Weird History
115 voters

12 Urban Legends About Famous Musicians That Are Actually True

July 12, 2021 865 votes 115 voters 6.1k views12 items

List RulesVote up the wild stories you're surprised are actually true.

In the modern era, nothing is more legendary than a musician in their prime. Even the most charismatic president bows before the gods of rock and roll, the angels of R&B, and the princes of pop. Movie stars come close to their charismatic eminence, but what Hollywood idol can compete with the electric power of Jimi Hendrix? What celeb couple can equal the enchanting harmony of Crosby, Stills & Nash?

Across the decades, over mountains of narcotics, and through scores of star-making tours, these larger-than-life personas have gathered a number of rock and roll stories - many of which are exaggerated or simply false. But a fair number of urban legends about musicians - such as AerosmithLynyrd SkynyrdMichael Jackson, and even Ozzy Osbourne - are totally true. Vote up the rock stories you can't believe actually happened.

  • In a 2014 interview with Billboard, Billy Joel says that "good morale" is important to him, his band, and his crew - and that's why he now reserves the front row for fans that can't afford better seats. As he explains:

    We never sell front rows, we hold those tickets at just about every concert. For years, the scalpers got the tickets and would scalp the front row for ridiculous amounts of money. Our tickets are cheap, under $100, some in the $80s, the highest is about $150. I'd look down and see rich people sitting there, I call 'em "gold chainers." Sitting there puffing on a cigar, "entertain me, piano man." They don't stand up, make noise, sit there with their bouffant haired girlfriend lookin' like a big shot. I kinda got sick of that, who the hell are these people, where are the real fans? 

    It turns out the real fans were always in the back of the room in the worst seats. We now hold those tickets, and I send my road crew out to the back of the room when the audience comes in and they get people from the worst seats and bring 'em in to the front rows. This way you've got people in the front row that are really happy to be there, real fans. 

    • Genres (Music): Blue-eyed soul, Pop music, Rock music, Piano rock, Folk rock
    • Albums: The Stranger, Piano Man, 52nd Street, Glass Houses, An Innocent Man
    • Nationality: United States of America
    Surprised it's true?

    More Billy Joel 

    The Best Billy Joel Songs of All Time#9 of 136 Famous Accordionists#20 of 489 The Best Rock Vocalists

  • Released in 1977, "Just a Song Before I Go" was Crosby, Stills & Nash's biggest hit - and Graham Nash never would have written it if not for an off-the-cuff remark by his weed-slinging friend. The musician told the Daily Press:

    I was in Maui, and I had an hour to kill before I had to catch my plane. I was staying with a friend who was a low-level drug dealer - marijuana, nothing too dark - and he said to me, "You’re supposed to be a big shot songwriter. Bet you can’t write a song just before you go." I asked him how much he wanted to bet. He said, "Five hundred dollars."

    Nash wrote the two-minute song in a stream-of-consciousness style and allegedly "[d]idn't change a note" when he and his band finally recorded it. As to whether or not his friend paid up?

    “I still have his $500,” Nash told the paper.

    • Genres (Music): Pop music, Folk rock, Rock and roll
    • Albums: Songs for Beginners, Innocent Eyes, Songs for Survivors, Wild Tales, Earth & Sky
    • Nationality: United States of America,United Kingdom,England
    Surprised it's true?

    More Graham Nash 

    #351 of 1,728 The Best Rock Bands Of All Time#104 of 218 The Greatest Rock Songwriters of All Time#99 of 106 Which Bands Or Musicians Do You Most Want To See Before They (Or You) Kick The Bucket?

  • Photo: Unknown / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain

    In the mid-1960s, Jimi Hendrix transitioned from playing for the Isley Brothers to playing for various soul and R&B acts like B.B. King, Jackie Wilson, and Sam Cooke.

    For a brief time, Hendrix toured with Little Richard as part of his backing bands, both the Royal Company and the Upsetters. Robert Penniman, Little Richard's brother, said that, despite Hendrix's obvious talent with the guitar, he "had a habit of being late and upstaging the main act, two things that no session guitarist should ever do."

    In an episode of VH1's Legends, Richard said of Hendrix:

    On the stage he would actually take the show. People would scream and I thought they were screaming for me. I look over and they’re screaming for Jimi! 

    According to Penniman, it wasn't the showboating that made them ultimately fire Hendrix but his perpetual lateness:

    He was a damn good guitar player, but the guy was never on time. He was always late for the bus and flirting with the girls and stuff like that. It came to a head in New York, where we had been playing the Apollo and Hendrix missed the bus for Washington, DC. I finally got Richard to cut him loose.

    • Genres (Music): Blues-rock, Rock music, Experimental rock, Psychedelia, Heavy metal
    • Albums: First Rays of the New Rising Sun, Band of Gypsys, Voodoo Child: The Jimi Hendrix Collection, Live at the Fillmore East, Live at Woodstock
    • Nationality: United States of America
    Surprised it's true?

    More Jimi Hendrix 

    Inside Jimi Hendrix’s Legendary And Controversial National Anthem Performance At Woodstock '69#1 of 100 Rolling Stone's Top 100 Guitarists of All Time#30 of 753 People We Wish Were Still Alive

  • Photo: William Waterway / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

    Since the 1970s, the unnamed subject of Carly Simon's "You're So Vain" has tickled the curiosity of her fans. The leading contenders are generally agreed to be James Taylor, Kris Kristofferson, Warren Beatty, and Mick Jagger, who provided backing vocals for the song.

    For decades, Simon was adamant she'd never reveal whom the song was about. That changed in 2003, when the singer agreed to let the secret slip as part of a charity benefit for Martha's Vineyard, where she lives.

    The identity of the song's subject was auctioned for $50,000 to NBC Sports president Dick Ebersol - on the condition that he tell no one else.

    • Genres (Music): Adult contemporary music, Pop music, Rock music, Folk music, Traditional pop music
    • Albums: Christmas Is Almost Here, Christmas Is Almost Here Again, Spoiled Girl, Coming Around Again, Hotcakes
    • Nationality: United States of America
    Surprised it's true?

    More Carly Simon 

    #358 of 649 The Best Singers Of All Time#16 of 230 The Greatest Living Rock Songwriters#39 of 497 The Best Female Vocalists Ever