Total Nerd

'Moana' Fan Theories That Might Just Be Right  

Jodi Smith
1.7k votes 343 voters 10.4k views 14 items

List Rules Vote up the most plausible theories.

It's no surprise that Disney animated films are a popular playground for fan theories in various places across the web. This includes one of Disney's newest films, Moana. Moana fan theories run the gamut from explaining why she has a mystical connection to the ocean to how Maui managed to relieve her of her boat. Some of the following Reddit theories seem more plausible than others, but any of them may be exactly on point. 

1
The Heart Keeps Moana Safe
The Heart Keeps Moana Safe is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 'Moana' Fan Theories That Might Just Be Right
Photo: Walt Disney Animation

Redditor u/SketchesFromMidgard speculates that since the Heart of Te Feti is able to grant life to vegetation, humans, and animals, it also protects Moana from danger while in her possession. Previously, Maui took the Heart from its rightful place and faced the wrath of lava monster Te Ka. Since Maui had the Heart, a strike from Te Ka did not burn or end him but only knocked the stone into the ocean depths. 

Gramma Tala gives the stone to Moana and almost immediately afterward becomes sick and passes away. The stone kept Gramma Tala from harm all of those years, so it does the same for Moana on her journey to return it. That is why Moana survives the storm that washes her up onto Maui's island, the fall into the Realm of Monsters, and the confrontation with the coconut assailants. 

Does this theory hold water?
2
Moana Is Offed By The Ocean To Come Back As A Demigod
Moana Is Offed By The Ocean To... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 'Moana' Fan Theories That Might Just Be Right
Photo: Walt Disney Animation

Moana sets sail to find Maui so he can lead her to the rightful location of the Heart of Te Fiti. Following a terrible storm, the princess wakes up on an island whose only inhabitant is Maui. Redditor u/87StickUpKid theorizes that the ocean took the life of Moana in the storm so that she could be reborn as a demigod.

Later in the film, Moana is able to push a stone statue over, fight hundreds of coconut people assailing her boat, and even free dive to the bottom of the ocean to retrieve the Heart. These do not seem to be things a mortal human can do, u/87StickUpKid claims, but a demigod like Maui can. The Redditor further notes that Moana enters and leaves the Realm of Monsters, a place where Maui says no mortals can go.

Does this theory hold water?
3
The Ocean Doesn't Trust Maui To Return The Stone On His Own
The Ocean Doesn't Trust Maui T... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 'Moana' Fan Theories That Might Just Be Right
Photo: Walt Disney Animation

During the course of the movie, Maui asks why the ocean would choose a young girl with no sailing experience to return the Heart of Te Fiti to its rightful location. Why not have Maui return what he took? Or why couldn't the ocean, which is shown to have anthropomorphic traits, replace the stone itself? Redditor u/graaah speculates that the ocean knows Maui is afraid of Te Ka and will not willingly take on the task. Maui is required for the mission, but another person is needed to push the demigod into action. 

The ocean doesn't know where to return the Heart, but Maui does. Moana is chosen for her ability to persevere and drive Maui into action to complete his part of the ocean's plan.

Does this theory hold water?
4
Moana's Grandmother Poses As The Ocean Spirit
Moana's Grandmother Poses As T... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 'Moana' Fan Theories That Might Just Be Right
Photo: Walt Disney Animation

Redditor u/copernic10 believes that the ocean didn't choose Moana for the arduous journey to retrieve Maui and gain his help to return the Heart of Te Fiti to its rightful place. Instead, Gramma Tala picked Moana for the task so their people could become great explorers of the oceans once again. The Redditor points to the conversation between Maui and Moana where the demigod reveals he's never heard of an Ocean God, making it improbable that one exists.

Redditor u/Kizadek poses a similar theory with an important twist: Gramma Tala sends Moana on her quest because Tala is the Ocean God herself. The Redditor cites the following clues: Gramma Tala dances with the ocean, she tells Moana she saw her receive the Heart of Te Fiti as a child when she wasn't visibly present, and Tala is the one that insists to Moana that the ocean chose her. Furthermore, when Gramma Tala posthumously appears to Moana, she laments putting so much onto her granddaughter's shoulders - a sign that Tala is the Ocean God that chose Moana for the task.

Does this theory hold water?