America Utterly Fascinating Theories Behind The Vanishing Roanoke Colony  

Lyra Radford
1.3M views 17 items

The disappearance of the Roanoke colony remains one of the oldest unsolved mysteries in the United States. It all began back in 1587, when Sir Walter Raleigh financed the attempts of John White to establish a colony on Roanoke Island, just off the coast of North Carolina. They landed on July 22, establishing themselves rather quickly, and everything seemed to be going well for the thriving colony of 115 people. In fact, John White’s daughter, Eleanor Dare, gave birth to a daughter while in Roanoke. Little Virginia Dare was born on August 18th and has the title of being the very first English child born in the Americas.

John White set sail back to England to gather fresh supplies, but an attack by the Spanish Armada delayed his return. White finally returned to Roanoke in 1590 after being away from his family for three years, but he arrived to find the entire colony had simply vanished, leaving nothing behind except the word “Croatoan” carved into a post and “Cro” etched into a tree. But what does "Croatoan mean" and where could the colony have gone? 

The Colonists Were Absorbed Into Local Native Tribes as Friends or Slaves

The Colonists Were Absorbed In... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Utterly Fascinating Theories Behind The Vanishing Roanoke Colony
Photo: Public Domain/via Wikimedia Commons

Just south of Roanoke was an island named Croatoan that was home to a Native American tribe of the same name. Since the settlers had developed a good rapport with the tribe and the name “Croatoan” was found, it was assumed the settlers must have moved to the island of Croatoan and been absorbed into the tribe or simply moved inland, perhaps driven off by Spanish troops. Some theorize they moved north to join the Chesapeake tribe, or perhaps the Chowanocs or Weapemeocs, among many others. 

There were many sightings of Europeans and European-made goods in the area in the years following the colony's disappearance, though most were hearsay. The "Zuniga map, a map of the area drawn about 1607 by a settler from Jamestown, states "four men clothed that came from roonock" were living among the Iroquois. Another English man claimed the had seen two-story stone houses at the Indian settlements of Peccarecanick and Ochanahoen; supposedly, English settlers had taught them how to build such houses.

Contemporary archaeologists have found some more verifiable evidence, including a gold signet ring, part of a rapier, and a slate and pencil that may have belonged to the Roanoke colonists living among Native people. 

It is also possible the colonists met with Native people who were less friendly. The contemporary historian William Stachey reported seeing Native tribes with European slaves, who were forced to beat copper.

To this day, many Native people in the region claim to have European ancestry. However, a DNA analysis of present-day local families that hoped to prove the people of Roanoke intermingled with Native people in the area has so far proven inconclusive.

The Colonists at Roanoke Were the Victims of Cannibalism - Or Practiced It Themselves

The Colonists at Roanoke Were ... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Utterly Fascinating Theories Behind The Vanishing Roanoke Colony
Photo: John White/via Wikimedia

There were other tribes in the area that weren’t as friendly as the Croatoan tribe. There was a theory that one of these more aggressive groups, who may have been cannibals, attacked and ate the English colonists. The lack of bodies could just mean there was nothing left: many cultures have used bones as ingredients for healing remedies, grinding them into a powder form. It may sound like a time-consuming task, but it took three years for White to find out they were missing. There’s no way to know exactly when the settlers started disappearing – they could have been picked off one by one.  

There is no evidence that any tribes in the area practiced cannibalism; there is, however, evidence that the colony of Jonestown, Virginia, committed cannibalism in 1609. It’s quite possible their predecessors over in Roanoke succumbed to eating human flesh as well. After their leader left for supplies and didn’t return for three years, they could have been starving. There was also talk from local tribes that the colonists were having a war within their ranks. The people of Roanoke could have resorted to cannibalism and eaten themselves out of existence.

Or perhaps some of them still exist, taken over by the ancient Native American spirit of the wild, known as a wendigo - it was believed that when a human resorted to cannibalism to survive, they might turn into the terrifying beast.

Edgar Allan Poe Had a Mysterious Connection to the Word "Croatoan"

Edgar Allan Poe Had a Mysterio... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Utterly Fascinating Theories Behind The Vanishing Roanoke Colony
Photo: John White/via Wikipedia

The whereabouts of the colony aren’t the only remaining mystery: archeologists and historians alike are still scratching their heads trying to figure out why "Croatoan" was carved into that post in the first place. It clearly wasn’t to point the blame at the tribe, and the colonists didn’t move in with them, so what is the significance of the word? Were they trying to say the Croatoan tribe would know what happened to them? (Giving more weight to the Croatoan’s story about an evil spirit taking over the settlers and the phenomenon with the wildlife.)

The word “Croatoan” has popped up several more times over the last few centuries, each time in connection with mysterious disappearances and nowhere near Roanoke.

The events leading up to the death of Edgar Allan Poe are still a mystery. He disappeared for a spell and when he was seen again he was babbling incoherently in the streets - seemingly drunk, but he wasn’t just drunk, he was delirious. Allegedly, one of the things Poe whispered while on his deathbed in this mysterious state of delirium was the word “Croatoan.”

What illness Poe had and his official cause of death are unknown. All medical records and his death certificate were allegedly lost. Could he have experienced what the lost colony experienced? 

The Word Appears at the Site of Many Other Mysterious Disappearances

The Word Appears at the Site o... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Utterly Fascinating Theories Behind The Vanishing Roanoke Colony
Photo: Public Domain/via Wikipedia

This mysterious word was also found scribbled in the journal of Amelia Earhart after her disappearance in 1937. Horror author Ambrose Bierce vanished in Mexico back in 1913. The bed he slept in last had the word "Croatoan" carved in its post. The notorious stagecoach robber Black Bart etched the word into the wall of his prison cell right before his release in 1888 and was never seen again. "Croatoan" was written on the last page of the logbook of the notorious ghost ship Carroll A. Deering back in 1921, when it ran aground on Cape Hatteras (missing its crew), right by what was once known as Croatoan Island.