Weird History

20 Historical Facts That Movies Got Totally Wrong  

Ranker News
383.7k views 20 items

History class is tough – there are lots of dates and names to remember. But when you're making a historical movie, you'd think Hollywood would do some extra fact-checking. Not all films, even if they are historical films about real-life figures and actual events, fully honor their original source material. On this list, films from all decades are revealed as having botched the reality of supposed non-fiction and reminded audiences that they were just Hollywood flicks. From Foxcatcher to Hotel Rwanda, and even 1915's The Birth of a Nation, many films feature blatant errors and historical inaccuracies that will annoy more than just the average history buff. For example, while George Clooney spiced up the third act of Good Night, and Good Luck, its timeline and the implications of that timeline are way off-base.

This list covers more than just the Hollywood endings, however. The opening scene of American Sniper, for instance, feeds into the claims of Clint Eastwood's "pro-military propaganda" by making an Iraqi woman look evil by giving her son an anti-tank grenade, which never, ever happened.

So what historical facts has Hollywood gotten completely wrong? Read on to find out and be sure to up-vote the most egregious history mistakes in these Hollywood movies.

Lincoln is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 20 Historical Facts That Movies Got Totally Wrong
Photo:  Lincoln/Walt Disney Pictures

Even Lincoln's screenwriter, Tony Kushner, confessed to this historical misrepresentation. One of the glaring inaccuracies in the film that won Daniel Day Lewis his third Academy Award is that Connecticut was portrayed as voting "no" on the 13th Amendment – a vote against ending slavery. In fact, every single representative in Connecticut's House voted "yes" for the amendment.

More Lincoln

#26 of 232 on The Best Movies Based on True Stories #86 of 708 on The Best Movies Roger Ebert Gave Four Stars #1 of 57 on The Best US Civil War Movies Ever Made #12 of 33 on The Best Steven Spielberg Movies

see more on Lincoln
Apollo 13 is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 20 Historical Facts That Movies Got Totally Wrong
Photo:  Apollo 13/Universal Pictures

Ron Howard's film chronicling the Apollo 13 mission featured astronaut Ken Mattingly being involved with the rescue mission, although Mattingly himself confesses to this historical falsity. In the film, he was exposed to measles (true) and bumped from the mission (true) before NASA called him back to lead rescue efforts (false). In reality, Mattingly said he had absolutely no assigned role in that rescue; he was a backup crew member who worked with a number of teams, not just one or two projects as portrayed in the film.

More Apollo 13

#2 of 232 on The Best Movies Based on True Stories #10 of 708 on The Best Movies Roger Ebert Gave Four Stars #23 of 204 on The Best Adventure Movies featuring Things 'Apollo 13' Got Totally Wrong

see more on Apollo 13
Gladiator is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 20 Historical Facts That Movies Got Totally Wrong
Photo:  Gladiator/DreamWorks Distribution

In the 2000 Russell Crowe movie, Marcus Aurelius was murdered by his own son, Commodus, during a battle in the Marcomannic War. The real Marcus Aurelius died in 180 AD in what is now Vienna. Aurelius actually gave succession to Commodus in real life, a far cry from dying by his hand.

More Gladiator

#31 of 385 on The Best War Movies Ever #28 of 1714 on The Most Rewatchable Movies featuring Gladiator Might Be One of The Most Historically Inaccurate Movies Ever The Bizarre Sequel To 'Gladiator' That Almost Got Made

see more on Gladiator
300: Rise of an Empire is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 20 Historical Facts That Movies Got Totally Wrong
Photo:  300/Warner Bros.

The character of King Darius was portrayed as being present at the Battle of Marathon. The truth is, King Darius wasn't even there, and, in fact, he died four years later of old age. Though it made for a nice plot point, King Darius was not killed with an arrow by Xerxes's father at the Battle.

More 300: Rise of an Empire

#73 of 75 on The Best Action Movie Sequels #11 of 47 on The Best Sword and Sandal Films Ever Made #31 of 40 on The Best Comic Book Movies Rated R #9 of 9 on The Best Movies Produced by Bernie Goldmann

see more on 300: Rise of an Empire