Total Nerd 15 Movies With "Happy Endings" That Were Actually Unspeakably Tragic  

Jacob Shelton
57.9k votes 14.8k voters 1.7M views 15 items Embed

List Rules Vote up the movies that have the saddest endings, now that you think about it.

The ending of a film is meant to tie things up into a neat little package. But when you look at the “life affirming” and “happy” endings of most major motion pictures, you start to realize that there are a lot of sad endings to happy movies. Many misunderstood movies are childhood favorites that revolve around a young person going through tough times and coming out the other end changed for the better. When that involves body switching, animal cruelty, and violent fantasy adventures, though, it's clear that even beloved classics secretly depressing conclusions.

That's not to say movies can't have bleak endings. Horror movies are built on shocking endings, and some of the best thrillers have big twists. But what about so-called upbeat movie endings you didn't realize are super dark? Which seemingly cheery date night movies are actually depressing? Those can really blindside you if you're just trying to enjoy some popcorn and couch time.

It's sad, but most of the characters in your favorite films are left with unspeakable trauma buzzing in the back of their heads. When you watch a film in that context it makes for some very depressing movie endings.


Close Encounters of the Third ... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 15 Movies With "Happy Endings" That Were Actually Unspeakably Tragic
Photo:  Close Encounters of the Third Kind/Sony

Roy Neary spends the entirety of Close Encounters of the Third Kind obsessing over extra terrestrials and UFOs. His obsession reaches such a fever pitch that his wife takes their kids and leaves him. Then, rather than get his act together and be a father to his children, Roy leaves the planet with a group of aliens. Being chosen by aliens to represent humanity throughout the galaxy is the ultimate version of going to get cigarettes and never coming back. 

Aside from Roy leaving his family high and dry, the end of the movie also shows a group of abductees being carelessly dropped back on Earth. Some of the people who were abducted went missing 30 years earlier. What are they going to do now that they're back? Their families are probably dead, they don't have any place to live, and they no longer have skills that can help them with work.

Also Ranked

#7 on The Best Steven Spielberg Movies

#43 on The Best Movies Roger Ebert Gave Four Stars

#8 on The Best Alien Movies Ever Made

#25 on The Best '70s Movies

2,683 2,491
Sadder than you thought?
see more on Close Encounters of the Third Kind
2 5,176 VOTES

Kill Bill: Vol. 2


Kill Bill Volume 2 is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 15 Movies With "Happy Endings" That Were Actually Unspeakably Tragic
Photo:  Kill Bill Volume 2/Miramax

Throughout the Kill Bill movies, Beatrix crisscrosses the world to get revenge on her old gang, who stole her baby and left her for dead. The finale of Vol. 2 is an almost anti-climactic showdown between Beatrix and Bill: she uses the Five Point Palm Exploding Heart Technique to fulfill the title, and whisks BB off to a new life.

While the audience may see this as a win over the biggest of big bads, BB has just been robbed of the only parent she ever knew and taken away from her home. There's no way she's not going to have huge questions or lingering trauma after meeting her mother this way.

Also Ranked

#53 on The Most Nausea-Inducing Great Films

#6 on Quentin Tarantino Movies, Ranked Best to Worst

#55 on The Best Movies of the '00s

#22 on The Best Movie Sequels Ever Made

2,679 2,497
Sadder than you thought?
see more on Kill Bill Volume 2
3 5,305 VOTES

Dirty Dancing


Dirty Dancing is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 15 Movies With "Happy Endings" That Were Actually Unspeakably Tragic
Photo:  Dirty Dancing/Lionsgate

At the end of Dirty Dancing, everyone is mad at each other. Baby's father thinks Johnny got one of the girls pregnant, and everyone at the camp thinks Johnny has been stealing from the guests. But things are settled when Johnny and Baby dance like they've never danced before to the anachronistic "I've Had The Time Of My Life."

It's all very heartwarming, but what happens immediately after the credits roll? At best, Baby's father can talk to the staff of the summer camp and get Johnny his job back, but would he even want to? This is guy who spent the summer hooking up with his daughter while giving her "dance lessons." 

And what's going to happen to Baby and Johnny? Presumably they'll never make it work. Baby's a teenager and Johnny seems to be a full adult. If they do try to stick it out, will she live with him in his abandoned dance studio? Or is he going to move to Mount Holyoke to try and keep up with his gal? No matter how you look at it, this relationship is doomed.

Also Ranked

#14 on Musical Movies With the Best Songs

#19 on "Old" Movies Every Young Person Needs To Watch In Their Lifetime

#43 on The Greatest Movies of the 1980s, Ranked

#85 on The Most Rewatchable Movies

2,743 2,562
Sadder than you thought?
see more on Dirty Dancing
4 4,222 VOTES

Independence Day


Independence Day is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 15 Movies With "Happy Endings" That Were Actually Unspeakably Tragic
Photo:  Independence Day/20th Century Fox

Pretty much every major character survives the alien onslaught in Independence Day. The President gets to be cool in his jet, Will Smith and Jeff Goldblum get to smoke cigars and hack an alien ship – it's very fun stuff!

But what about the fact that most of the world's population is now dead? And how do you govern in a world where everyone knows that there are things from other planets that definitely want to kill us? There's no way that Earth doesn't turn into a jingoist, speciesist nightmare overnight after the movie cuts to black.

Also Ranked

#23 on The Most Rewatchable Movies

#1 on The Greatest Disaster Movies of All Time

#6 on The Best Alien Movies Ever Made

#8 on Great Movies So Patriotic, They Are Basically American Propaganda

2,187 2,035
Sadder than you thought?
see more on Independence Day