Total Nerd
37 voters

The Most Egregious Alternate Costumes In Comic Book History

Updated November 5, 2019 225 votes 37 voters10 items

List RulesVote up the most embarrassing superhero look

We understand - when your super hero character has been around for decades, you can't resist the urge to tinker with their look in the hopes that a fresh new style will breathe new life into them. After all, history is riddled with characters that are better left forgotten and there are only so many awkward crossover events comic fans can stomach  But some of these costume changes go beyond "refresh" and well into "burn it with fire." 

Which of these alternate costumes are the most heinous in super hero history? 

  • 1

    Star Sapphire (DC Comics)

    Star Sapphire (DC Comics)
    Photo: Marvel / Amazon / Fair Use

    Green Lantern nemesis (and occasional love interest) Star Sapphire used to wear a fairly functional costume. It still had wide collar and garish fuchsia color scheme, but it was tame compared to this incarnation, which basically answered the question, "How little material is necessary for something to qualify as a costume?"

    28
    12
    Agree or disagree?
  • Colossus (Marvel Comics)
    Photo: Marvel / Amazon / Fair Use

    If you're going to have the X-Men's resident Russian strongman turn heel, you have to do better than just slapping him in a pair of Vladimir Lenin footie pajamas. "It was the 80s" is no excuse.

    21
    6
    Agree or disagree?

    More Colossus 

    #3134 of 3,510 The Best Movie Characters Of All Time#12 of 13 13 Marvel Superhero 'Deaths' You Knew Were Never Going To Stay Permanent#9 of 64 The Best X-Men Characters Of All Time

  • Superman...Again (DC Comics)
    Photo: DC / Amazon / Fair Use

    What is it with people and Superman? It's the most iconic costume in all of comics! And yet...Remember the time they "rebooted" him by having the Man of Steel come back wearing...a T-shirt? It made cosplay easier, sure, but...c'mon...

    17
    6
    Agree or disagree?
  • Captain America (Marvel Comics)
    Photo: Marvel / Amazon / Fair Use

    With the country still smarting from Watergate, it was a bold idea to have Captain America get fed up and ditch the red, white, and blue. It was NOT a bold idea to have him adopt the name "Nomad" and dress like a Ukrainian lion tamer.

    14
    6
    Agree or disagree?

    More Captain America 

    #7 of 187 The Top Marvel Comics Superheroes#3 of 172 The Best Characters In The Marvel Cinematic Universe#7 of 297 The Best Comic Book Superheroes Of All Time