Photo: Freebase/Public domain

Actors Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting  

Celebrity Insider
8.1k views 16 items
Here is a list of lucky actors who were considered 2nd-choice casting for classic movie roles. Some of the actors who were considered first were either too young or was not well-suited for the role, while others doubted their acting skills or had issues with payment. Whatever the reason, the actors' issue allowed their runner ups a chance to make it big. Most of these second choice stars were unknown or under-rated actors. Many castings that came off as the quintessential choice often were numbered second, third or even fourth on the 'possibles' list; For this reason, many classic movies became a hit and stars were born. These incredible casting lead accidents have made these films legendary over time. From the state of 'first and only choice', the casting directors ended up signing the last resort actors, but never to regret about it. These are the lucky stars who owe their successes to 2nd-choice casting. This list espouses the 'sour grapes' expression, Hollywood style.

1
Anne Bancroft is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 74 (1931-2005) - The Graduate

2
Clark Gable is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 59 (1901-1960) - Gone With The Wind

3
Dustin Hoffman is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
age 80 - The Graduate

4
Gloria Swanson is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 84 (1899-1983) - Sunset Boulevard

5
Harrison Ford is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
age 75 - Raiders Of The Lost Ark

6
Humphrey Bogart is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 58 (1899-1957) - Casablanca

7
Ingrid Bergman is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 67 (1915-1982) - Anastasia

8
John Cassavetes is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 60 (1929-1989) - Rosemary's Baby

9
Judy Garland is listed (or ranked) 9 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 47 (1922-1969) - Wizard Of Oz

10
Katharine Hepburn is listed (or ranked) 10 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 96 (1907-2003) - Suddenly Last Summer

11
Marlon Brando is listed (or ranked) 11 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 80 (1924-2004) - On The Waterfront

12
Mia Farrow is listed (or ranked) 12 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
age 73 - The Great Gatsby, Rosemary's Baby

13
Peter O'Toole is listed (or ranked) 13 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 81 (1932-2013) - Lawrence Of Arabia

14
Tony Curtis is listed (or ranked) 14 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
The Defiant Ones

15
Vivien Leigh is listed (or ranked) 15 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 54 (1913-1967) - A Streetcar Named Desire

16
William Holden is listed (or ranked) 16 on the list Lucky Stars: Actors Who Got Lucky With 2nd-choice Casting
Died at 63 (1918-1981) - Sunset Boulevard