All People's Sexiest Man Alive Covers, Ranked By Current Sexiness Standards 

Mel Judson
Updated November 5, 2019 162.9k votes 10.8k voters 121.2k views 32 items

List Rules Vote up the fellas whose sex appeal holds up to contemporary standards of male hotness, and vote down the guys who may have been the sexiest man alive at the time, but couldn't bring the smolder if they time-traveled to today.

For decades, People magazine has anointed a Sexiest Man Alive, crowning a handsome man with that enviable title and putting his beautiful mug on the cover, allowing less beautiful men and women to marvel at them in supermarket checkout lines around the world. The annual celebration of the hottest man among the hottest male celebrties kicked off in 1985 with Mel Gibson.

Sexiest Men Alive selections since have changed along with shifting perceptions of male sexiness, through hunks (mostly actors) as varied as Denzel Washington, Chris Hemsworth, Mark Harmon, Idris Elba, Nick Nolte, and Sean Connery. A few fellas have even snagged the coveted title repeatedly, and one received it retroactively - after People skipped the holy christening of a Sexiest Man Alive in 1994, the title was retroactively applied to Keanu Reeves in 2015.

The covers of these issues function as more than dated thirst traps; they work as time capsules for the year they were published, reflecting what People and, by extension, actual people considered sexy at the time. As such, they provide an opportunity to examine how the tastes and trends of bygone ages hold up to contemporary scrutiny, highlighting how our collective taste in beefcakes changes over the years.

Does 1989 winner Sean Connery's mustache still light passionate fires in the 21st century? Does Brad Pitt's buttermilk hair-and-soul-patch combo still make the 1995 cover a veritable thirst trap? Vote with your hearts, according to the enduring sexiness of each Sexiest Man Alive cover.

Idris Elba is listed (or ranked) 4 on the list All People's Sexiest Man Alive Covers, Ranked By Current Sexiness Standards
Photo:  People

Age: 46

Birthplace: London Borough of Hackney, London, United Kingdom

Is he still hot?

More Idris Elba 

15 Facts About Idris Elba That Will Make You Even Thirstier #34 of 276 The Best (Male) Actors Working Today #89 of 310 The Coolest Actors Ever