Netflix’s Unhinged New Baking Show Has Us Questioning Reality

List Rules
Vote up the cakes that fooled you.

The new baking show Is It Cake just dropped on Netflix and it is unlike anything we've ever seen before. The show can best be described as 'unhinged', as contestants try and fool the judges as to which items are cake, and which aren't. Needless to say, we were left baffled with some of the results, as were many others on the internet. Here are some of the best cakes from the series, with a side of fan reactions. Vote up the cakes that totally fooled you!


  • 1. Nina Put In Work With Those Chips

    Nina Put In Work With Those Chips
    Photo: Is It Cake? / Netlix

     

  • 2. Who Makes The Cash Cakes?

    Who Makes The Cash Cakes?
    Photo: Is It Cake? / Netflix

     

  • 3. Everyone Loves Nina

    Everyone Loves Nina
    Photo: Is It Cake? / Reddit

     

  • 4. April 'Sew' Should Have One

    April 'Sew' Should Have One
    Photo: Is It Cake? / Netflix

     

  • 5. Johnny Cheated!

    Johnny Cheated!
    Photo: Is It Cake? / Netflix

     

  • 6. Those Veggies Are Impeccable

    Those Veggies Are Impeccable
    Photo: Is It Cake? / Netflix