Graveyard Shift Creepy Old West Ghost Stories and Legends  

Laura Allan
35.4k views 12 items Embed

Who doesn't love a good spooky story around the campfire? One thing is for sure, cowboys of the old west loved them, and may old west legends are still around today because of that. From strange creatures and Native American myths, to tales of dead women and children, some of the grisliest and most spine-chilling ghost stories come from the wild west. There are even times when people themselves became legends, and their ghosts give rise to new stories to thrill and chill people once evening begins to fall.

Certain old west figures seem specifically reluctant to fade away. From Jesse James to The Lost Dutchman, these legends may die but they're never forgotten. In the same way, terrifying old west ghosts meant to frighten children and cowboys alike refuse to die, living on to horrify us today and give us brand new, unexpected nightmares. 

So, are you brave enough to learn a little history and maybe a new ghost story or two? Don't worry, no one will blame you if you want to hide under the covers. 

"El Muerto" of South Texas


"El Muerto" of South T... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list Creepy Old West Ghost Stories and Legends
Photo: Soren Lünd/via welcomeimages.org/CC BY 4.0

In the early 1800s, South Texas and Mexico weren't really sure about where the border should lie. It was either the Nueces River or the Rio Grande River, but because no agreement could be reached, the area in between became a no man's land. Local cattle rustlers took advantage of this. One specific outlaw named Vidal was particularly nasty, and the local rangers decided to make an example of him in the worst way imaginable.

When he was caught, they killed him, cut off his head, then lashed his body to a mustang in an upright position as if he was riding. Then they let the horse loose to wander, as a symbol of the form of justice that would befall any outlaw who dared step out of line. Quite similar to the legend of Sleepy Hollow or the Headless Horseman, many cowboys over the years have seen a headless bandit called "El Muerto" riding through the Rio Grande area, even into the 21st century.

Jesse James Still Haunts His Family Farm


Jesse James Still Haunts His F... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list Creepy Old West Ghost Stories and Legends
Photo:  Fallschirmjäger/via wikipedia.org/Public Domain

Jesse Woodson James was an outlaw, train robber, bank robber, and gang leader between the 1860s and the 1880s, and he was finally killed on April 3, 1882 by Robert Ford. While rumors of his survival floated around, his ghost has purportedly been spotted around his family farm in Kearney, Missouri for over 100 years. Additionally, lights come on at random times, mysterious movements are caught on security cameras, and mysterious voices can be heard in rooms that are supposed to be empty. Legend has it that this is evidence of the ghostly gunslinger returned home, never to leave again.

The Cry of the Death Bird


The Cry of the Death Bird is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list Creepy Old West Ghost Stories and Legends
Photo: Al_HikesAZ/flickr/CC-BY-NC 2.0

The Native Americans of the old west often passed on several of their legends and beliefs to frontiersmen, and from that often spawned legends. One particularly ghostly tale has to do with a small bird, appropriately titled the Death Bird. Native Americans believed that before death, the bird would appear to either warn people and save their lives, or to tell them that it was too late and they might as well pick out a coffin. 

In the late 1800s, cowboys began to see this ghostly spirit bird as well, sometimes signifying that someone nearby was dying and needed help or that the cowboy himself was on a final roundup. Even if you didn't see it, supposedly you could hear it's unearthly, piercing call.  

The Ghost of Silver Heels


The Ghost of Silver Heels is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list Creepy Old West Ghost Stories and Legends
Photo: snake.eyes/flickr/CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0

Not all ghosts are necessarily scary, and Silver Heels is a legend that's more sad than frightening. In 1861, there was a dance hall girl in Buckskin Joe mining camp who was nicknamed Silver Heels. The miners loved her, showered her with gifts, and she was considered beautiful by all. But as with most beautiful things, her joyful dancing was not to last. 

One winter, small pox spread through the camp with force. Silver Heels stopped dancing and set to work helping the sick and tending to the dying. She even helped with burials. But after the worst of the sickness had passed, Silver Heels was nowhere to be found. Legend says that she at last fell sick with small pox, and her once beautiful face became scarred beyond recognition, so she hid from everyone until her death in shame. No one knows when she passed.

Some say that you can still see a ghostly veiled figure wandering the cemetery, putting flowers by gravestones. Even in death, Silver Heels still seeks to bring comfort to her miners.