Total Nerd Casting Call for Mary Jane Watson  

Ranker Comics
6k votes 660 voters 16.5k views 30 items

List Rules Vote up and rerank your favorite casting choices for Mary-Jane Watson!

Mary Jane Watson Parker, the ultimate girl next door, the redheaded supermodel dream girl. She's funny, spunky, and is always ready to party. She also has a heart of gold and has more patience and tolerance for Spidey's madness than anyone else. Needless to say... she's hard to cast.

With Shailene Woodley being cast and then cut from Amazing Spider-Man 2, for pacing reasons, her involvement in the third seems unlikely (but with Fault in our Stars and Divergent, we're not too worried about her). So who do we cast as this dream woman?

It takes more than just being a pretty ginger to fill these designer shoes (can you imagine Lindsey Lohan as MJ?). We need a mix of talent, beauty, intelligence, charm, and heart to really hit the jackpot.

We think these actresses have what it takes to find that fine line between party mode and heart, these are the best actresses to play Mary Jane Watson!
1 411 VOTES

Amber Heard


Amber Heard is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Casting Call for Mary Jane Watson
Photo: Mariya Butd/flickr/CC-BY 2.0
Vibrant, fiesty, and with supermodel good looks, Amber Heard is certainly the head-turner that Mary Jane would have to be.

Also Ranked

#5 on The Most Beautiful Women In Hollywood

#18 on The Most Beautiful Women Of 2018, Ranked

#32 on The Most Beautiful Women in the World

#55 on Who Is America's Sweetheart in 2018?

243 168
Would this be a great call?
see more on Amber Heard
2 460 VOTES

Karen Gillan


Karen Gillan is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Casting Call for Mary Jane Watson
Photo: via Twitter
A gorgeous, natural redhead with a penchant for geekdom (Doctor Who, Guardians of the Galaxy) Karen would make an amazing MJ.

Also Ranked

#15 on Celebrities Who Should Be A-Listers

#31 on The Most Beautiful Women Of 2018, Ranked

#1 on The Best Living Scottish Actresses

#8 on The Best Actresses Of 2018, Ranked

243 217
Would this be a great call?
see more on Karen Gillan
3 352 VOTES

Jane Levy


Jane Levy is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Casting Call for Mary Jane Watson
Photo: via Reddit
She has a very comic book character look about her, she's a talented actress, and she has a great fan following. A perfect addition to the Marc Webb Spider-Verse.
172 180
Would this be a great call?
see more on Jane Levy
4 339 VOTES

Emma Stone


Emma Stone is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Casting Call for Mary Jane Watson
Photo: via Tumblr
Stone could appear in a world where Norman Osborn was introduced for five minutes and then appears as just a head in a "Futurama"-esque stasis head-tank. Why not let her go back red and keep the Garfield/Stone charm going.

Also Ranked

#43 on The Best Actresses Working Today

#18 on The Most Beautiful Women In Hollywood

#72 on The Best Actresses in Film History

#16 on The Most Beautiful Women Of 2018, Ranked

162 177
Would this be a great call?
see more on Emma Stone