Total Nerd

14 Monsters You Don't Want To Admit You Have A Crush On  

Hannah Collins
2.8k votes 346 voters 7.3k views 14 items

List Rules Vote up the monster hotties you wouldn't mind haunting your dreams tonight.

In fantasy and horror-based media, we're supposed to root for the normal-looking good guys and be repulsed by the monsters and villains they fight. But, more often than we'd care to admit to ourselves, monsters can have a certain edgy appeal that conventionally attractive good guys just don't. Whether they're river gods, demons, slasher movie villains, or freshly-risen corpses, there's just something about a bad boy or girl that we can't say no to, no matter how many horns, fangs, robo-parts, or tentacles they're rocking.

Fans of horror sometimes don't even have an issue revealing their crushes on fictional monsters, like cosplayers dressed up as sexy Pennywise. Director Guillermo del Toro even fed this taboo theme into his human/fish fornication movie, The Shape of Water.

It definitely helps, too, when the character actor out of makeup is a secret hottie. Creatures like your average sparkly vampire or bikini-clad succubus are tailor-made to seduce us, but the sexy fictional monsters on this list are definitely not for those with such pedestrian tastes. 

Hellboy is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 14 Monsters You Don't Want To Admit You Have A Crush On
Photo:  Hellboy/Columbia/Revolution

Mike Mignola's devilish comic book creation is a demon pulled from the depths of Hell by the Nazis. His "Right Hand of Doom," lava-colored skin, hulking body, and fangs are supposed to inspire fear, but there are definitely a lot of people who are not-so-secretly horny for the horned slayer.

"Gruff and romantic, with a low tolerance for bullsh*t and bullies, Hellboy comes off the screen as the kind of man every girl wants at her side horns, tail, and all," writer Margorie Liu noted of Ron Perlman's live-action version. Who would say no to that six-pack and those bulging biceps, too? 

More Hellboy

#45 of 387 on The Best Comic Book Superheroes of All Time #33 of 53 on Characters Who Are Most Worthy Of Lifting Mjolnir #62 of 144 on The Most Hardcore Big Screen Action Heroes #9 of 18 on Fictional Characters Who Are Way Older Than They Look

see more on Hellboy
Jack Skellington is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 14 Monsters You Don't Want To Admit You Have A Crush On
Photo:  The Nightmare Before Christmas/Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Despite being a spooky claymation skeleton, The Nightmare Before Christmas's Jack Skellington possesses a lot of charm and a great set of pipes, too. He's also cast as a romantic hero, and the sweetness between him and puppet-girl Sally makes a lot of audience members' hearts beat a little faster.

The internet is filled with fan art and fiction (and even in-depth articles) made to quench the secret Pumpkin King (or "Bone Daddy") thirst.

More Jack Skellington

#2 of 30 on This Artist Turns Disney Characters Into Pokemon Evolutions #61 of 89 on Characters You Most Want To See In Super Smash Bros. Switch #2 of 69 on The Most Notorious Skeleton Characters of All Time #21 of 175 on The Best To Worst Kingdom Hearts Characters

see more on Jack Skellington
Billy Butcherson is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 14 Monsters You Don't Want To Admit You Have A Crush On
Photo:  Hocus Pocus/Walt Disney Studios

Unlike vampires and werewolves, zombies have usually been a hard romantic sell. There's just something about the decaying flesh and brain-hunger that seems to turn most people off. That is, unless you're Hocus Pocus's Billy Butcherson. Despite the gnarled skin and Robert Smith wig, people have been secretly lusting after Billy since 1993.

If you're one of them, you'll be relieved to hear that this was the intention. "Kenny [Ortega, director of Hocus Pocus] kind of wanted Billy to be an attractive zombie," actor Doug Jones revealed in a 2013 interview for BuzzFeed. "I hear that from people all the time who grew up with the movie. Their first movie crush was Billy Butcherson, often. It’s really kind of sweet and charming to hear that."   

see more on Billy Butcherson
Pyramid Head is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 14 Monsters You Don't Want To Admit You Have A Crush On
Photo:  Silent Hill: Revelation/Open Road Films

Silent Hill's knife-wielding Big Bad is one of the most terrifying video game antagonists of all time, but that hasn't stopped people from fantasizing about the blood-soaked butcher. After all, judging on the bits of P-Head's body we can actually see, he's clearly not adverse to doing a few push-ups.

"You know it's wrong," one author writes of the monster for their fan fiction, "Guilty Pleasure." The author summarizes their work with this: "Every fiber in your being tells you it's wrong, but there's something about the Executioner of Silent Hill that secretly has you begging for him over and over again." 

More Pyramid Head

#77 of 266 on The Most Hardcore Video Game Heroes of All Time #9 of 163 on The Best Video Game Villains of All Time #1 of 20 on The Scariest Video Game Monsters Of All Time #5 of 61 on The Fictional Monsters You'd Least Like to Have After You

see more on Pyramid Head