Horror Movies That Should Have Won The Oscar For Best Picture  

Orrin Grey
4.5k votes 652 voters 12.9k views 15 items

List Rules Vote up the films that were definitely better than the movies that actually took home Best Picture.

Only two horror movies have won Best Picture at the Academy Awards: The Silence of the Lambs in 1992 and The Shape of Water in 2018. The best horror movies in cinematic history deserve to at least be considered for Best Picture. Some of the most legendary horror films, however, were not even well received when they were released. Stanley Kubrick's The Shining is held in high esteem in regard to his filmography, but critics were not impressed when it was initially released.  Jaws created the summer blockbuster and broke money-making records, but did not walk away with the title of Best Picture. 

Just because the Academy doesn't recognize horror films as often as drama and comedy doesn't mean there haven't been plenty of movies over the years that deserve the honor every bit as much as the film that ultimately won. Fortunately, streaming services like Shudder cost the fraction of a movie theater ticket at $4.99 a month and give horror and genre flicks the praise they deserve. 

Which horror movie do you wish had been recognized by the Academy for Best Picture? 

back to page 1
5 260 VOTES
King Kong is listed (or ranked) 5 on the list Horror Movies That Should Have Won The Oscar For Best Picture
Photo:  RKO Pictures

King Kong is as much an adventure movie as a monster movie. Its story was so brilliant that decades later, directors and producers are still making money off of the world's favorite giant gorilla. King Kong was ahead of its time both in its effects and its story telling. In fact, creator Merian C. Cooper originally wanted to produce a film where an actual gorilla fought an actual Komodo dragon. He intended to make this happen by bringing a gorilla from Africa to Komodo island in Indonesia. Unfortunately, the film was created at the beginning of the Great Depression, and Cooper could not get funding for such an expedition. 

That Year's Best PictureCavalcade

Released: 1933

Directed by: Merian C. Cooper, Ernest B. Schoedsack

More King Kong

#10 of 169 on The Greatest Classic Sci-Fi Movies #64 of 591 on The Greatest Disaster Movies of All Time #13 of 135 on The Scariest Animal Movies Ever Made #17 of 21 on Deleted Scenes That Would've Changed the Whole Movie

Did this movie deserve Best Picture?
see more on King Kong
Bride of Frankenstein is listed (or ranked) 6 on the list Horror Movies That Should Have Won The Oscar For Best Picture
Photo:  Universal Pictures

If any horror director deserves an Academy Award for Best Picture, it's James Whale. Whale is responsible for some of the greatest films in the canon of classic horror. His most popular film, however, is undoubtedly the 1931 adaptation of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. Frankenstein allowed audiences to visualize the drama that unfolded within Shelley's story, drama that challenged cultural repression of any living person regardless of social adaptability.

Although Frankenstein is a masterpiece, its sequel, The Bride of Frankenstein, is one of the first films to make audiences question if a second movie can be better than the firstThe Bride of Frankenstein is a provocative exploration of humanity, even in its most grotesque forms.

That Year's Best PictureMutiny on the Bounty

Released: 1935

Directed by: James Whale

More Bride of Frankenstein

#4 of 20 on The Best Horror Movies With Weddings, Ranked #31 of 100 on The Best Horror Movie Sequels #15 of 41 on Every Single Movie On Rotten Tomatoes With 100% Approval, Ranked #46 of 108 on The Best Halloween Movies for Kids

Did this movie deserve Best Picture?
see more on Bride of Frankenstein
7 317 VOTES
Pan's Labyrinth is listed (or ranked) 7 on the list Horror Movies That Should Have Won The Oscar For Best Picture
Photo:  Warner Bros.

Foreign language films seldom get nominated for Best Picture, and none has ever won the coveted award, but Guillermo del Toro's Pan's Labyrinth did walk away with three Oscars in 2007. While Del Toro eventually picked up Best Picture gold for his 2017 film The Shape of Water, this beautiful and unsettling fairy tale set during the aftermath of the Spanish Civil War could just as easily have been his magnum opus.

Nominated For: Best Foreign Language Film, Best Original Screenplay, Best Cinematography (Won), Best Production Design (Won), Best Makeup (Won), Best Original Score

That Year's Best Picture: The Departed

Released: 2006

Directed by: Guillermo del Toro

More Pan's Labyrinth

#63 of 588 on The Greatest Film Scores of All Time #52 of 166 on Live Action Films with the Best CGI Effects #49 of 111 on The Best Intelligent Horror Movies

Did this movie deserve Best Picture?
see more on Pan's Labyrinth
8 375 VOTES
Jaws is listed (or ranked) 8 on the list Horror Movies That Should Have Won The Oscar For Best Picture
Photo:  Universal Pictures

Jaws was the second horror film to ever receive a Best Picture nomination. It is one of the most beloved films of all time, and is widely credited with giving rise to the summer blockbuster. It was the first horror film to break $235 million in profits and earned more than its Best Picture competition.  

Nominated For: Best Picture, Best Film Editing (Won), Original Dramatic Score (Won), Best Sound (Won)

That Year's Best Picture: One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

Released: 1975

Directed by: Steven Spielberg

More Jaws

#16 of 334 on 'Old' Movies Every Young Person Needs To Watch In Their Lifetime #44 of 1714 on The Most Rewatchable Movies featuring Jaws Was Inspired By The Matawan Man-Eater, And The True Story Is Even Scarier Than The Movie Behind The Scenes Of Every Death In ‘Jaws’

Did this movie deserve Best Picture?
see more on Jaws