Graveyard Shift

Pretty Good Horror Movies That Will Make You Afraid To Go In The Water  

Megan Summers
920 votes 157 voters 2.9k views 14 items

List Rules Vote up the films that make you fear the water.

Lakes. Rivers. Ponds. Oceans. Shallows. Seas. No matter the body of water, our cultural obsession with what lies beneath has spawned some of the most frightening cinematic scenarios. Jaws set the tone in 1975 for the water-based creature feature, and in subsequent decades, other filmmakers have sought to ruin any remaining sense of comfort for swimmers, surfers, boaters, and floaters.

The films on this list will make you think twice about taking that quick dip. Hold your breath and dive in, if you dare.

Open Water is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Pretty Good Horror Movies That Will Make You Afraid To Go In The Water
Photo: Lions Gate Films

Open Water's simple yet groundbreaking concept is the stuff of nightmares: two divers in Australia are accidentally abandoned in shark-infested waters. Cue 80 minutes of watching the pair drift and float as their imminent doom closes in upon them. There are no paranormal menaces or government-made super fish needed to make this a horrific story.

This low-budget film ends exactly how you'd imagine, but it's the wait that fills viewers with the most dread. What's even worse is that it's based on a true story, which means it could happen to any of us.

Does this make water scary?
see more on Open Water
Deep Blue Sea is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Pretty Good Horror Movies That Will Make You Afraid To Go In The Water
Photo: Warner Bros.

Despite its critical status as a B horror movie, Deep Blue Sea manages to deliver plenty of scares. Imagine a group of scientistic and engineers navigating flooded underwater corridors while genetically engineered sharks stalk them. Imagine Samuel L. Jackson getting dragged into the water by a sharp-toothed mako in the middle of a dramatic monologue. Imagine L.L. Cool J and Thomas Jane fighting for their lives as they watch their fellow crew members get devoured.

Deep Blue Sea is remembered for its claustrophobic, action-packed take on what happens when people mess with nature. It even generated a sequel in 2018.

The next time you're at the beach and see a fin in the distance, you better hope it's not a lab-made shark that has gone rogue and turned into a slaying machine.

Does this make water scary?
see more on Deep Blue Sea
Anaconda is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Pretty Good Horror Movies That Will Make You Afraid To Go In The Water
Photo: Columbia Pictures

Nothing screams late-'90s mainstream action-horror like watching Jennifer Lopez and Ice Cube get chased around by colossal water-bound snakes. Anaconda follows a documentary crew as they focus on Shirishama tribe life along the Amazon River. Instead, they find themselves the focus of a pair of dangerous snakes. Waterfalls, murky knee-high water, and deep jungle foliage set an exotic backdrop for a contemporary take on the human versus predator trope. Anaconda is a slithering, pulpy feeding frenzy. 

While disliked by critics, the movie was commercially successful, earning over $16 million on its opening weekend.

Does this make water scary?
see more on Anaconda
Lake Placid
Lake Placid is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Pretty Good Horror Movies That Will Make You Afraid To Go In The Water
Photo: 20th Century Fox

It was only a matter of time before a mating pair of giant saltwater crocodiles displaced in a Maine lake started eating people, especially since a reclusive lake dweller played by Betty White has been feeding them for years. Lake Placid's star-studded cast, including Bill Pullman, Bridget Fonda, and Brendan Gleeson, try to protect Black Lake from these 30-foot monstrosities. Removed heads, mangled cows, and dangerous splashes transform this once peaceful lake town into a bloodbath. Eventually, residents have to bring in the heavy artillery to take care of business.

Since its release in 1999, Lake Placid has had five sequels, but none have impacted lake life quite like the original.

Does this make water scary?