True Crime 13 Terrifying Shopping Mall Kidnappings  

Jacob Shelton
54.3k views 13 items

Malls are the one safe space where everyone in the world feels like they can relax, but it’s simply not true. While you’re letting your guard down in front of the Forever 21, someone is thinking about shoving you into the back of an unmarked SUV. People who were kidnapped at shopping malls don't often have happy endings. Either they ended up being chopped up into multiple pieces, or they spent years in forced prostitution. No one knows why the worst kidnappers choose malls as ground zero for stealing a person’s humanity, but crimes in shopping malls are definitely some of the scariest things that can happen.

People who were abducted at shopping malls don’t tend to walk away from the abduction with a positive outlook on capitalism; in fact, most of them don’t walk away at all. For whatever reason, people who were kidnapped from malls usually end up mutilated in some way. There’s probably a psychology dissertation that’s waiting to be written about the choice that a murderer makes to pick his victims out of a mall parking lot, but until that’s published, you’ll just have to read all the gory details that have been collected here for you. Even if these stories don’t turn you off of shopping at your local galleria forever, they should at least put you on guard. And you never know, they might even save your life. 

Toddler James Bulger Was Kidnapped and Murdered by Two Ten-Year-Old Boys
Toddler James Bulger Was Kidna... is listed (or ranked) 1 on the list 13 Terrifying Shopping Mall Kidnappings
Photo: via YouTube

In 1993, James Bulger, a two-year-old boy, was abducted from a shopping mall in Bootle, England, by two ten-year-old boys. The two kidnappers led James on a two-and-a-half mile walk across Liverpool to the Leeds and Liverpool Canal, where they pushed him into a ravine head first. They then took James to a rarely used railway station where they tortured him by shoving batteries into his mouth, hitting him with rocks, and finally weighing him down on the railroad tracks in hopes of making his death seem like an accident. When James body was found it had been sliced in half by a train

Teen Sisters Planned to Kidnap and Molest a Toddler
Teen Sisters Planned to Kidnap... is listed (or ranked) 2 on the list 13 Terrifying Shopping Mall Kidnappings
Photo: Stephen Downes/flickr/CC-BY-NC 2.0

Who's the worst? Teenagers are the worst. A pair of teenage sisters from Tyneside, England, were arrested in 2016 for shoplifting, kidnapping, and intention of committing a sexual offense after they tried to steal a toddler from a Primark. According to the Inquistr, the girls specifically wanted to steal a black baby, and when they attempted to kidnap the little girl, they also stole baby milk and a bottle. After the teens kidnapped the toddler, it took only about 45 minutes for them to be tracked down. After their arrest, police took a look at their computers and found that their search history held things like "poor little thing getting kidnapped and raped" and "African woman sexual activity."

Two Sisters Were Kidnapped from a Maryland Mall and Never Seen Again
Two Sisters Were Kidnapped fro... is listed (or ranked) 3 on the list 13 Terrifying Shopping Mall Kidnappings
Photo: via YouTube

In 1975, Katherine and Sheila Lyon disappeared on a trip to a Maryland mall where they had gone to see the Easter exhibits. Multiple people saw them out together, and the girls were from such a prominent family that the police began an investigation on the same night that they disappeared. Even though a huge search party was put together, and multiple leads were investigated, the bodies of the girls were never found. It wasn't until 2013 that investigators got a break in the case when they discovered that Lloyd Lee Welch, a man who was serving a prison sentence for child sexual abuse, had probably committed the crime. One of his relatives even told the police that he had helped bury two bloody duffel bags in Bedford County, Virginia.

A Grieving Mother Stole a Baby from King of Prussia Mall
A Grieving Mother Stole a Baby... is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list 13 Terrifying Shopping Mall Kidnappings
Photo: rowens27/flickr/CC-BY-ND 2.0

There's nothing more frightening than losing your child, but having to watch it play back on video may be an even worse torture. At the King of Prussia Mall in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, in 2016, Cherie Amoore befriended Malika Hunter, a mother who was shopping with her seven-week-old baby and her toddler. The two women stopped and had a bite at the food court when Cherie grabbed the baby and booked it. After she was apprehended, Amoore (who had lost her own newborn son a month before) told local police, 

I don’t know why I did it. I can’t explain it. I held him, and all those feelings rushed back. I just wanted my baby. I felt like I was holding my son again. It felt so good. I didn’t want to lose that feeling. I was crazy. I never intended to do anything like this.

Happily, the infant was recovered unharmed.