Total Nerd The Hardest Dark Souls Bosses to Defeat  

Zachary James Niblick
1.7k votes 371 voters 45.1k views 9 items

Dark Souls bosses are really tough to beat. That makes sense, since Dark Souls is, without a doubt, one of the most brutal and frustrating experiences in the history of video games. It harkens back to the days of Megaman, Contra, and Ninja Gaiden, when bosses forced gamers to use every conceivable trick they learned along the way. Because it's so difficult, every minor victory in Dark Souls is a cathartic experience. This is the beautifully twisted premise behind Dark Souls... the game stretches you to your limits, only to leave you with an unmatched sense of accomplishment for every successful encounter. 

From trudging through the depths of literal hell to squaring off against gigantic Lovecraftian beasts, Dark Souls has perfected the art of deriving pleasure from punishment. 

That's why we've compiled a list of the most brutal, most terrifying, and most impossible boss battles from Dark Souls, along with a few helpful tips and strategies to beat them. You should expect to find no DLC content here, as this list pertains only to the original release. Bear in mind that these bosses are in no way a definitive collection of the worst frustrations Dark Souls has to offer; it's only the most challenging bosses in the game.

Vote up the most frustrating Dark Souls boss battles and feel free to leave a comment about the bosses that gave you the most trouble

1 276 VOTES

Ornstein and Smough

Ornstein and Smough is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Hardest Dark Souls Bosses to Defeat
Photo: via Imgur

Let's just talk about S&O for a quick second, shall we? Ask anyone masochistic enough to have made it this far in Dark Souls just who the toughest boss is and they'll likely point to this pair.

There are about 10,000 ways Ornstein and Smough could leave you in a puddle on that gorgeous marble floor, but this fight's sheer brutality can be summed up by one distinct fact: you have to fight them both at the same time.

This isn't exactly uncharted territory for Dark Souls by any means, but what sets this boss battle apart is that you aren't fighting two of the same thing. S&O function independently: they each posses a very calculated skill set optimized to balance the other's attacks to ensure your timely demise. Ornstein will charge across the room and knock you to the floor with his spear while Smough flanks, and crushes you with his hammer before you're able to get back on your feet.  

But that's not all, folks! Because when you kill one of the two, the remaining a-hole will absorb the other's power, gain an HP, damage, and resistance boost, and heal all the way back to 100%.

Wait, there's more! They'll also take on the physical characteristics of the other: Ornstein will grow to Smough's giant size while Smough gains Ornstein's lightning power. 

Yeah. Good luck. 
241 35
Agree or disagree?
2 216 VOTES

The Four Kings

The Four Kings is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Hardest Dark Souls Bosses to Defeat
Photo: via Twitter

I don't think I've ever felt as "stuck" in Dark Souls as I did during my first playthrough against the Four Kings. No matter what I tried, I simply couldn't beat them fast enough. 

You see, the whole shtick with these guys is that four ghastly, suspiciously androgynous, apparitions appear one at a time at offset intervals. Essentially, you're given a stupidly short amount of time to slay one of the Kings before another one pops up. If you haven't beaten one yet, too bad, here's another. This continues until all four Kings are attacking you at once - at which point you're almost certainly dead. 

This boss battle is a nightmare. There's a constant dread that the next King could show up at any moment and wreck every ounce of progress you've made against his compatriots. At the end of the day, the Four Kings fight is just a morbid pretense through and through.

I mean, you don't even fight them on solid ground. To simply challenge the Kings without dying, you have to have a certain ring equipped that lets you walk on thin air in the Abyss. Ring slots aren't infinite, so yeah... that sucks. 
117 99
Agree or disagree?
3 211 VOTES

Capra Demon

Capra Demon is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Hardest Dark Souls Bosses to Defeat
Photo: via Wikimedia

All told, the Capra Demon really ain't so bad. Just look at that face. 

By the time you've trudged through to the end of Dark Souls, you've been beaten and bruised by every baddie in the book enough times over that your fight with Capra early on seems like afternoon tea. That's a nice sentiment from the endgame throne, but let's think back to when you first got to the Undead Burg; the Capra Demon fight is when Dark Souls gets real.

Sure, the Bell Gargoyles are probably your first major slap in the face - "Wow, I've almost beaten him... Wait, what's that noise? Oh, there's another one..." 

But despite the initial shock of double vision, you inevitably figure out that the right combination of strafing, dodging, blocking, and just a liiiiittle bit of elbow grease takes the Gargoyles down. Not so with Capra. The Capra Demon is the first time Dark Souls flips you upside down, shakes your lunch money out of your pockets, and leaves you for dead in a post-swirly coma.
70 141
Agree or disagree?
4 183 VOTES

Honorable Mention: Havel the Rock

Honorable Mention: Havel the R... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Hardest Dark Souls Bosses to Defeat
Photo: via Wikimedia

Some things in life just refuse to die. And while abominations like the disco suit and the Macarena eventually packed up and headed to Florida to whittle away their remaining years, the unfortunate truth about Havel the Rock is that he'll be around forever. He will never die.

Even when you finally send this mini-boss south for good, he stays in your nightmares, taunting you.  

It speaks volumes about this fight's difficulty that beating Havel will fill you with a more greater sense of accomplishment than taking down half of the actual bosses in Dark Souls. Chipping away at this guy feels a bit as productive as tossing toothpicks at a moving boulder. It's incredibly easy for low vitality players to die in one hit, and even the most buffed up warriors won't fare well once Havel's hammer lands an extra swing or two. 

Thankfully, he's not the brightest fellow. If you're feeling cheap, you can simply lure him to the top of the stairs and jump off. He'll follow you down and take a nice chunk of damage upon impact. Heal or use Fall Control to keep yourself alive long enough to rinse and repeat this process and the fight's yours.
61 122
Agree or disagree?