137 voters

The Best Natasha Lyonne Movies

Updated February 25, 2021 1.1k votes 137 voters 7.3k views63 items

List RulesVote for your favorite movies, regardless of critic reviews or how big the role was.

List of the best Natasha Lyonne movies, ranked best to worst with movie trailers when available. Natasha Lyonne's highest grossing movies have received a lot of accolades over the years, earning millions upon millions around the world. The order of these top Natasha Lyonne movies is decided by how many votes they receive, so only highly rated Natasha Lyonne movies will be at the top of the list. Natasha Lyonne has been in a lot of films, so people often debate each other over what the greatest Natasha Lyonne movie of all time is. If you and a friend are arguing about this then use this list of the most entertaining Natasha Lyonne films to end the squabble once and for all.

If you think the best Natasha Lyonne role isn't at the top, then upvote it so it has the chance to become number one. The greatest Natasha Lyonne performances didn't necessarily come from the best movies, but in most cases they go hand in hand.

The list you're viewing contains films like Girl Most Likely and Gavin McInnes Is a F**king A**hole.

"This list answers the questions, "What are the best Natasha Lyonne movies?" and "What are the greatest Natasha Lyonne roles of all time?"
  • 1

    But I'm a Cheerleader

    Michelle Williams, RuPaul
    But I'm a Cheerleader is a 1999 satirical romantic comedy film directed by Jamie Babbit and...  more

    More But I'm a Cheerleader 

    #623 of 781 The Greatest Chick Flicks Ever Made#132 of 200 The Best Teen Romance Movies

  • 2

    Scary Movie 2

    Anna Faris, Tim Curry
    Scary Movie 2 is a 2001 American horror comedy film and the second film in the Scary Movie...  more

    More Scary Movie 2 

    #136 of 175 The Best Movie Sequels Ever Made#64 of 65 The Best Adventure Movies for Kids

  • 3

    Slums of Beverly Hills

    Alan Arkin, Marisa Tomei
    Slums of Beverly Hills is a 1998 American comedy film directed by Tamara Jenkins. A...  more

    More Slums of Beverly Hills 

    #69 of 116 The Funniest Movies About High School#290 of 315 Movies with the Best Soundtracks

  • 4

    American Pie

    Alyson Hannigan, Tara Reid
    American Pie is a 1999 teen comedy film written by Adam Herz and directed by brothers Paul and...  more

    More American Pie 

    'American Pie' Is A Nightmarish Vision Of Late '90s High School Life#235 of 1,506 The Most Rewatchable Movies

  • 5

    Party Monster

    Macaulay Culkin, Seth Green
    Party Monster is a 2003 American factually based drama directed by Fenton Bailey and Randy...  more

    More Party Monster 

    #63 of 125 The Best Period Movies Set in the '80s#33 of 204 The Best Drug Movies of All Time

  • 6

    American Pie 2

    Alyson Hannigan, Tara Reid
    American Pie 2 is a 2001 American comedy film and the sequel to the 1999 film American Pie and...  more

    More American Pie 2 

    #25 of 141 The Best College Movies Ever#8 of 12 12 Comedy Sequels That Might Actually Be Better Than The Originals

  • 7

    Blade: Trinity

    Wesley Snipes, Jessica Biel
    Blade: Trinity is a 2004 American vampire superhero action film written, produced and directed...  more

    More Blade: Trinity 

    12 Unbelievable Stories From Behind The Scenes Of Blade: Trinity#75 of 116 The Worst Superhero Movies Ever Made

  • 8


    Halle Berry, Robin Williams
    Robots is a 2005 American computer animated science fiction comedy film produced by Blue Sky...  more

    More Robots 

    #198 of 533 The Best Animated Films Ever#32 of 99 The Greatest Kids Sci-Fi Movies

  • 9

    If These Walls Could Talk 2

    Sharon Stone, Ellen DeGeneres
    If These Walls Could Talk 2 is a 2000 television movie in the United States, broadcast on HBO....  more

    More If These Walls Could Talk 2 

    #25 of 132 The Best Lesbian Movies#132 of 208 The Best LGBTQ+ Themed Movies

  • 10

    Everyone Says I Love You

    Natalie Portman, Julia Roberts
    Everyone Says I Love You is a 1996 American musical comedy film written and directed by Woody...  more
  • 11

    Dennis the Menace

    Christopher Lloyd, Lea Thompson
    Dennis the Menace is a 1993 live-action American family film based on the Hank Ketcham comic...  more

    More Dennis the Menace 

    #89 of 117 The Best Movies Based on TV Shows#2 of 12 Classic '90s Kids Movies You Forgot Are Actually Super Messed Up

  • 12

    Krippendorf's Tribe

    Mila Kunis, Jenna Elfman
    Krippendorf's Tribe is a 1998 film adaptation of Frank Parkin's novel of the same name,...  more

    More Krippendorf's Tribe 

    #26 of 28 The Very Best Mila Kunis Movies#59 of 66 The Best Richard Dreyfuss Movies

  • 13

    All About Evil

    Natasha Lyonne, Cassandra Peterson
    "Here's the story of ALL ABOUT EVIL, a twisted black comedy set in the world of a classic old...  more
  • 14

    The Grey Zone

    Steve Buscemi, Mira Sorvino
    The Grey Zone is a 2001 film directed by Tim Blake Nelson and starring David Arquette, Steve...  more

    More The Grey Zone 

    #13 of 66 The Best Movies About the Holocaust#78 of 93 The Best Steve Buscemi Movies

  • 15


    Jack Nicholson, Meryl Streep
    Heartburn is a 1986 American comedy-drama film directed by Mike Nichols and starring Meryl...  more

    More Heartburn 

    #294 of 305 The Funniest '80s Movies#55 of 66 The Best Movies About Getting Dumped

  • 16

    American Reunion

    Alyson Hannigan, Neil Patrick Harris
    American Reunion is a 2012 ensemble comedy film written and directed by Jon Hurwitz and Hayden...  more
  • 17

    Die Mommie Die!

    Natasha Lyonne, Jason Priestley
    Die, Mommie, Die! is a 2003 American satirical comedy film written by Charles Busch, who also...  more
  • 18

    Modern Vampires

    Kim Cattrall, Craig Ferguson
    Modern Vampires is a 1998 black horror/comedy film that was released Oct 19, 1999 straight to...  more
  • 19

    Detroit Rock City

    Emmanuelle Chriqui, Edward Furlong
    Detroit Rock City is a 1999 American comedy film directed by Adam Rifkin and written by Carl...  more

    More Detroit Rock City 

    #160 of 252 The Funniest '90s Movies#38 of 195 The Best Movies About Music

  • 20

    Freeway II: Confessions of a Trickbaby

    Natasha Lyonne, David Alan Grier
    Freeway II: Confessions of a Trickbaby is a 1999 exploitation film and the sequel to Freeway,...  more
  • 21

    America Brown

    Natasha Lyonne, Ryan Kwanten
    America Brown is a 2004 film directed by Paul Black....  more
  • 22

    My Suicidal Sweetheart

    Natasha Lyonne, Rosanna Arquette
    My Suicidal Sweetheart is an American independent dark comedy film written and produced by...  more
  • 23

    Comic Book Villains

    Natasha Lyonne, Michael Rapaport
    Comic Book Villains is a 2002 American film....  more
  • 24

    Plan B

    Diane Keaton, Natasha Lyonne
    Plan B is a 2002 comedy film directed by Greg Yaitanes....  more
  • 25


    Natasha Lyonne, Ed McMahon