8.0k voters

We Asked Which Horror Movies Are So Scary You Still Can't Watch Them, And Here Are The Results

Updated June 2, 2019 90.4k votes 8.0k voters 104.4k views20 items

List RulesVote up the horror movies so scary, you can't watch them to this day.

Even if you're a horror movie fanatic, some films are difficult to watch. Several of the best horror movies feature scenes terrifying enough to stick with us forever, creating irrational, yet wholly understandable fears. To discover the worst of the worst, Graveyard Shift asked horror movie junkies which flicks are a little too frightening to handle.

Whether the movie scared you as a child, or you simply can't deal with creepy dolls, here are some of the most fascinating and hilarious reasons why people can't watch particular films.

Vote up the horror films so scary you can't make it to the end.

  • The Exorcist1

    The Exorcist

    Max von Sydow, Ellen Burstyn


    Directed byWilliam Friedkin

    "The Exorcist. I watched it way too young - around 12, I think. I genuinely turned into a freak who only slept in the day, as I was too terrified to sleep at night! Sleep therapy and a counselor sorted me out, but I still to this day feel physically sick if I see a picture of her face."

    More The Exorcist 

    Did A Malevolent Spirit Actually Curse 'The Exorcist' From The Get-Go?The Story Of Roland Doe Inspired The Exorcist – But It's Way More Terrifying Than The Movie

  • Insidious2


    Rose Byrne, Barbara Hershey


    Directed byJames Wan

    "The Insidious movies actually scare me. And I'm a hard one to scare with movies."

  • The Grudge3

    The Grudge

    Sarah Michelle Gellar, KaDee Strickland


    Directed byTakashi Shimizu

    "Laugh all you want, but The Grudge movies scarred me for life. I was forced to watch the first one when I was... about 8 if memory serves me right, and I still have nightmares to this day. Can't hear that noise without freaking out, and [I can't] look into a closet if it has an attic space."

    More The Grudge 

    #3 of 15 Non R-Rated Horror Movies As Scary As Anything#49 of 114 The Best Horror Movie Franchises

  • The Fourth Kind4

    The Fourth Kind

    Milla Jovovich, Elias Koteas


    Directed byOlatunde Osunsanmi

    "Anything to do with aliens sh*ts me up. It's just how it's made to look like a true story, with 'parallels' to 'original footage;' while part of my brain knows it's not real, part of it finds the whole thing far too real, and far too terrifying! Milla Jovovich should stick to zombie films... I love a good zombie film!"

    More The Fourth Kind 

    #80 of 186 The Best Alien Movies Ever Made#17 of 57 The Best Alien Horror Movies Ever Made

  • The Ring5

    The Ring

    Naomi Watts, Pauley Perrette


    Directed byGore Verbinski

    "The Ring traumatized me so badly when I saw it in theaters almost 16 years ago, and I haven't been able to watch it since."

  • The Hills Have Eyes6

    The Hills Have Eyes

    Dee Wallace, Michael Berryman


    Directed byWes Craven

    "Don't get me wrong - I'm a horror movie fanatic. I'm not scared of horror movies, but I cannot watch The Hills Have Eyes. It's just too much."

    More The Hills Have Eyes 

    #2 of 20 20 Horrifying Crime Movies Whose True Stories Are Way More Terrifying#12 of 42 The Most Gratuitous Torture Horror Movies That Are Undeniably Sadistic

  • Pet Sematary7

    Pet Sematary

    Stephen King, Fred Gwynne


    Directed byMary Lambert

    "Pet Sematary. The Gage scene freaked me out after having kids because it's every parent's worst nightmare. Plus, I live on a road where logging trucks go by constantly."

  • A Nightmare On Elm Street8

    A Nightmare On Elm Street

    Johnny Depp, Robert Englund


    Directed byWes Craven

    "When I was 16, I was introduced to Freddy Krueger. I spent the next three nights in my parents' room. Then I made myself watch it until I wasn't scared."

    More A Nightmare on Elm Street 

    Ranking Freddy Krueger's Best Kills from A Nightmare on Elm StreetBehind The Scenes Of Glen's Death In 'A Nightmare On Elm Street'

  • 28 Days Later9

    28 Days Later

    Cillian Murphy, Christopher Eccleston


    Directed byDanny Boyle

    "28 Days Later got my heart racing. That wasn't the first movie to have running zombies, but it was the first movie I saw on the big screen that had them."

    More 28 Days Later 

    14 Small But Fascinating Details Fans Noticed In '28 Days Later'#1 of 144 The Best Zombie Movies Of All Time

  • Halloween10


    Jamie Lee Curtis, Kyle Richards


    Directed byJohn Carpenter

    "I'm sorry, but Michael Meyers gives me so much anxiety I feel nauseous. I have a serious fear of being chased, and the way Michael stalks and chases is overkill. If I watch a Halloween movie, I ALWAYS have the same dream where he chases me 'til he stabs me, and I wake up crying. How lame, but so scary."

