Horror Movies On Netflix With The Highest Rotten Tomatoes Scores 

Jodi Smith
Updated September 6, 2019 288.8k views 18 items

Figuring out the best horror movies on Netflix remains a time-consuming task. Choice paralysis is no joke, and sometimes relying on algorithms to guide your decisions doesn't pan out the way you hoped. It's a much better idea to take the Rotten Tomatoes scores for movies and rank them based on that - even if the scores are nebulous and tricky. 

Rotten Tomatoes, a review aggregation site, labels movies as Fresh or Rotten. Avoid rummaging through Netflix's immense library of freaky flicks by watching one of these horror films with the best Rotten Tomatoes score. 

Data-driven recommendations based on voting from over 40 million monthly visits to Ranker. Try the free app
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Tomatometer: 100%

Creep 2 is filmed in a found footage style with vlogging added into the mix. After the success of Creep in 2014, writer/director Patrick Brice and writer/star Mark Duplass returned with this sequel, which follows a strange man who enjoys making new friends by placing ads. 

A struggling vlogger/YouTuber, Sara, answers Aaron's online ad looking for "video work." Sara meets Aaron in his secluded mountain home where he makes an unbelievable confession, forcing her to decide whether to take her chances staying with him or escape while she can.

While critics say this film is by no means as creepy or menacing as the first, the cringe-inducing awkwardness of the characters makes it an uncomfortable horror film.

Actors: Mark Duplass, Desiree Akhavan, Karan Soni

Released: 2017

Directed by: Patrick Brice

Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Tomatometer: 99%

The Wailing - or Gokseong - is a South Korean horror film about a small town in the wake of a bizarre epidemic. This mysterious illness causes a rash, which precedes violent and murderous outbursts. The victims then experience a trance-like state and die. 

Police officer Jong-goo's partner convinces him to look at a Japanese stranger in the town as the possible cause of the illness and death. Soon, Jong-goo is in a race to save his daughter from the mysterious illness plaguing the rest of the town.

Many critics cite the film's brutal nature and seamless fusion of Eastern mythology and hard crime lore as the core of its brilliance. Professional reviewers suggest going into the film blind, so maybe skip the trailer for this one. 

Actors: Kwak Do-won, Hwang Jung-min, Chun Woo-hee

Directed by: Na Hong-jin

Under The Shadow
Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Tomatometer: 99%

This 2016 Persian film takes us into the lives of Shideh and her daughter, Dorsa. The two are left alone in an apartment after Shideh's husband, Dr. Iraj, is drafted to work in the war zone during the 1988 Tehran missile attacks. 

Dorsa soon begins asking questions about the legendary jinn, spirits drawn to places of turmoil, anxiety, and fear. Shideh and Dorsa must contend with the possibility that the legends are true. 

Under the Shadow is a critical darling due to its subtle but unnerving nature. The film has a boiling frog type of buildup; the tension is gradual and quiet, but it slowly burns you. 

Ranker Video
Video: YouTube

Tomatometer: 98%

The Babadook centers on the dysfunctional household of Amelia and her son, Samuel. Samuel's father died in a car accident while driving Amelia to the hospital to give birth, leaving them both off-center and different from the people around them. One day, a book about "the Babadook" appears, and Amelia reads it to Samuel. The book terrifies the child and sets off a chain of horrifying events in their lives.

Critics are obsessed with this Australian horror film due to it weaving the anxieties of motherhood into a traditional boogeyman story. 

Actors: Essie Davis, Daniel Henshall, Adam Morgan, Hayley McElhinney, Craig Behenna, + more

Released: 2014

Directed by: Jennifer Kent

More The Babadook 

#87 of 253 The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time #146 of 850 The Best Horror Movies Of All Time #14 of 149 The Best and Scariest Psychological Thrillers of All Time