The Most Overrated Contestants on Survivor

Ranked by
  • Ozzy Lusth
    1
    08/23/1981
    Fun player... but far too easily trapped by his own arrogance. Could never win for that reason.
  • James Clement
    2
    03/09/1977
    Has never had a single chance of winning this game, no matter how many times you might bring him back.
  • Her supposed awesomeness only came about because she was on a tribe of complete losers. Watching her play subsequently showed that she has little to no self-awareness.
  • Sophie Clarke
    4
    07/10/1989
    Another field of bad players. These kinds of wins make me tired.
  • Rupert Boneham
    5
    01/27/1964
    The fact that I've had to watch this guy's shitty game more than one time is ridiculous.
  • Lisa Whelchel
    6
    05/29/1963
    I'm not sure she's overrated, exactly, as she's never been spoken of that highly as a player. But there does seem to be some esteem for her ridiculous, all-over-the-place gameplay... so I add her.