Culture

Movie Adaptations That Make A Lot More Sense If You’ve Read The Books  

Donn Saylor
331 votes 99 voters 2.5k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the movies you think come with required reading.

A film can bring a beloved book to life, making visible what's only on the page or in the imagination. But even with the best of intentions, sometimes filmmakers miss the mark, and they make movie adaptations that are more enjoyable if you read the book. This is largely because books have hundreds of pages to provide context and backstory, and authors have the advantage of devoting significant time to character and story development. Screenwriters, however, have no such luxury; most of them have around 120 minutes, give or take, to compress an entire literary universe into a film that captures viewers' attention.

No story genre is immune from the difficulties of making the transition from page to screen, whether it's a young adult drama or sci-fi adventure. Fantasy and science-fiction novels, however, create unique challenges, because carefully crafted, complex worlds are everything. Filmmakers might be limited by budget constraints, often meaning huge, essential chunks of a complex story are cut. So for some movies, you need to read the book to understand what's happening. 

Even if you love a particular movie, you might understand it better - and also enjoy it more - if you read the book in tandem with seeing the film.

The Golden Compass is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Movie Adaptations That Make A Lot More Sense If You’ve Read The Books
Photo:  New Line Cinema

Philip Pullman's The Golden Compass (AKA Northern Lights) has been hailed as a modern masterpiece of YA lit. But the 2007 film version misses the mark in some big ways. So significant, in fact, that many devoted fans of the book were left scratching their heads and wondering what happened to the rest of the movie.

Case in point: the daemons. In Pullman's novel, who and what daemons are is not revealed via pages of exposition; it only becomes evident through the action of the story. The movie takes a decidedly different tack: it tries to encapsulate the complex daemons into a few lines of early-in-the-film voiceover narration. Some vague narration also attempts to explain the story's complicated class system.

Does reading the book help?
see more on The Golden Compass
A Wrinkle in Time is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Movie Adaptations That Make A Lot More Sense If You’ve Read The Books
Photo:  Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

While Ava DuVernay's 2018 film version and Madeleine L'Engle's classic novel follows the same basic premise, some notable differences between the two might confuse moviegoers. One of the biggest head-scratchers is the science behind the story.

The film doesn't fully explain the science of tessering, and what it does portray is an overly sentimental interpretation of L'Engle's original intention. As a result, many viewers can't fully appreciate the vast field of scholarship behind this phenomenon. To get a better idea of the science behind the story, read the book.

Does reading the book help?
see more on A Wrinkle in Time
Percy Jackson & the Olympians:... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Movie Adaptations That Make A Lot More Sense If You’ve Read The Books
Photo:  20th Century Fox

The two Percy Jackson movies are drawn from Rick Riordan's series about an adolescent demigod and his friends as they embark on quests to save the world from evil. Because of the vibrantly drawn universe in Riordan's books, the movies suffer from oversimplifications and a watering-down of heroes and villains.

The film version also cast several high-profile actors to play the adult roles, significantly expanding them from what was in the original books. It did so, however, at the expense of the younger characters. This makes it difficult and confusing to cheer for the leads audiences are supposed to know and love. 

Does reading the book help?
see more on Percy Jackson & the Olympians: The Lightning Thief
Lemony Snicket's A Series of U... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Movie Adaptations That Make A Lot More Sense If You’ve Read The Books
Photo:  Paramount Pictures

Before Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events became a Netflix series, there was a film version. Starring Jim Carrey, the 2004 movie was a hit, but even its $209 million box office wasn't enough to earn a sequel. This means viewers never learn anything about the VFD: the Volunteer Fire Department, a secret society in which the kids become increasingly more involved after their first encounter with Count Olaf.

The VFD figures prominently in the kids' adventures as the books unfold. With that element missing from the movie, we only get a sampling of the epic stories. Luckily, the Netflix series gives this crucial plot point its due.

Does reading the book help?
see more on Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events