Button Mash

The Best Madden NFL Cover Athletes  

Arthur Roderick
3.7k votes 536 voters 350.1k views 21 items

List Rules Vote for your favorite Madden NFL cover athletes.

Each year since 1999, the Madden NFL video game has selected one notable National Football League player to grace the cover of the game. These Madden NFL cover athletes were each selected for the honor for one reason or another, such as being the best in the league at their position, winning the Super Bowl or doing something really awesome.

The popular football video game was first released in 1988 and initially featured Pro Football Hall of Fame former player turned broadcaster John Madden on the cover. In 1999, Electronic Arts started the trend of selecting one NFL player to appear on the cover, thus starting the Madden NFL cover athlete tradition. Garrison Hearst was the first to take the cover from Madden, appearing on the video game in 1999. Many of the best quarterbacks of all time have also graced the cover since.

While the Madden NFL cover athletes receive the distinction of gracing the cover of the video game and landing in the homes of millions of football fans around the globe, many believe that with great glory comes the Madden Curse.

Similar to athletes who have appeared on the cover of Sports Illustrated magazine, many who were selected to appear on Madden NFL saw some sort of misfortune in the following season such as injury or legal trouble. Accordingly, fans often campaign against their favorite player appearing on the cover out of fear of the curse.

Curse or not, just like the NCAA Football cover athletes, the football players who have appeared on Madden NFL received a great honor that will be remembered for years to come. Vote up the best Madden NFL covers, for all Madden covers, and let everyone know who you think was most affected by the Madden curse in the comments section.
Calvin Johnson is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list The Best Madden NFL Cover Athletes
Photo: via Pinterest
1 279 VOTES

More Calvin Johnson

#28 of 254 on People Who Should Be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame #36 of 1390 on The Best Football Players Ever #2 of 109 on The Best Detroit Lions of All Time #4 of 251 on The Best Wide Receivers of All Time

Agree or disagree?
see more on Calvin Johnson
Larry Fitzgerald is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list The Best Madden NFL Cover Athletes
Photo: via Imgur
2 222 VOTES
Alongside Troy Polamalu, Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Larry Fitzgerald was the second player on the Madden NFL 2010 cover. Fitzgerald faced Polamalu in Super Bowl XLIII and though the Cardinals were on the losing end of the game, Fitzgerald set several league postseason records and was recognized by the video game.

More Larry Fitzgerald

#5 of 254 on People Who Should Be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame #34 of 1390 on The Best Football Players Ever #31 of 46 on The 50 Hottest Men in the NFL #17 of 57 on Who Is the Best Wide Receiver in the NFL Right Now?

Agree or disagree?
see more on Larry Fitzgerald
Adrian Peterson is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list The Best Madden NFL Cover Athletes
Photo: via Imgur

For Madden 25 EA Sports polled fans as to who should grace the cover. The people voted and EA Sports listened--kind of. In April, legendary Detroit Lions running back Barry Sanders defeated Minnesota Vikings' Adrian Peterson in the finals of a tournament to determine who would grace the 25th edition of the Madden video game franchise.

Now, EA Sports is splitting the honor, leaving Sanders as the cover athlete for the XBox 360 and PlayStation 3 versions of the game, while going with Peterson for the next generation consoles, XBox One and PlayStation 4.

More Adrian Peterson

#5 of 199 on The Best NFL Running Backs of All Time #71 of 127 on The Greatest Washington Redskins of All Time #46 of 1390 on The Best Football Players Ever #18 of 46 on The 50 Hottest Men in the NFL

Agree or disagree?
see more on Adrian Peterson
Drew Brees is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list The Best Madden NFL Cover Athletes
Photo: via Imgur
4 245 VOTES
Bringing joy to an area devastated by Hurricane Katrina, Drew Brees and the New Orleans Saints won their first Super Bowl in 2010. As one bonus for the accomplishment, Brees was named the cover athlete for Madden NFL 2011 as selected by voters.

More Drew Brees

#9 of 219 on The Best Quarterbacks of All Time #4 of 51 on The Greatest College Football Quarterbacks of All Time #27 of 1390 on The Best Football Players Ever #26 of 46 on The 50 Hottest Men in the NFL

Agree or disagree?
see more on Drew Brees