Graveyard Shift

Comedies That Are Horror Films From the Supporting Character's Perspective  

Jacob Shelton
4k votes 918 voters 46k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the movies that would be horror movies from somebody else's point of view.

The most popular comedic characters all have one thing in common - they don’t care about anyone but themselves. They put their needs and goals in front of everyone else; too bad if you’re in their way.

Oddly enough, that's the exact same way a killer in a horror film acts. And from the perspectives of the supporting characters, many so-called comedies are actually pretty grim. 

Some such films are obviously horrific, but others only reveal their true, macabre nature after you take a closer look. The next time you’re watching a screwball comedy, remember the supporting characters are dying inside, terrified of what the main character’s going to do. Comedy is all about perspective. 

The Switch is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Comedies That Are Horror Films From the Supporting Character's Perspective
Photo:  Lionsgate

Admittedly, Jennifer Aniston never plays a supporting character, but what she goes through in The Switch is nothing short of terrifying. Kassie Larson just wants to have a kid with a sperm donor, but her creep of a "best friend" swaps out the donor's sperm sample with his own seed at a party, forcing her to secretly raise his child.

This is basically what the villain of 2016's crime thriller Don't Breathe does to an unsuspecting woman. Who thought the premise sounded like a romantic comedy?

Actors: Jennifer Aniston, Jeff Goldblum, Juliette Lewis, Jason Bateman, Patrick Wilson, + more

Released: 2010

Directed by: Will Speck, Josh Gordon

More The Switch

#27 of 68 on The Best Jeff Goldblum Movies #10 of 39 on The Very Best Jennifer Aniston Movies #3 of 40 on The Best Jason Bateman Movies #19 of 50 on The Best Juliette Lewis Movies

Is this horrifying from their viewpoint?
see more on The Switch
50 First Dates is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Comedies That Are Horror Films From the Supporting Character's Perspective
Photo:  Sony Pictures Home Entertainment

Is there anyone on the planet who isn't horrified for Lucy Whitmore in 50 First Dates? After suffering a massive head trauma, the woman believes she's living the same day over and over.

Whitmore's friends and family do everything they can to keep her from realizing anything's changed, but she's aging and the world is slowly leaving her behind. Then Henry Roth comes into town and decides to take her on a date. Even after her family (who are all terrible people) tell Roth about her condition, he persists in pursuing Lucy and by the end of the film she's pregnant with his child.

By this logic, she wakes up one day and everyone's like, "by the way you're pregnant."

Actors: Drew Barrymore, Adam Sandler, Dan Aykroyd, Rob Schneider, Maya Rudolph, + more

Released: 2004

Directed by: Peter Segal

More 50 First Dates

#25 of 810 on The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made #19 of 170 on The Greatest Date Movies of All Time #12 of 15 on Movies You Never Realized Have Super Bleak Endings featuring 50 First Dates Isn't Romantic - It's About A Guy Who Takes Advantage Of A Disabled Woman

Is this horrifying from their viewpoint?
see more on 50 First Dates
My Best Friend's Wedding is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Comedies That Are Horror Films From the Supporting Character's Perspective
Photo:  Sony Home Picture Entertainment

Kimmy Wallace is just trying to have a nice wedding. She's so focused on her dream, she doesn't realize she's stepped in the middle of the toxic relationship between longtime "friends" Julianne and Michael.

When Kimmy asks Julianne - a woman who's in love with her fiance - to act as her maid of honor, the bride-to-be essentially seals her fate as a victim. Throughout the film Julianne commits one horrible act after another in the name of stealing Wallace's fiance.

Julianne exploits every one of her romantic rival's weak spots, even breaking into Kimmy's father's email in an attempt to stop the wedding. This is psychological terror at its most pure. 

Actors: Julia Roberts, Dermot Mulroney, Rupert Everett, Cameron Diaz, Paul Giamatti, + more

Released: 1997

Directed by: P. J. Hogan

More My Best Friend's Wedding

#93 of 493 on The Funniest '90s Movies #31 of 810 on The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made #26 of 170 on The Greatest Date Movies of All Time featuring My Best Friend's Wedding Is The Most Twisted, Screwed Up Rom-Com Ever Made

Is this horrifying from their viewpoint?
see more on My Best Friend's Wedding
Shrek is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Comedies That Are Horror Films From the Supporting Character's Perspective
Photo:  Universal Pictures Home Entertainment

Everyone loves Shrek, a heartwarming tale about learning to love yourself that takes a detour into Hostel territory somewhere near the end of the second act.

For everyone but the Gingerbread Man, this film is a tiptoe through the tulips, but when the poor cookie is captured by Lord Farquaad his life is utterly destroyed. Not only are his legs removed and crumbled to dust in front of him, but his gumdrop buttons are pulled off and chewed up before his eyes. This is terrifying, yet it's a thing Dreamworks thought would be cool to show children. 

Actors: Cameron Diaz, Eddie Murphy, Mike Myers, John Lithgow, Vincent Cassel, + more

Released: 2001

Directed by: Andrew Adamson, Vicky Jenson

More Shrek

#10 of 599 on The Best Animated Films Ever #26 of 410 on The Best Rainy Day Movies featuring 12 Things You Never Knew About The Making Of 'Shrek' Adult Jokes in the Shrek Movies That Went Over Your Head

Is this horrifying from their viewpoint?
see more on Shrek