• Total Nerd

16 Controversial MCU Moments That Divided The Fanbase

List RulesVote up the MCU moments that made you mad.

To refer to the Marvel Cinematic Universe as a beloved franchise might be putting it a tad too mildly. Few media franchises in all of history have been met with as much praise, enthusiasm, or sheer box-office response by its fans as the MCU, and more than a decade in, that adulation is only growing louder.

A frequently heard refrain is that Marvel Studios “doesn’t miss.” But while there are plenty who would agree with that statement, others aren’t quite so sure about the Hawkeye-like accuracy.

Like any franchise, the MCU has a couple of divisive, love-it-or-hate-it films on its record, but they’re few and far between. Much more common, however, are those individual moments within films that have managed to temporarily split the exuberant franchise in twain - at least until the next awesome event occurs and everyone forgets all about it.

  • 1
    46 VOTES

    Star-Lord Losing His Cool At Thanos ('Avengers: Infinity War')

    TV and film fans are more than familiar with the concept of the “idiot ball,” a metaphorical object held by seemingly intelligent characters on those occasions in which their stupid decisions are needed to move the plot forward. Usually, it’s stressful for viewers to witness their favorites make such consequential and out-of-character choices.

    It’s another matter entirely, however, when a character’s turn with the idiot ball leads directly to the demise of half of all life in the universe.

    That’s a circumstance that could only apply to Peter Quill, the Legendary Star-Lord, also known as the guy who couldn’t just wait until after the Infinity Gauntlet had been removed from Thanos’s hand to start questioning the Mad Titan about Gamora’s fate. 

    It’s an emotional moment, and Quill’s reaction to learning that the love of his life might have died is entirely understandable. But in this scene, Star-Lord’s innate impetuousness was cranked up to 11, and the entire universe suffered for it.

    For many, it was an act that instantly made Star-Lord their least favorite character in the franchise. For those who came into Avengers: Infinity War as more of a Guardians of the Galaxy supporter, it had to be downright embarrassing. 

  • 2
    32 VOTES

    Sharon Carter Goes Full Villain ('The Falcon and the Winter Soldier')

    Photo: Disney+

    For much of the first season of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, the clues pointing to Sharon Carter being the real identity of the Power Broker piled up, to the point that most began to suspect she was a red herring.

    The finale, however, saw Carter indeed revealed as the Power Broker - along with her cold-blooded murder of Karli Morgenthau, her lying to Captain America, and her full pardon from the US government - all leading her into more presumable power-broking in future phases.

    The obviousness of the twist within the series bothered some, but not nearly as much as the suddenness of the twist within the context of the franchise as a whole. The last time audiences saw Carter on-screen, she was waxing poetic about her Aunt Peggy and helping Steve Rogers fight for what’s right in Captain America: Civil War, and then, seven years later, she’s the kingpin of crime in Madripoor, of all places. It’s a very sharp heel turn, and it does beggar belief a bit.

    Twistiness aside, there are, of course, those who did not care for Sharon becoming a villain at all, regardless of how it was delivered. She was someone in whom Peggy Carter, Nick Fury, and Captain America all placed their full trust - and it’d be a shame to think of them as poor judges of character.

  • 3
    40 VOTES

    Shuri Schooling Tony Stark And Bruce Banner ('Avengers: Infinity War')

    There was a short exchange in Avengers: Infinity War that probably seemed innocuous to most who saw it in theaters, but set certain corners of the internet ablaze with fury. Upon being tasked with the de-Stoning of the Vision, Shuri asked Bruce Banner why he and Tony Stark didn’t program the synthezoid’s synapses to work collectively, which prompted Banner to reply that they hadn’t thought of it - and Shuri to sarcastically assure them, “I’m sure you did your best.”

    For many, it was a quick and easy way to establish Shuri as Wakanda’s scientist supreme, a character capable of schooling even Hulk and Iron Man in the art of artificial intelligence. In a film bursting at the seams with cameo appearances, the dialogue quickly demonstrated that Shuri was smart and snarky, and that’s just efficient.

    To others, however, the thought of Shuri talking down to two founding Avengers was unconscionable. How dare this Wakandan 20-something question the knowledge of the Science Bros? There are some who will even go as far as to suggest that the interaction served to undermine the reputations and legitimacy of Banner and Stark - but they were still smart enough to figure out time travel, so that point is probably moot by now.

  • 4
    66 VOTES

    Black Widow's Sacrifice ('Avengers: Endgame')

    Natasha Romanoff’s decision to sacrifice her life on Vormir in Avengers: Endgame, all in the name of completing the Infinity Gauntlet and returning the snapped half of the universe back to life, can essentially be taken one of two ways.

    Strictly within the context of her own story arc, many see it as a fitting conclusion. The Black Widow was always haunted by the red in her ledger, and sacrificing oneself to bring trillions of beings back to life is pretty much the ultimate act of redemption. All Natasha really wanted to do was to make up for the evil she had committed, and she certainly did that.

    But there’s also the role that Romanoff’s demise played in the plot of Endgame, and the franchise as a whole, to consider. There’s an age-old comic book trope called “women in refrigerators” that refers to a story beat in which a woman is hurt or killed solely for the purpose of providing motivation for a male character.

    Shortly after her demise, the remaining five (all-male) original Avengers stood around and discussed how the loss of Natasha had affected them. And then she was only referenced a handful of times thereafter, while Tony Stark’s own sacrifice got to be the centerpiece of the film’s climax, complete with a well-attended funeral sequence.

    Some feel she got the short end of the sacrificial stick.