    More Halloween 

    Stories About Jamie Lee Curtis From Behind The Scenes Of The Original 'Halloween''Halloween' Isn't Actually A Fable About The Dangers Of Teenage Intimacy

  • Annabelle11


    Alfre Woodard, Annabelle Wallis


    Directed byJohn R. Leonetti

    "I watched Annabelle when I was pregnant. That scared the crap out of me. Not the demonic doll part, the very beginning when the psycho couple sneak into the main character's [place] and proceed to stab the woman in her pregnant belly. That messed me up for the rest of my pregnancy."

    More Annabelle 

    #16 of 67 The Best Demonic Possession Movies#74 of 114 The Best Intelligent Horror Movies

  • The Blair Witch Project12

    The Blair Witch Project

    Heather Donahue, Joshua Leonard


    Directed byDaniel Myrick, Eduardo Sánchez

    "Some of y'all might find this funny, but The Blair Witch Project scared me the first time I watched! Anything unseen in some creepy woods scares me! Once I went camping, and some people in the area who were camping as well yelled at us for being loud at 8 pm. I snuck [up to their campsite] in the middle of the night... put all kinds of rocks and sticks cobbled together around them, Blair Witch-style. Always wondered what they thought when they woke up in the morning."

    More The Blair Witch Project 

    Wild Details The Cast And Crew Has Revealed About Making 'The Blair Witch Project'#127 of 242 The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time

  • Darkness Falls13

    Darkness Falls

    Emily Browning, Emma Caulfield


    Directed byJonathan Liebesman

    "I was flipping through channels and came across [Darkness Falls]. I remember... this little boy with covers over his head, and when he took them down, there was this black, shadowy woman hovering above them. I immediately turned the channel saying, 'Nope nope nope.'"

    More Darkness Falls 

    #213 of 488 The Scariest Movies Ever Made#22 of 50 Horror Movies With The Most Satisfying Endings

  • Salem's Lot14

    Salem's Lot

    David Soul, Bonnie Bedelia


    Directed byTobe Hooper

    "The kid outside the window. Then there's the same thing in the corner in the dark, and it opens its eyes. Creepy."

    More Salem's Lot 

    #4 of 33 The Best Television Adaptations of Stephen King's Work#1 of 18 Obscure Horror Movies from the 1970s You Should Know About

  • Jaws15


    Steven Spielberg, Richard Dreyfuss


    Directed bySteven Spielberg

    "Mine isn't much of a horror film, but Jaws. To this day, I cannot watch anything with sharks in it. And my family lives for Shark Week. Can't handle it. Turns my stomach and freaks me out!"

    More Jaws 

    Behind The Scenes Of Every Death In ‘Jaws’#120 of 1,189 Every Oscar Winning Film Ever

  • Suspiria16


    Joan Bennett, Alida Valli


    Directed byDario Argento

    "It's really weird, and I'm not sure why, but to this day there's something about Suspiria that freaks me out to no end. The Exorcism of Emily Rose used to scare the sh*t out of me as well."

    More Suspiria 

    #161 of 722 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time#107 of 553 The Best '70s Movies

  • Mother17


    Kim Hye-ja, Won Bin


    Directed byBong Joon-ho

    "I don't even know if it's a horror movie - it just really got to me. Had to turn it off, which was weird. I freaking love scary movies!"

  • Dolls18


    Guy Rolfe, Stephen Lee


    Directed byStuart Gordon

    "When I was about 18, I watched Dolls the night before my trip to visit my grandma. She said she didn't have room at her place, so I had to stay with my aunt and uncle. They showed me my room, and I instantly freaked out - my auntie collected antique dolls! I stayed at my grandma's home and slept on a cot."

  • The Perfect Storm19

    The Perfect Storm

    George Clooney, Mark Wahlberg


    Directed byWolfgang Petersen

    "I still can't sit through the storm sequence in The Perfect Storm. It absolutely terrifies me. Ocean disaster movies - can't do them, except Poseidon. Can't bring myself to watch The Finest Hours either."

    More The Perfect Storm 

    Tragic Facts About The Perfect Storm, The Shipwreck Story No One Lived To Tell#99 of 277 The Top Tearjerker Movies That Make Men Cry

  • Kill Bill: Volume 220

    Kill Bill: Volume 2

    Uma Thurman, Lucy Liu


    Directed byQuentin Tarantino

    "That scene in Kill Bill: Volume 2 where Kiddo plucks out the woman's eye. The acting out of flailing and screaming in agony made my skin crawl and stuck in my mind. Wasn't scary, but it disturbed me enough not to want to watch that scene again."

    More Kill Bill Volume 2 

    #239 of 1,540 The Most Rewatchable Movies#241 of 480 The Greatest Movies For Guys