17.2k voters

Oscar-Nominated Movies with Plot Holes You Can't Unsee

Updated January 19, 2021 82.4k votes 17.2k voters 897k views23 items

There’s an unspoken deal between filmmakers and spectators. Filmmakers ask that spectators accept films as make believe and know that in order to get lost in a film world they must agree to some level of suspension of disbelief. Seasoned spectators accept those terms in order to insert themselves into the world created by the filmmakers. However, there are limitations to that deal. Even though an audience is perfectly willing to accept things like a little boy that sees ghosts, or a teenager that can travel to the future in a DeLorean through a wormhole when it hits 88 mph - that doesn’t mean that an audience is willing to overlook parts of the plot that don’t add up. Here are the Oscar-nominated movies with plot holes you can’t un-see.

Yes, there are even plot holes in Academy Award nominated movies. The Matrix is one of the most innovative sci-fi films ever made and its introduction of bullet time technology and a mind-bending plot earned it four Academy Awards, but it’s far from perfect.

It’s easy for a spectator to accept the premise of a dystopian future in which machines hold the bodies of humans captive, while their minds are part of a simulated reality or dream world called the Matrix. But, we can’t ignore the giant plot hole that puts Cypher into the Matrix without the benefit of an operator or with someone there to plug him in. It goes against the narrative rules of the film that have been constructed for the audience, therefore it’s a plot hole that needs to be at the very least brought up for discussion. There are theories out there attempting to explain away this plot hole, but none truly satisfy all the rules previously established by the film.

The Matrix is just one Academy Award film that actually has a slew of plot holes. Check out these other plot holes in great movies and vote up the film plot holes that bother you the most.

  • 1

    Just Move To A Safer Place

    Photo: user uploaded image

    Film: The Quiet Place

    Nominated for sound editing, the John Krasinski-helmed horror pic created intense tension in its simple premise of noise-hating aliens invading Earth, killing off anyone who dares to eat a bag of chips. But it also created a weird plot hole.

    The movie establishes a loud, large waterfall as a safe place to talk since the noise is constant and ignored by the aliens. So why not just live near it? Especially if there will be a noisy newborn joining the group soon, why not live in the safe zone? 

    • Actors: John Krasinski, Emily Blunt, Millicent Simmonds, Noah Jupe
    • Released: 2018
    • Directed by: John Krasinski
    Is this plot hole unforgivable?
  • Film: Interstellar

    A lot has been made about the plethora of plot holes in Christopher Nolan's 2014 film, which received five Academy Award nominations and won for Best Visual Effects. Here's a big one that the entire narrative is based on: the earth is supposedly screwed as humans are losing the ability to grow crops because of a plague called Blight. However, it's shown that food can grow in space stations without issue. So why can't people just grow their food in a controlled green house set with the same parameters as the space station? That seems like it would be a lot easier than figuring out how to live on another planet.
    • Actors: Anne Hathaway, Matthew McConaughey, Matt Damon, Jessica Chastain, Michael Caine
    • Released: 2014
    • Directed by: Christopher Nolan
    Is this plot hole unforgivable?

    More Interstellar 

    #1149 of 1,195 Every Oscar Winning Film Ever#78 of 245 The Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time#49 of 549 The Greatest Epic Movies Ever Made

  • Photo: Face/Off

    Film: Face/Off

    John Woo's sci-fi thriller Face/Off was nominated for a Best Sound Effects Editing Oscar in 1998. An FBI agent (John Travolta) undergoes a face transplant so he can look look like a terrorist (Nic Cage) in order to stop an extortion plot. The bad guy then puts on the FBI agent's face and a classic game of switcheroo takes place. The gaping plot hole is that the two men have just switched faces, not bodies. It's hard to believe that the agent's wife doesn't realize that her husband has a completely different body.
    • Actors: John Travolta, Nicolas Cage, Gina Gershon, Margaret Cho, Thomas Jane
    • Released: 1997
    • Directed by: John Woo
    Is this plot hole unforgivable?

    More Face/Off 

    #256 of 1,506 The Most Rewatchable Movies#74 of 440 The Best Movies Of The 1990s#70 of 92 The Most Rewatchable Action Movies

  • 4

    Why Does Buzz Freeze?

    Film: Toy Story

    In 1995, Disney/Pixar's Toy Story was nominated for best writing, best song for Randy Newman's "You've Got A Friend In Me," and best score. But despite all the accolades, there is still one glaring issue with the story and it has to do with Buzz Lightyear.

    In Toy Story, it is made clear that the toys will freeze if there is a person around who can witness their actions. It is a rule of toydom. However, since Buzz does not believe he is a toy, why does he abide by these rules?  Do space rangers have similar rules? 

    • Actors: Tom Hanks, Tim Allen, Annie Potts, Don Rickles, Wallace Shawn
    • Released: 1995
    • Directed by: John Lasseter
    Is this plot hole unforgivable?