VOTE Hot Amish Dudes You’d Like to Take Behind the Barn  

Ashley Reign
2.6k votes 452 voters 26k views 19 items

List Rules Vote up the Amish hotties you'd want to churn your butter.

Though pictures of hot Amish guys may not have prime real estate on your dream board, maybe it's time to make some space. Isolated as the Amish seem, that only adds to the mystery that surrounds the occasional guy you see piloting his fly-ass buggy down the road on the way to the local farmer's market.

Shy as they may seem, here you'll find photos of hot Amish guys doing the things Amish guys do best. Whether they're plowing "fields" or erecting a little timber, you might be surprised at how well some of that hard labor has paid off for these mysterious men.

1 266 VOTES

This Gentleman Wonders If You'd Like Him to Tie Your Bonnet


This Gentleman Wonders If You&... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Hot Amish Dudes You’d Like to Take Behind the Barn
Photo: via meguideu
194 72
Is he hot?
2 199 VOTES

Hey, Girl. Want Us to Pound You Next?


Hey, Girl. Want Us to Pound Yo... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Hot Amish Dudes You’d Like to Take Behind the Barn
Photo: via Forbidden News
146 53
Is he hot?
3 128 VOTES

Hey, Girl. Wanna Churn My Butter?


Hey, Girl. Wanna Churn My Butt... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Hot Amish Dudes You’d Like to Take Behind the Barn
Photo: via Pinterest
92 36
Is he hot?
4 172 VOTES

Hey, Babe. Wanna Ride My Pony?


Hey, Babe. Wanna Ride My Pony? is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Hot Amish Dudes You’d Like to Take Behind the Barn
Photo: via Pinterest
110 62
Is he hot?