films The 12 Most Inaccurate War Movies Ever Made  

Donn Saylor
198 votes 109 voters 1.0k views 12 items Embed

List Rules Vote up the war movies that got everything wrong.

Movies have always been given considerable creative liberties when retelling real-life events. When it comes to the most inaccurate war movies, however, there is something sort of unsavory about reshaping such a serious narrative to fit the filmmaker's goals and intentions. After all, to quote General Sherman, "War is Hell." Fiddling with the facts of a real-world war does a great disservice to those who were involved with or in any way impacted by the conflict.

None of this means these films didn't find an audience. Some movies that get war all wrong are astonishingly successful. Many generate hundreds of millions of box office dollars. Others are celebrated Academy Award winners. Others, of course, are just plain failures--critically, commercially, and historically.

Sure, movies are an escape, so why quibble over historical accuracy? Because movies are also an accessible way to inform, educate, and enlighten. Historical accuracy should be a priority in any movie dealing with war. While there are countless films that do make attention to detail a priority, read on to discover several that clearly didn't and vote up for what you think are the least realistic movies about war.


Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

One veteran described Kathryn Bigelow's 2008 Iraq War movie as being "completely made up, with no basis in reality." Despite Bigelow's claims that she wanted the movie to feel as documentary-like as possible, there is very little in The Hurt Locker that measures up to what really happened to the Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) team or how they operated. The movie portrays a tense, 130-minute high-wire act of coursing adrenaline. In reality, those who work in EOD must be logical, measured, and extremely cautious, and they don't barrel into warzones alone. What could have been a jarringly real portrait of the EOD instead got the action movie makeover, with all the typical character tropes and contrived situations action flicks typically entail.

Actors: Evangeline Lilly, Ralph Fiennes, Jeremy Renner, Guy Pearce, David Morse, + more

Initial Release: 2008

Directed by: Kathryn Bigelow

Also Ranked

#51 on The Very Best Oscar-Winning Movies

#29 on The Best War Movies Ever

#78 on The Best Movies of the '00s

#33 on The Best Oscar-Winning Screenplays

see more on The Hurt Locker
2
13 1

Windtalkers


Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

It is well documented that American military personnel recruited Navajo soldiers to transmit messages in their native language during the Second World War. But what director John Woo does to their heroic effort in Windtalkers is nothing short of butchery. First of all, the movie isn't even really centered on the Native American characters at all; they're supporting players in a story that stars the crazy-eyed, un-Navajo, Nicolas Cage. The movie also implies that non-Native soldiers were supposed to kill any Navajo platoonmates if any of the latter were about to be captured. Yeah…that never happened. Seems like a pretty major plot-point to fudge. The plot also technically hinges on a historical inaccuracy that one critic pointed out: 

"The whole imperative of the film -- that we could lose the war if the Navajo is captured -- is basically false, given that Japan was on its knees in late 1944, and Saipan already was won when most of the film's action takes place."

You know. Minor details.

Actors: Nicolas Cage, Mark Ruffalo, Christian Slater, Jason Isaacs, Peter Stormare, + more

Initial Release: 2002

Directed by: John Woo

Also Ranked

#9 on The Best Native American Movies

see more on Windtalkers

Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

The 2001 war movie Enemy at the Gates, starring Joseph Fiennes and Jude Law and directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud, set out to tell the story of two snipers involved in the Battle of Stalingrad. Unfortunately, it fell far short of its goal: it told a story of two snipers involved in the battle, but it didn't tell the story. The movie takes the central character and essentially makes him a one-man army, despite the fact that millions were engaged in this battle. There are also smaller but nonetheless glaring missteps, like portraying the Russians as going into battle unarmed (there is no historical record of this). Oh, and the duel around which the whole film revolves? Probably never happened. Of course, this wouldn't be as problematic if the film wasn't pitched and promoted as a true portrayal of history, which is more than a bit misleading.

Actors: Rachel Weisz, Jude Law, Ed Harris, Ron Perlman, Bob Hoskins, + more

Initial Release: 2001

Directed by: Jean-Jacques Annaud

Also Ranked

#21 on The Best War Movies Ever

#13 on The Greatest World War II Movies of All Time

#19 on The Greatest World War II Dramas

see more on Enemy at the Gates
4
19 10

U-571


Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

When the Prime Minister of Great Britain says your movie is historical hogwash, you know you've made a wrong turn. And in the case of the 2000 Jonathan Mostow-directed U-571 that also stars Jon Bon Jovi, there were wrong turns aplenty. U-571 supposedly chronicles the capture of the first Enigma Machine in World War II during a mission known as Operation Primrose. But as many historians have pointed out, at this point in the war the British had already captured multiple Enigmas...months before the war even began.  In fact, the British captured all of the Machines and codebooks save for two occasions. But of course, the movie takes the opportunity to shift takes all of the victories and accomplishments of the British soldiers over to the American soldiers. No wonder Tony Blair called it an insult to the British and their pivotal role in the Second World War.

Actors: Matthew McConaughey, Jon Bon Jovi, Bill Paxton, Harvey Keitel, Thomas Kretschmann, + more

Initial Release: 2000

Directed by: Jonathan Mostow

Also Ranked

#59 on The Best War Movies Ever

#40 on The Greatest World War II Movies of All Time

#6 on The Best Submarine Movies Of All Time

see more on U-571