way to ruin a solid fantasy premise, it’s transplanting characters from their fantasy world to the time and place in which the film was made. With the notable exception of Thor, these movies all play out the same way, and the story always suffers. This is exactly what ruined the solid, simple, good vs. evil premise of Masters of the Universe.

He-Man and his buddies had enough built-in weirdness without inter-dimensional adventure. The show starred a muscle-bound dummy who lived undercover as a mondo wuss, rode a big green cat into battle, and waged eternal war against a magical skeleton. There was no need for He-Man and his peeps to take a magical journey to the 1980s, where they got help from Courteney Cox and her boyfriend.

If the film had focused on the war against Skeletor (and cast someone other than Dolph Lundgren in the starring role), it might have been a different story entirely.

More Masters of the Universe

#28 of 128 on The Best Free Movies On YouTube, Ranked #21 of 50 on 50 Movies That Contained Future Stars #6 of 24 on The Best Superhero Movies of the 1980s #7 of 20 on Terrible Movies You Have To See Before You Die

Was this executed terribly?
see more on Masters of the Universe