Button Mash

The Most Ridiculously Valuable Nintendo 64 Games 

Crystal Brackett
Updated October 25, 2019 2.4k votes 684 voters 70.3k views 18 items

List Rules Vote up the super-rare cartridges you wish you'd held onto.

At first glance, your Nintendo game collection probably doesn't seem very valuable to anyone other than you and your childhood memories. After some diligent digging around, however, you might just realize a few of the cartridges you've casually snagged over the years are now worth more than you paid for your N64 back in the day. Nerds across the globe will fork over heaps of cash to get their hands on rare collectibles, especially if it's something retro and out of print.

After recognizing the true value of your Nintendo 64 games, you'll start to understand the real-life, tangible value of holding onto your timeless treasures. Next time you think about pawning off your old geeky goods when they go out of style, just remember some future nerd out there will be more than willing to pay you a high price for your rare video game merch.

back to page 1
5
Mario Party 3: $1,999
Mario Party 3 is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list The Most Ridiculously Valuable Nintendo 64 Games
Photo:  powerupvideogames/eBay

Partying with Mario and his friends will really break the bank.

Is this valuable?
Paper Mario is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list The Most Ridiculously Valuable Nintendo 64 Games
Photo:  avidgamerz/eBay

For a copy of Paper Mario, you'll have to fork over your hard-earned paper.

Is this valuable?
Donkey Kong 64 is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list The Most Ridiculously Valuable Nintendo 64 Games
Photo:  baconneggz1/eBay

Be prepared to spend more than a few bananas if you want to dive deep into the jungle with Donkey Kong.

Is this valuable?
Banjo-Kazooie is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list The Most Ridiculously Valuable Nintendo 64 Games
Photo:  video-game-traders/eBay

Teaming up for adventure in Banjo-Kazooie is priceless - if you ignore the $540 price tag.

Is this valuable?